Fatwas on Prophetic adab (proper conduct) 25 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
- He almost uttered an ill word in anger but held his tongue
A questioner who was so angered he nearly uttered an ill word but caught his tongue asked whether he must repeat the testimony. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78017, 28 February 2009) answered with the Prophet's counsel — do not be angry — thanking God the matter never passed inner thought, his tongue held; God has pardoned this ummah what their selves whisper so long as it is not done or spoken; he should seek forgiveness and renew his resolve to uprightness away from anger's provocations.
- The Ash'aris and the manners of creedal disagreement
A questioner asked AMJA's view of the creed of the Ash'aris — the great majority of the people of the sunna and the community — and of those who attack it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81577, 30 May 2010) answered that transgression is unlawful whether against this creed or any other — by justice the heavens and earth stand; the Ash'aris got some things right and erred in others, and matters are discussed among their people on their merits, within mutual counsel, with proofs and scholarly arguments and far from the atmosphere of trading accusations and abuse. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Cursing lifeless things
A questioner asked the ruling on cursing lifeless things. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82312, 24 August 2010) answered that the Muslim is not a reviler, a curser, obscene or foul-mouthed; no living thing or lifeless object should be cursed except where a text has come cursing it — such as the unmarked cursing of wrongdoers generally, as in 'God's curse be upon the unjust' or 'the liars', and the like.
- Do animals have souls or only life
A questioner asked whether creatures — big fish and tiny ones, the butterfly, the ant, the worm — have souls or merely life. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80536, 27 November 2009) declined the speculative question, counselling him to occupy himself with what benefits him and touches his need in worshipping his Lord, and to spare the muftis' time for questions that constitute scholarly rescue. Recorded as a deferral, not a ruling.
- The phrase 'may God not change us'
A questioner objected to the phrase 'may God not change our state', common on the tongues of those who profit from a regime or condition without regard to others. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81482, 16 May 2010) answered that his zeal and desire to relieve the distressed and reform affairs is appreciated, but his reading is one of two interpretations: the phrase also bears another — an invocation for blessings to last and not vanish, and for success in the obedience that keeps blessing and well-being — like the transmitted prayers seeking refuge from sudden wrath, the turning of well-being and the removal of blessing, per 'that is because God never changes a favour He bestowed on a people until they change what is in themselves'; and the default is to carry a Muslim's words on their best sense.
- Good intercession in worldly petitions
A questioner cited a study on intercession's rulings listing examples of good intercession today — recommendations for university admission, charitable funding or public posts. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86533, 6 March 2012) answered they had not read the study, but the examples have a sound interpretation: some Islamic universities, charities and public offices require letters of recommendation so the authority makes the right decision and invests in the right place — nothing objectionable in that, and whoever intercedes properly we hope is rewarded, per 'whoever intercedes a good intercession has a share of it' and 'intercede and you will be rewarded'. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- What hair is shaved or plucked — the fitra's rules
A questioner asked what hair must be shaved and what plucked, for man and woman. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23020, 20 May 2008) answered that among the fitra's ways for men and women together are plucking the armpit and shaving the pubes; forbidden for both is plucking — the eyebrows or a woman's facial hair — and forbidden the man is shaving his beard — as the answer details.
- The left hand for cleansing — why the right is spared
A questioner asked whether the private parts are washed with the left or right hand after relieving oneself. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80297, 20 October 2009) answered that the rule is using the left hand to cleanse the place of urine, stool and the like, the prohibition on using the right here being established; part of the wisdom is the right's honor — it being for the nobler doings — so it is not put to removing filth, as the answer details.
- A woman is married for four things — the hadith explained
A man about to marry asked for a detailed explanation of 'a woman is married for four things'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78315, 22 March 2009) answered that the hadith is in Bukhari, Muslim and the Sunan: people's custom runs to seeking a woman in marriage for one of four traits — beauty, wealth, lineage and religion — and what befits people of honour and religion is that religion be the aim of their regard; so the Prophet urged winning the religious one and stressed it most emphatically in 'win her of religion, may your hands be dusty' — originally 'your hands stick to dust' from poverty, but the Arabs use it for reproach, emphasis and urging, as detailed.
- Ordinary istibra — no straining the self
A questioner described straining hard to istibra after urinating. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21955, 16 September 2007) answered that he should not strain himself — lest he make worshipping his Lord hateful to his soul and bring it bodily and mental illnesses; he suffices with the ordinary istibra at which the urine's ceasing prevails in his suspicion — as the answer details.
- Attending a brother's wedding in a mixed hall
A veiled young woman asked whether she may attend her brother's wedding in a mixed hall possibly holding objectionable things. Dr. Walid ibn Idris al-Munaysi (fatwa no. 1873, 8 December 2006) answered that men and women gathering in one place is not forbidden so long as no seclusion occurs between a single man and a single unrelated woman with no third in a closed room, and so long as the gathering does not lead to forbidden acts such as women's display and soft speech or whatever stirs temptation; if the party is free of objectionables there is no legal bar to attending even mixed, and if some objectionables are present, attending with the intention of advising and inviting them is governed by intentions — with a caution to be careful.
- Naming a child with one of God's names
A questioner asked the ruling on naming a child with one of God's beautiful names such as Ahad, and whether a forbidden name must be changed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81904, 19 July 2010) answered that naming with a name God kept for Himself — like al-Rahman or al-Khaliq — is not permissible; the Prophet changed such names when they occurred, turning al-Jabbar into Abd al-Jabbar and al-Hakam into Abdullah, and in the Quran stands 'do you know of any namesake for Him' — no equal deserving such a name. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Protesting a speaker, by what is good
A questioner asked about what Muslim students did during a lecture by the Israeli ambassador Michael Oren at UC Irvine. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81116, 9 March 2010) answered that enjoining good must itself be good and denouncing wrong should not be done with wrong; dawa may be harmed by what he described more than it benefits; these societies have their own channels for conveying a message and registering protest, and stepping outside them puts the actors in the circle of aberrance and notoriety in the public sense of the very people they want to reach — he hoped they would review themselves, consult one another on what is right, and correct their standing for the next round. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Regret over a small slip, and seeking forgiveness
A questioner disliked licking food off his fingers though knowing it is recommended, having thought it applied only when food fell on the finger — and feared that was dislike of a sunna. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78103, 6 March 2009) answered that the measure is the endings, and God had opened his chest in the end — he hopes his earlier state is forgiven; whenever unease stirs in his breast he should hasten to seek forgiveness, sure that his Lord is vast in forgiveness.
- Blessing a sneezing non-Muslim
A questioner asked whether one may bless a sneezing non-Muslim with their customary phrases like 'Bless you' in America, which contain no prayer for mercy or forgiveness. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23201, 24 June 2008) answered that Abu Dawud narrated — al-Hakim grading it sound — Abu Musa al-Ash'ari's report that the Jews used to sneeze before the Prophet hoping he would say 'God have mercy on you', and he would say 'God guide you and mend your state'; Ibn Daqiq al-Id noted that those who make tashmit a prayer of good bring the disbelievers into the command's generality, while those limiting it to mercy do not; and Ibn Hajar held that legally Abu Musa's hadith shows they enter the general command to bless.
- Why does God not intervene at a crime
A questioner who saw a murdered woman and her little daughter driven mad by the sight asked why God did not intervene and spare the child, and whether a supplication wards off crime. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81607, 3 June 2010) answered that God created everything by measure and does what He wills — everyone among people wills what he cannot do or does what he does not will, but God alone does what He wills; He is not questioned about what He does, yet His acts are never sundered from His wisdom whether we grasp it or it escapes us; good is in His hands and evil is not attributed to Him, and it is not for anyone to say 'why did God not do such-and-such' — that is not courtesy with God. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Students standing up when the teacher enters
A question from a middle-school teacher whose pupils stand up for him out of respect when he enters the classroom without his asking them to, which he dislikes; Ibn Baz answered that standing up for a person who enters, by way of honouring him, is something the Sunna forbids: the Companions did not stand for the Prophet because they knew he disliked it, and the Prophet said that whoever likes people to stand up for him should take his seat in the Fire; so the pupils must not stand but keep their places and greet him, this kind of standing being at the least strongly disliked, and the teacher may neither like it nor order it, but must admonish and forbid them sincerely, for when they see he means it they will sit; the Ministry of Education and the General Presidency for Education should instruct schools accordingly, for boys and girls alike. He distinguished this from rising to meet and shake hands with the person, to seat him in one's place or to walk him out, which is unobjectionable, citing Talha ibn Ubaydallah rising to Ka'b ibn Malik when God accepted his repentance in the Prophet's presence, the Prophet's words to the Ansar 'stand up for your chief' when Sa'd ibn Mu'adh arrived, and Fatima rising to her father and he to her. He answered those who call the standing a way of alerting pupils that this is a satanic pretext, since his greeting alerts them, and advised one whose superior is angered by not being stood for to explain to him that it is not allowed and that the Messenger disliked it.
- Changing one's name to a better one
A questioner asked about changing one's name to a better one. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21556) answered that changing a name may be obligatory — if the name is peculiar to God, or otherwise unbefitting — and the answer sets out the cases.
- Resting the hand on the verse while reading the mushaf
A questioner asked about passing the hand over the verses while reading the Quran from the mushaf. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21555) answered that doing so to aid accurate reading and ease memorisation is permissible — as the answer details.
- The limits and controls of interaction between men and women
A questioner asked about the limits of interaction between a man and an unrelated woman. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20908) answered that the sharia took a middle path — not banning it entirely so people's interests are obstructed, nor leaving it unbounded — as the answer details.
- A man wearing a silver chain and braiding his hair
A questioner asked about a man wearing a silver chain and tying his hair in braids. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20910) answered that men wearing silver chains is disputed among the jurists; the Dar's view is that it is permitted — as the answer details.
- Answering a feast invitation for one returned from Hajj (the naqi'a)
A questioner asked about answering a neighbour's invitation to a meal for one returned from Hajj (the naqi'a). Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20838) answered that answering it is recommended — as kindness, kinship and sharing his joy — as the answer details.
- Reciting the Quran accompanied by music
A questioner asked about making clips of Quranic verses accompanied by kinds of music, listening to them or promoting them. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21581) answered by setting out the ruling.
- Selling carpets bearing the name of God
A questioner asked about selling carpets bearing the name of God that are spread and stepped upon. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21613) answered by affirming the duty of revering what God has exalted — Quranic words and divine names — and set out the ruling accordingly.
- Sharing food and drink from one vessel
A questioner asked about sharing food and drink from one vessel. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21037) answered that sharing a vessel is lawful provided it does not cause harm to health, and set out the case of one whose own cleanliness-need leads him to abstain.