Al-Hadi gives retaliation for a slave's blows and answers an extra lash

قصاص الهادي لضربات الغلام والسوط الزائد في الجلد

Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah tells that he was sitting with al-Hadi when a man complained of a slave called Rizq who had struck him four blows; al-Hadi had the slave brought, heard that the man had taken the slave's knife and not returned it, and when the slave admitted he had been wrong, ordered four blows on his back as retaliation and twenty strokes of a staff as correction. A second report tells of two men struck for wine, one of whom the flogger gave an extra lash, so al-Hadi ordered ten dirhams for the man struck.

DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.

Depth

At a glance

Era
Abbasid Fragmentation
Region
Arabia

Politics, governance and authority

Overview

Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah tells his son Ali ibn Muhammad two reports about Yahya ibn al-Husayn: retaliation for a man struck by his slave, and amends for an extra lash in a wine penalty. Both are Zaydi, in the voice of the imam's followers; the manuscript margin carries the heading "the rule on the flogger adding to the flogging". 1

The slave Rizq

He said: I was sitting with him one day when a man came seeking redress against a slave called Rizq; the man said, "May I be your ransom, my slave struck me," and bared his back, where there were four blows. 2 Al-Hadi said, "Bring him." A group went and brought the slave, and al-Hadi asked what had led him to strike this man; he said the man had taken a knife of his and he had asked for it back and it was not handed over. 2 1 Al-Hadi asked, "Then why did you strike him?" and kept questioning him until the slave admitted, "I struck him and I was wrong." 1 He ordered the slave struck four blows on the back as retaliation for the man's beating, and twenty strokes of a staff as correction, and said, "By God, had my son Muhammad or my father struck him, I would have exacted retaliation from him." 1

The extra lash

Two men were brought to Yahya ibn al-Husayn one day with testimony that they had drunk wine; he ordered them struck, and the flogger was harder on one of them by an extra lash. Yahya told him, "Had I known you meant the extra, I would have struck you," and then ordered ten dirhams for the man struck because of the extra lash. 1 A second manuscript reads "for the one flogged" where the first has "for the one struck". 1

Notes

These are reports of the imam's judging as their narrator tells them; the text compares them with nothing, and gives no day or place. For the general legal subject see Fixed penalties (hudud).

Connections

Explore the connections

Had participant
Yahya al-Hadi al-Rassi· Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah al-Abbasi· Ali ibn Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah al-Abbasi al-Alawi
Related to
Fixed penalties (hudud)

People and things also explored

More reports on the wine penalty, from al-Kufi and Ibn Abi Hisham· Al-Hadi applies the penalty for wine and corrects others, as Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah tells it· Al-Hadi leaves Sa'da for Khaywan and meets al-Da'am at al-Amshiyya, Muharram 288 AH· Al-Hadi's march from Sa'da to Najran on the second of Dhu al-Hijja and his camp at the fortress, 286 AH· Al-Hadi reconciles Khawlan and Banu Salman at Madhab, and the shade of the cloud, Jumada II 286 AH· Ali ibn Muhammad reaches Sa'da with the pilgrims, finds his father governor there, and the Tabari emigrants arrive, Dhu al-Hijja 285 AH· Banu al-Harith swear against Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah in Jumada I 292 AH and the opening of al-Hadi's letter to them, p. 275· The evening fight between Banu Sa'd and the Akilis at Sa'da, 286 AH

Sources

  1. Sirat al-Imam al-Hadi ila al-Haqq Yahya ibn al-Husayn — Ali ibn Muhammad al-Abbasi al-Alawi , p.121
  2. Sirat al-Imam al-Hadi ila al-Haqq Yahya ibn al-Husayn — Ali ibn Muhammad al-Abbasi al-Alawi , p.120
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “Al-Hadi gives retaliation for a slave's blows and answers an extra lash”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/event/al-hadi-retaliation-for-a-slaves-blows-and-the-extra-lash-286/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-14.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Time

Eras, timelines, this day in history, any year in the Islamic world.
Related

More reports on the wine penalty, from al-Kufi and Ibn Abi Hisham

Ali ibn Muhammad relays further reports on the wine penalty from Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Sulayman al-Kufi, from Muhammad ibn Abi Hisham and from his father: a frail man given three whips bound together, a woman who begged mercy for the sake of Ali ibn Abi Talib and was told the penalty belongs to God, a saying of al-Hadi about taking what is due even from his grandfather al-Qasim ibn Ibrahim, and two men in whose house wine was found, struck sixty each.