Is 'the astrologers lie even when truthful' a hadith?

By Nazir Ayyad

مدى صحة مقولة كذب المنجمون ولو صدقوا

A questioner asked about the soundness of the saying on people's tongues, 'the astrologers lie even when they speak truth.' Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21084) answered that it is not among the noble prophetic hadiths, though its meaning is sound — as the answer details.

Depth

At a glance

This entry is a record so far, without an article. The facts and connections below come from the museum's data.

Connections

Explore the connections

About
Hadith methodology (mustalah al-hadith)· Creed and law (aqida and shari'a)

People and things also explored

The good report (hasan)· The obscured (mu'dal) and the interrupted (munqati') report· The defective hadith (mu'allal) and the science of hidden defects· The suspended report (mu'allaq)· The objectionable report (munkar)· The loosely attributed report (mursal)· Hadith· The sound report (sahih)

Sources

  • Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (dar-alifta.org)

Original page

Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “Is 'the astrologers lie even when truthful' a hadith?”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/work/fatwa-dar-alifta-eg-astrologers-lie-hadith-authenticity/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-17.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Words

Qur'an, hadith, poetry, and the languages and scripts of Muslim peoples.
Related

The good report (hasan)

For Ibn Hajar the report good in itself (hasan li-dhatihi) meets all the conditions of the sound report except that its narrator's accuracy is lighter; it shares with the sound report in serving as proof, though below it; the report good through another (hasan li-ghayrihi) is one on which judgement is suspended until an indication tips it toward acceptance, as with an obscure narrator's report with several chains; he explains al-Tirmidhi's 'hasan sahih' as hesitation over a lone narrator or as two chains, and holds that al-Tirmidhi's definition of hasan covers only what he calls simply 'hasan'.