The deathbed of Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, his instruction about his grave, and the differing reports of where he died

Time People

احتضار أبي موسى الأشعري ووصيته في حفر قبره واختلاف موضع وفاته

Mecca → Kufa

When death came to Abu Musa al-Ash'ari he called his young men and told them to dig his grave wide and deep, saying it would be one of two places: either it would be widened and he would see his place in Paradise, or it would be narrowed and he would see chains and fetters 1. According to Abu Burda he told his sons to remember the man of the loaf, and told the story of the worshipper whose loaf outweighed his years 1. Where he died is disputed, Mecca in one account and al-Thawiyya, two miles from Kufa, in another, and the year ranges from 42 to 52 2.

DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.

Depth

At a glance

In space

MeccaKufa

Map: Natural Earth, public domain · places and route from the graph

Summary

Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, Abd Allah ibn Qays, was among the reciters and jurists of the Companions, and according to Ibn Kathir had the finest voice of the Companions in his day. 2 The account of his death centres on his instruction to dig his grave wide and deep and what he said about the two possible outcomes, his advice to his sons to remember the man of the loaf, and the historians' disagreement about the place of his grave and the year of his death.

Background

Ibn Kathir quotes al-Sha'bi that Umar wrote in his will that no governor should be kept more than a year except Abu Musa, who should be kept four years. 2 He describes him as short, slight and beardless. 2

His instruction to dig his grave

Sifat al-Safwa relates from al-Dahhak ibn Abd al-Rahman ibn Arzab that Abu Musa called his young men when death came to him and said: go and dig, and make it wide and deep. They came back and said: we have dug it, wide and deep. He said: by God, it will be one of two stations: either my grave will be widened until each corner of it is forty cubits and a door to Paradise will be opened for me, so that I look upon my wives and my dwellings and what God has prepared for me of honour, and its fragrance and ease reach me until I am raised; or it will be the other, and we seek God's refuge from it, and my grave will be narrowed until I am tighter than a spear in its socket, and a door of Hell will be opened and I will look upon my chains, fetters and companions, and its blasts and boiling water reach me until I am raised. 1

His counsel to his sons: the man of the loaf

It relates from Abu Burda that when death came to Abu Musa he said: my sons, remember the man of the loaf. The story is of a man who worshipped in his cell, the narrator thinks for seventy years, coming down only one day; Satan made a woman appear to him and he was with her seven days or nights; then the veil was lifted from him and he went out repenting, praying and prostrating at every step, until night found him at a bench with twelve poor men on it. Exhaustion overtook him and he threw himself between two of them. A monk used to send them loaves each night and gave each person one; the penitent was left out, and the man beside him gave him his own loaf, and in the morning the penitent was dead. The seventy years were weighed against the seven nights and the nights outweighed them; then the loaf was weighed against the seven nights and the loaf outweighed. And Abu Musa said: my sons, remember the man of the loaf. 1 The second copy of Sifat al-Safwa gives the same report and ending. 3

His death and grave

Sifat al-Safwa says: the biographers say Abu Musa died in 52, or 42, or 44, and was buried at Mecca; it is also said he was buried at al-Thawiyya, two miles from Kufa. 1 Ibn Kathir says Ibn al-Jawzi, in al-Muntazam, recorded his death in this year (52), which is one view; another puts it a year earlier, another in 42, and others differently. His death was at Mecca, when he withdrew from people after the arbitration, or, it is said, at a place called al-Thawiyya two miles from Kufa. 2

Where the reports differ

Al-Dhahabi gives, from al-Haytham ibn Adi in Ibn Sa'd's report, that Abu Musa became Muslim at Mecca, emigrated to Abyssinia, that his first campaign was Khaybar, and that he died in 42. 4 So there are several opinions on the place of the grave, Mecca or al-Thawiyya, and on the year, 42, 44 or 52. The books read do not say what Abu Musa left or who washed him or prayed over him.

Sources and documentation

The card rests on Ibn al-Jawzi's Sifat al-safwa in al-Tartusi's abridgement, Ibn Kathir's al-Bidaya wa-l-nihaya and al-Dhahabi's Siyar a'lam al-nubala'. Page numbers are scan pages as read. The books read give no detailed account of his illness beyond the above, so this record is shorter than the others.

Connections

Explore the connections

Had participant
Abu Musa al-Ashari
Occurred at
Mecca· Kufa

People and things also explored

Ibn 'Asakir's hajj and hearings at Mecca and Kufa on the way back, 521/1127· Abdullah ibn Mas'ud· Abu Amr ibn al-Ala'· Ahmad ibn Hanbal· Asbat ibn Muhammad· Hashim ibn Utba al-Mirqal· Sa'd ibn Abi Waqqas· Sufyan ibn Uyayna

Sources

  1. Sifat al-Safwa — Ibn al-Jawzi (ed. Khalid Mustafa Tartusi, Dar al-Kitab al-Arabi, Beirut 1433/2012) , scan vol. 1 p. 203
  2. al-Bidaya wa-l-Nihaya — Ibn Kathir , scan vol. 4 p. 425
  3. Sifat al-Safwa — Ibn al-Jawzi (ed. Khalid Mustafa Tartusi, Dar al-Kitab al-Arabi, Beirut 1433/2012) , scan vol. 4 p. 221
  4. Siyar A'lam al-Nubala' — al-Dhahabi (Dar al-Risala al-Alamiyya edition) , scan vol. 3 p. 278
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “The deathbed of Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, his instruction about his grave, and the differing reports of where he died”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/event/deathbed-of-abu-musa-al-ashari/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-16.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Time

Eras, timelines, this day in history, any year in the Islamic world.
Related

Ibn 'Asakir's hajj and hearings at Mecca and Kufa on the way back, 521/1127

In 521 Ibn 'Asakir made the pilgrimage; at Mecca he heard 'Abdallah ibn Muhammad ibn al-Ghazzal al-Misri, pupil of Karima al-Marwaziyya, and at Kufa he heard 'Umar ibn Ibrahim al-'Alawi; he passed some time at Mecca and Medina and stopped at Kufa on his way back to Baghdad.