Fatwas on Ikhtilaf (disagreement among jurists and its kinds) 9 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
The museum's record of Ikhtilaf (disagreement among jurists and its kinds)
- Blood donation and the wudu — the schools on copious blood
A questioner asked whether a blood donor must do wudu for the prayer or his wudu stands. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21947, 16 January 2007) answered that the two imams Abu Hanifa and Ahmad held copious blood breaks the wudu, while Shafi'i and Malik held it does not; the cautious course is doing wudu — as the answer details the weighing.
- Classifying dawa groups as deviant
A questioner put three questions about the Muslim Brotherhood, including whether it counts among the deviant groups. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87474, 21 September 2012) answered that it is not the Assembly's practice to discuss dawa groups and figures — it describes truth and falsehood and leaves the questioner to apply the criterion; a dawa collective is not a deviant faction unless it rallies around an innovated root principle contradicting what is fixed by Book, sunna and consensus, or around novel practices that dominate its striving, and they know no such thing of the Muslim Brotherhood, a dawa collective standing for the sharia's support and an Islamic state — it is not classed among those factions; if a branch in a given country is known for that, that branch alone bears the mark without the ruling spreading beyond it — and he answered the remaining questions as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Camel meat and the wudu — an ijtihad question
A questioner asked the decisive word on eating camel meat — does it break the wudu? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3206, 10 July 2007) answered that this is among the ijtihad questions admitting difference: the majority's madhhab holds camel meat does not break the wudu; the Hanbalis, and the Shafi'is in the old position, held it breaks it and wudu is required — chosen also by Ibn Khuzayma and Ibn Baz — as the answer details.
- Qunut in the Fajr prayer — an ijtihad matter not to be condemned
A questioner asked the ruling on qunut in Fajr and the soundness of following an imam who insists on it. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21987, 14 October 2012) answered that this is among ijtihad's questions in which the dissenter is not condemned, though people counsel one another with proofs; some imams of the followed schools did hold Fajr qunut — the answer detailing the ruling on following.
- Laxity in declaring sinfulness, heresy and disbelief
A questioner raised the spread of laxity in declaring others sinful, heretical or disbelievers over differences in questions where ijtihad is legitimate, splitting the Muslims. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81295, 12 April 2010) answered that ijtihad questions should be argued with proofs and scholarly evidence, without crowding the dissenter, and may not licence trading accusations and abuse.
- The call to Sunni–Shia rapprochement — its political and creed senses
A questioner — having read Shiite books with grave notions and the Sunni scholars' answers — asked what the callers to rapprochement base themselves on. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21855, 28 May 2007) answered that the call to taqrib is an ambiguous term: if it means rapprochement in the political frame and in the two sides' common interests, it is an acceptable call — indeed necessary to spare blood, secure the roads, and let people travel and dwell in their lands safely; it is the basis of settled security and flourishing lands, and by nature admits tact, tolerance and even the yielding of some claims if needed. But rapprochement in the creed-frame is impossible, the differences between the two doctrines being essential and not admitting fusion — as the answer details. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Declaring the Imamiyya's scholars disbelievers — the cautious line
A questioner asked whether it is true that 'our view of the Imamite Shia is that their ignorant are sinners and their scholars disbelievers'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3262, 22 July 2007) answered that declaring the Imamiyya's scholars disbelievers is disputed among scholars; the cautious course is to say: whoever is proven of himself to hold an unbelieving creed is a disbeliever for it — without pronouncing takfir over their scholars wholesale, such a saying being reckless. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Touching the member — a madhhab dispute, per Ibn Qudama
A questioner asked whether touching the member breaks wudu, citing Companions' positions. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21957, 5 November 2007) answered that the wudu's breaking on touching the member is among the scholars' disputed questions — many jurists have set out the difference; he transmits Ibn Qudama's words in al-Mughni, where the positions and Ahmad's narrations are given — as the answer details.
- Why the jurists differ — God's wisdom in the texts
A questioner asked for the reason jurists and hadith-scholars differ on questions. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21826, 11 April 2005) answered that their disagreement in many scholarly and practical matters has causes and wise purposes — had God willed, He could have made all the two revelations' texts admit but one reading; but in His mercy and wisdom He made some decisive and certain, representing the common faith-ground of the qibla-people, and some open to ijtihad, giving the ummah room, training its minds, and rewarding its effort.