Al-Battani on the year counted by the return to a fixed star

رد البتاني ما قيل في السنة بالعودة إلى كوكب ثابت

In chapter 27 al-Battani reports that earlier astronomers disagreed on the length of the year; some ancient Egyptians and Babylonians gave it as three hundred and sixty-five days, a quarter, and a part of a hundred and twenty of a day, counting it from the Sun's leaving a fixed star until it returns to it, and he reports Ptolemy's judgement that this view is extremely weak 1.

DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.

Depth

At a glance

Astronomy and timekeepingMathematics

Summary

In chapter 27 al-Battani reports that earlier astronomers disagreed on the length of the year; some ancient Egyptians and Babylonians gave it as three hundred and sixty-five days, a quarter, and a part of a hundred and twenty of a day, counting it from the Sun's leaving a fixed star until it returns to it, and he reports Ptolemy's judgement that this view is extremely weak 1.

Ptolemy's argument

As reported by al-Battani, Ptolemy said that if this view were allowed, one could equally say that the year is the Sun's leaving Saturn or another wandering planet until it returns to it, and that is a view plainly false. The argument is one of parity: if the measure is a body that itself moves, the measure moves with it 1. The definition of the year that stands against this view is in the year between returns to an equinox or solstice point. The passage shows al-Battani using Ptolemy and the Almagest as the authority on which his own observation is built 1.

Connections

Explore the connections

Part of
al-Zij al-Sabi (The Sabian Zij)

People and things also explored

Zij (astronomical handbook with tables)· The test whether a degree lies above or below the earth· The Almagest catalogue of 1,022 stars in forty-five figures· The altitude from the hours of the day that have passed· The altitude of a star at midheaven from its distance from the equator· The altitude of a star from the night hours· The rising amplitude from the latitude· Summer and winter risings from the longest day, and for any degree

Sources

  1. al-Zij al-Sabi, ed. Carlo Nallino (Byblion, Jbeil, 2005) , p.65
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “Al-Battani on the year counted by the return to a fixed star”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/concept/zij-sabi-year-ancients-fixed-star-return-rejected/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-14.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Ideas

Beliefs, concepts, sciences and schools, explained in plain words.
Related

Zij (astronomical handbook with tables)

Among the Arabs a zij is a book setting out higher spherical astronomy and the methods of celestial computation, with all the tables needed and usually without cosmographical rudiments; Europeans' rendering 'Tables' is inexact, a single table being a jadwal, named for the likeness of its columns to water channels.