IIFA draft resolution 223 (23/7) on the physician's liability for unintentional medical errors from an Islamic perspective

قرار مجمع الفقه الإسلامي الدولي 223 (23/7) بشأن مسؤولية الطبيب عن الأخطاء الطبية غير العمدية من منظور إسلامي

A collective draft resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 23rd session in Medina (19–23 Safar 1440, 28 October – 1 November 2018), after reviewing the resolutions of the scholarly conference of the Islamic Organisation for Medical Sciences in Kuwait (5–7 Jumada II 1436, 26–28 March 2015). It adopted the definitions: medical error as failure to complete a planned act as intended, through negligence, shortcoming or the like; medical incident as an injury arising from medical intervention not attributable to the patient's underlying health conditions; institutional incidents as those arising from the coincidence of error-causing factors at several levels together with causes inside the health system; and the principles of the health profession as the established bases and scientifically and practically recognised rules. Its decisions include: developing scholarly programmes on the causes of errors to reduce them; preparing suitable internal and external conditions for health care; making patient safety the central axis of all health policies; training and awareness workshops for health workers; providing equipment, laboratories and information and adhering to international work protocols for accurate diagnosis; limiting the medical staff's working day to eight hours, especially on night shifts, to preserve the physician's focus; reducing the number of patients per physician; periodically reviewing all laws and decisions on safety guarantees; periodic maintenance of medical devices by experts; establishing a supreme body for medical errors under the competent minister to investigate incidents promptly before their traces vanish and report with recommendations; encouraging erring physicians to disclose errors and finding a legal means of leniency; protecting those who report errors; creating a medical-error information bank run by a committee of physicians, jurists and lawyers with mandatory reporting by health-ministry bodies; assessing a staff member responsible for grave errors; registering and monitoring medicines, especially dangerous ones, for side effects and interactions; public awareness to change society's view of fallibility in medical practice; and introducing an electronic barcode card for every person for use in all health transactions.

Depth

At a glance

This entry is a record so far, without an article. The facts and connections below come from the museum's data.

Connections

Explore the connections

About
Medical treatment (al-mu'alaja)· Al-kharaj bil-daman (yield follows liability)

People and things also explored

The poultices and compresses of pleurisy· Simple and compound drugs (al-adwiya al-mufrada wal-murakkaba)· The resolvent drugs for the toothaches· The numbing drugs for the teeth· The chest drugs· The dental drugs· Venesection, or bloodletting (al-fasd)· Surgery, the work of the hand (al-jiraha)

Sources

  • International Islamic Fiqh Academy

Original page

Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “IIFA draft resolution 223 (23/7) on the physician's liability for unintentional medical errors from an Islamic perspective”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/work/fatwa-iifa-223-physician-liability-medical-errors/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-16.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Words

Qur'an, hadith, poetry, and the languages and scripts of Muslim peoples.
Related

The poultices and compresses of pleurisy

What makes expectoration abound: sleeping on the ailing side; a slight shaking may be needed, and giving him the water that tends to warmth in succession — very beneficial for him. Poultices and liniments may be used: the first that should be applied is a cerate of this kind, then the gradation goes to the fats, the mucilages and mill-dust, then to the stronger poultices of this kind, and if something stronger is needed the poultice made of the strongest of this kind is used. Know that if the matter is abundant, poultices and ointments are harmful; if scant, they do not harm — likewise when the tumour has dissolved and a residue remains; and if a beneficial evacuation by venesection has occurred, anointing is also permitted. A good poultice and a good liniment of this kind have been described; and among the poultices that join maturing with quieting the pain is a poultice of this kind. Moist and dry compresses may aid: the moist agree better with what tends to the erysipelas kind, the dry with what tends to the phlegmon kind — but the moist, if it does not benefit, does not harm, while the dry, if it harms, harms greatly. First to be preferred is the sponge soaked in hot water, stronger than that sea water and salt water, then beyond that, if needed, fomenting with steam or with a hot matter of this kind; and stronger still is what is made with vinegar and its like on wool steeped in oil; and among the light dry things, bran, then jawars, then salt. Fomentation and venesection resolve every high or low pain, unless the filling hinders by the fomentation's drawing; and venesection resolves the high pains more. When you poultice or foment, keep their vapour from the patient's face lest it stir in him distress and shortness of breath. The disease may be very dry — then the vapour of the poultice and the temperate moist compress benefits if it strikes the face and enters the inhaling. The lohochs they use may aid: the most fitting for the burned are of this kind. Once it is well cleansed, the cupping glasses, if set on the painful spot, show great benefit — they may quiet the pain altogether or draw it to the outer regions — and the mustard poultice, used on such a spot, does the cupping glasses' work in drawing. When it passes the seventh: the ancients used to order a lohoch of this kind and sometimes employed the great electuaries — a good road, taken by those true in the craft who trust themselves to notice and repair whatever this regimen may require and have the power over it, and by it they reach a cleansing that heals; while the modern cowards, who do not trust themselves in it, fear the honey and put sugar in its place. The ancients also used to direct strongly cleansing drugs prepared with honey as pills held under the tongue, and to direct at this time the poultices named 'the scented' and the oils of this kind. In sum, whoever walks this path of the ancients must walk it with care, caution and the fear of bursting a tumour or stirring much heat — then he may afterward trust in a quick success. If the disease lasts to the fourteenth, cupping on the nape is then indispensable. If sleeplessness grows severe on them, a syrup of this kind is indispensable; if the breath runs frequent on them, its harm is repaired only by moistening with a mucilage of this kind, sipped little by little with a julep. Sprinkling the side with tepid water may benefit in lightening the pain and lessening the frequency of breath — though it is harmful, as you have learned. After the evident decline the bath is used; strong cooling is shunned, except in what is of the erysipelas kind, and likewise the thickening regimen is shunned and sufficiency made with thinning; a thing of this kind is cooked in the waters and drinks mentioned, at their end, and they lick a seed of this kind with honey. If the tumour resists and turns toward gathering, the regimen we name in its own chapter is used