Debates explorer
Munazarat Browser
Every mention of debates and disputation in the museum's sources: the Qur'an's arguments — Ibrahim with his people and Nimrod, Musa before Pharaoh, the mubahala verse, «argue with them in the best manner» — the debates of the Prophet, the Companions and the Successors with Jews, Christians and polytheists, Ibn Abbas's debate with the Khawarij at Harura, the scholars' disputations in councils and courts, and the modern debates — sourced records that grow as new texts land.
This build holds 495 records in 5 sections; the texts are drafts until a human reads them.
The browser's method
Every record here is an ordinary museum record — with its sources and its three-language prose. Debates are found at build time by a guarded detector over the passage texts — the dispute verbs (ناظر، تناظر، جادل، حاجّ، احتج، باهل، حاور، اختصم), the genre nouns (مناظرة، جدال، محاجّة، مباهلة) and named-episode anchors («نصارى نجران» with the mubahala, «حروراء» with Ibn Abbas and the Khawarij, «النجاشي» with Ja'far and Amr ibn al-As); the fiqh li'an oath, the «جديلة» braid, حَجّ the pilgrimage, «احتاج» the needing and the «ناظر» viewer sense stay out, verified false positives are excluded by id, and every book harvested later brings its debates here automatically once its passages land in the graph; curated records join through the munazarat-browser tag. Each passage is marked debate when it carries an actual exchange and mention when it is only about disputation, and opponent chips class the debate as with the scriptuaries, the polytheists, inside the ummah or other.
The whole set is available at /api/v1/munazarat.json
DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.
The browser's sections
In the Sunnah
What the two Sahihs, the Muwatta and the Sunan carry of disputation: the Jews taking the Prophet's hand to the Torah, their questions about the Spirit, the Cave sleepers and Dhu al-Qarnayn, and the Companions' debates after him — every report with its source and numbering.
- Ahmad ibn Hanbal's Kitab al-Zuhd, scan volume 3, p. 236 — a deathbed and last hours; a burial, grave or resting place
Kitab al-Zuhd of Ahmad ibn Hanbal · 3:236 · About debating · Other
… اللّٰه والحمد لله ولا إله إلا اللّه واللّه أكبر. حدثنا عبداللّه حدثنا أبي حدثنا حجاج حدثنا ليث حدثي عقيل عن ابن شهاب أن سعد بن أبي وقاص لما حضره الموت دعا بخاق جبة له صوف فقال كفنوني فيها زإني كنت …
No matches.