Free ornament or disciplined geometry?

The artist in the workshop designs a new mosque wall. Two roads: free vegetal ornament flowing as life flows, never repeating, or star-and-polygon geometry disciplined by measures, repeating to infinity? The decision: freedom of the hand or order of the mind?

The positions

the free hand

the leaf and frond grow as life grows, without bound

The evidence

the arabesque covered walls and doors in every era

Sources: exhibit/pathway-g11-hrt3m-islamic-art-architecturebuilding/alhambra

the geometers

the stars' order mirrors the universe's order; the pattern never fails

The evidence

the geometric stars generated patterns beyond counting

Sources: exhibit/pathway-g11-hrt3m-islamic-art-architectureconcept/islamic-calligraphy

You decide

Which road would have guided your hand? Write your reason.

Saved on this device