Fatwas on Seeking knowledge 47 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of Seeking knowledge

  • What a seeker should do when no guiding shaykh can be found

    A question from a seeker who has long searched for a guiding shaykh to teach him the spiritual path and the religious sciences and has found none; Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that there is much good in the community and that scholars who train others never cease, so a student should search earnestly, ask after them and draw on their knowledge, and that one who finds no guiding and training shaykh should abundantly invoke blessings and peace on the Prophet while keeping to remembrance and worship and refraining from the forbidden, for this brings him to his goal on the journey to God. It quoted Imam Muhammad al-Sanusi that he had seen in the words of some masters of Sufism that whoever lacks training shaykhs should invoke blessings on the Prophet abundantly and will reach his goal by them, and Ahmad Zarruq in Qawa'id al-Tasawwuf (p. 86, rule 114) that remembrance is the charter of sainthood, with the saying of his shaykh Abu al-Abbas al-Hadrami to keep up remembrance and abundant blessings on the Prophet, these being a ladder, an ascent and a path to God when the seeker meets no guiding shaykh.

    Original page

  • The span between Adam and Muhammad

    A questioner noticed, reading the prophetic biographies, the span from Adam to Muhammad and asked about it. Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 21851, 13 November 2006) answered that no established proof exists in the prophetic biography for this span, nor decisive scientific facts — only differing theories; he counselled the questioner not to spend his time on such matters but to concentrate on what benefits his religion and his world.

    Original page

  • Unifying Muslim discourse in the Quranic tongue

    A questioner asked whether Muslims' discourse with one another may be unified in the tongue of the Quran rather than intermediary languages. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82485, 9 September 2010) answered that speaking Arabic is among Islam's rites and expressed his wish that it be the mother tongue on which all Muslims meet in speech on every land under every sky. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The book 'The Limit of Islam' — a reading caution

    A questioner asked for remarks on the book 'The Limit of Islam'. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21866, 3 September 2007) answered that they do not recommend reading it except to scholars and the clear-sighted among students — to expose the creed-errors in it that might deceive people. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Request for a study critiquing Darwin's theory

    A student asked for help preparing for an Australian university a documented study critiquing Darwin's theory by a Muslim scholar. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81759, 28 June 2010) answered that the request lies outside the Assembly's current concerns, and referred him to the International Commission on Scientific Signs in the Quran and Sunna, a body specialising in such questions. Recorded as a referral, not a ruling.

    Original page

  • Do animals have souls or only life

    A questioner asked whether creatures — big fish and tiny ones, the butterfly, the ant, the worm — have souls or merely life. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80536, 27 November 2009) declined the speculative question, counselling him to occupy himself with what benefits him and touches his need in worshipping his Lord, and to spare the muftis' time for questions that constitute scholarly rescue. Recorded as a deferral, not a ruling.

    Original page

  • A fateful exam and the duty to learn

    A student facing a decisive exam asked whether he must still learn obligatory knowledge, and asked the meaning of God's name, where intention sits in wudu, and the senses of knowledge, wisdom, power, hearing and sight among God's names. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78677, 28 April 2009) answered that when an issue befalls him he should refer it to a scholar he trusts in religion and learning and act on his fatwa — he need not follow one imam in all his choices; 'Allah' is the One hearts worship in love, hope, fear and desire who alone deserves worship; intention accompanies wudu's acts — entering upon it aware he intends wudu, not mere cleaning; and the meanings of knowledge, wisdom, power, hearing and sight are clear yet affirmed in a manner befitting His majesty, without likening.

    Original page

  • The hinn and binn before Adam

    A questioner cited reports from some Companions that God created before Adam creatures called the hinn and the binn, and asked what they are. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77690, 4 February 2009) answered that scholars know God created the jinn before Adam and commanded Iblis — who was of them — to bow to Adam; he refused and was among the disbelievers. As for the binn, they had not heard of them, and he counselled him to busy himself with what benefits, since wading into questions on which no action rests is the needless exertion we were forbidden.

    Original page

  • How the seeker learns tawhid

    A questioner asked how a seeker of knowledge learns to affirm God's oneness — 'how do I affirm it'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77975, 25 February 2009) answered that the general profession of tawhid is realized in all Muslims — none of them but professes God's oneness and Muhammad's messengership — while the details and realities of tawhid are what must be learned, by reading the creed books: he recommended Dr. Umar Sulayman al-Ashqar's Beliefs series as useful for him, or if hard to get, his own book 'Know that there is no god but God' on his site — let him begin there and each step will deliver him to the next.

    Original page

  • Hypothetical fiqh questions

    Following up on an earlier question about the four madhhabs' agreement on requiring compensation, the answerer was asked more. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77698, 4 February 2009) said its basis with them is that the value of destroyed property is alike for intent and error — then asked in turn whether these questions were actual cases he lived or mere pastime: how fine it is to occupy oneself with what benefits, sparing time and effort for worshipping one's Lord and learning what has actually befallen him; what has not befallen him he should leave, for when it befalls God will grant relief at its hour.

    Original page

  • Excuse by ignorance, computer games, and the heedless

    A questioner asked four things: whether a man is excused by ignorance in the fundamentals of religion when he is lazy about learning; the ruling on 3-D computer games; repeating a prayer doubted; and the meaning of 'those who are heedless in their prayer'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78093, 5 March 2009) answered that the default is hastening to learn and teach to lift ignorance — let him busy himself with learning rather than judging the ignorant, that question being of the fitna questions whose fire he should not enter; computer play is lawful so long as the images hold no obscenity and it does not bar him from remembrance and prayer; redoing a doubted act of worship to leave the disagreement is good, the wary course being recommended — if he thought one unspecified prayer of yesterday void he repeats them all and is cleared; 'heedless in their prayer' means those who delay prayer past its time.

    Original page

  • Islam and the theory of evolution

    A questioner asked whether Islam is the truth and what it says of the theory of evolution. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87496, 27 September 2012) answered that Islam is the clear truth by the texts' testimony, and that evolution is in his view empty talk refuted by the western academies themselves, pointing to God's creating creation in stages as stated. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Is information a creed

    A questioner asked whether information counts as creed, noting people with much knowledge about Islam. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77891, 19 February 2009) answered that the matter's first, axis and sum is knowledge — 'know that there is no god but God' — for action without knowledge is impossible, as knowledge without action is madness; knowledge of God, His angels, books, messengers, the Last Day and decree is creed — but this creed must then lead you to action, else it is evidence against its holder and ruin on Judgment Day: some orientalists amassed much information on Islam that never led them to faith, so it is evidence against them, and Abu Talib knew Muhammad was on truth, saying 'I have known Muhammad's religion to be the best religion of people'.

    Original page

  • Learning English and computing, and the hadith on intention

    A questioner asked whether learning English and computing is lawful, and what is meant by the hadith that whoever learns knowledge meant to be sought for God's face only to gain some worldly offer will not smell Paradise's scent. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81134, 11 March 2010) answered that learning a trade to run one's living is unobjectionable — the Muslims' consensus — and does not contradict the hadith, which concerns purely sharia sciences, as in 'whoever seeks knowledge to vie with scholars, dispute with fools, or draw people's faces to himself — the Fire'; one who learns a trade to spare himself begging's humiliation, feed his family and keep kinship does a good deed intended for God's face — let him make his intention good.

    Original page

  • What a Muslim may not be ignorant of — research guidance

    A questioner needed to prepare a study fixing what a Muslim may not be ignorant of across the sharia-sciences' chapters — fiqh, creed, thought and dealings. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 527, 5 February 2005) gave him leave, asking God's guidance for both, and counselled going back to the compendia of fiqh gathered by trustworthy scholars, extracting their cream as his material, then ordering it on a method he approves; best he have a sharia supervisor to guide and help him if new to writing — pointing out knowledge is half of knowledge.

    Original page

  • The faith of the Prophet's parents — a question best left

    A questioner raised the view that the Prophet's ancestors and parents were on Ibrahim's religion, monotheists, citing 'and your going about among the prostrate'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77070, 9 December 2008) answered that the preponderant view is otherwise, and advised him not to split words over this question and its like — the dispute around it stirs souls' rancour and nothing of action rests on it; he feared wading into it was the needless exertion we were forbidden, and counselled occupying oneself with what benefits.

    Original page

  • Numerical analysis of the Qur'an — learn first

    A questioner offered numerical analyses of the Qur'an — counting cows, fat and lean — linking them to the zakat of cattle. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 2644, 14 February 2007) thanked him for his care for the Qur'an and his pondering it, and counselled leaving such analyses for now: the approach needs tools to be acquired first, then analysis and interpretation may follow; let him seek knowledge from its sources at its people's hands and busy himself with that at this stage — once he holds the tools of inquiry and interpretation he will himself discover the risks and overreach in such analyses.

    Original page

  • Balancing the sciences of religion and of the world

    A questioner asked how to balance the sciences of religion and of the world. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists (fatwa no. 360, 21 September 2004) answered that among religion's sciences some are individually obligatory — learning them binding on every Muslim, sinful to leave, none excused for ignoring, like what one's prayer, fast and other worship cannot stand on; he need not know each question with its proof — asking a fatwa-authority he trusts in religion and learning suffices for worship on insight; the communally obligatory sciences fall on the ummah as a whole, not each person — medicine, engineering and the like serving its interests.

    Original page

  • The wordings of doubt in transmitting hadith

    A questioner asked which wordings mark a hadith citation as doubtful, and whether 'such-and-such is established from the Messenger of God' is one. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78471, 5 April 2009) answered that 'established from the Messenger' is plainly not a wording of doubt — it is a wording of certainty, implying commitment to the hadith's soundness, so it should preface a report only when one is sure of it; the doubt wordings are like 'it is reported' with a doubled r and 'it is said' and the like.

    Original page

  • Waswasa and psychiatric treatment — no harm to faith or marriage

    A chronic whisperer feared his waswasa might affect his faith and his marriage. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84392, 9 May 2011) prayed God wipe over him with His healing hand and join reward with health, urging him to seek treatment for the waswasa with trustworthy psychiatrists — God sent down no illness without sending its cure, known to some and unknown to others; what he describes has no effect on his faith nor on his bond with his wife — let him cast the whispering off, give it no heed, turn to mending his own state, take righteous company aiding his religion and world, and abound in remembrance and Qur'an recitation.

    Original page

  • A study on the knowledge no Muslim may be ignorant of ⁦(asked about preparing the paper)⁩

    A questioner wanted to prepare a paper on 'the knowledge no Muslim may be ignorant of'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi answered for the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 21818, 14 October 2012): do it, and no harm — advising him to go back to the concise fiqh manuals compiled by trustworthy scholars and extract their essence as material, then organise it on a sound method, and to take a religious supervisor to guide and assist him if he is new to writing, for showing the way to knowledge is half of knowledge.

    Original page

  • Using miscarried foetuses in scientific and therapeutic experiments

    A questioner asked about using miscarried foetuses in scientific experiments, treatment and organ transplantation. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20860) answered that it is permissible when a set of controls is observed — which the answer sets out.

    Original page

  • Acting on weak hadith and narrating it in virtues and exhortation

    A questioner asked about acting on weak hadith and narrating it in the virtues of deeds, exhortation and stories. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22492) answered that narrating weak hadith in the virtues of works is permissible as the scholars of fiqh and hadith have held, provided its weakness is not severe — under the conditions the answer details.

    Original page

  • Using AI to write scholarly content and publish it

    A questioner asked about using AI to write scholarly content and then publish it. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22203) answered that AI is a lawful means of producing scholarly content as long as it remains a tool assisting research and the gathering of information — with the researcher verifying its output — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Attributing written works to someone other than their author

    A questioner asked about attributing written works to someone other than their author. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21617) answered that scholarly trustworthiness requires the correct attribution of sayings and works and referring every citation to its source — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Believing meteorological weather forecasts

    A questioner asked about believing the published forecasts of the meteorological authority for coming weather. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22134) answered that nothing in the sharia bars believing them; the answer sets out the difference between this and claiming knowledge of the unseen.

    Original page

  • Buying used books cheaply at their usual spots

    A questioner asked about buying used books at a low price from places set aside for that. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22017) answered that buying them is lawful so long as their ownership passed to the seller by a sound lawful means, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The meaning of jealousy in respect of God

    A questioner asked the meaning of the jealousy mentioned in the hadith in respect of God. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22457) answered that the jealousy attributed to God is a figurative jealousy carried upon the sense that God hates indecencies and therefore forbade them to His servants, as the answer details in construing the text.

    Original page

  • A patient relying on AI for medical questions

    A questioner asked about using AI applications to diagnose illnesses and determine medicines. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22359) answered that using AI to conclusively diagnose diseases without real examination and to determine medicines without a doctor's direct intervention or supervision is prohibited in the sharia, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Praying with the anomalous readings

    A questioner asked about praying with the anomalous (shadh) readings that diverge from the Uthmanic rasm. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21954) answered that deliberately praying with anomalous readings invalidates the prayer — recitation loses one of its pillars and departs from the mushaf the community agreed upon — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Relying on AI for interpreting the Qur'an

    A questioner asked about relying on AI applications for interpreting the Qur'an. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22413) answered that total reliance on AI applications in Qur'an commentary is prohibited in the sharia; the answer sets out what AI may and may not be used for in this field, and the conditions of each.

    Original page

  • Establishing schools inside mosques

    A questioner asked about establishing schools inside mosques. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20932) answered that the matter belongs to the competent authorities as they see benefit realised, provided the mosque is not diverted from its legal function — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Selling books that contain scholarly errors and sharia violations

    A questioner asked about selling books containing scholarly errors and sharia violations. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 24334) answered that scholarly books may lawfully be sold so long as they are owned by the seller and contain what benefits; but where they contain sharia violations and scholarly errors that the competent committees have determined, their circulation is prohibited — as the answer's detailed controls set out.

    Original page

  • Sharing paid online courses with non-subscribers

    A questioner asked about letting a non-subscriber share his access to paid online courses. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20902) answered that it is not lawful without the owner's permission, being among the material rights that may not be transgressed — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Studying the history and antiquities of past nations

    A questioner asked about studying the history and antiquities of past nations. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22192) answered that the Qur'an and Sunna, in many of their texts, drew attention to the necessity of travelling the earth and contemplating the remains of former nations for admonition; the answer sets out the ruling on studying them on that basis.

    Original page

  • Using text files of others' books without permission

    A publishing house asked about using the text files on its devices of works and books it wants to lay out and produce, without their owners' permission. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22404) answered by setting out the ruling on that and its controls, in terms of authors' rights and intellectual property as the answer details.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 208 (22/4) on declaring a Muslim an unbeliever: its causes, effects and remedy

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 22nd session in Kuwait (2–5 Jumada al-Akhira 1436, 22–25 March 2015), in view of the worsening boldness in declaring Muslims unbelievers and the haste to pronounce apostasy on individuals, communities, states and governments without regard for the principles, objectives and rules of the sharia, and the grave consequences of killing, destruction and displacement. It ruled: first, reaffirming its resolution 152 (17/1) from the 17th session on Islam and the single community and the creedal, juristic and educational schools, which holds it impermissible to declare unbeliever any Muslim group believing in God and His messenger and the pillars of faith and Islam that does not deny what is necessarily known of religion; second, reaffirming resolution 175 (19/1) on religious freedom in Islamic sharia — its dimensions and controls — which holds that the fatwa of apostasy or takfir belongs to the recognised scholars with the judiciary undertaking what the jurists required and removing doubts, and warns against the danger of attributing takfir to a sect of Muslims and fastening it on them, let alone declaring the Companions and Mothers of the Believers unbelievers or belittling their standing. It recommended that the secretariat complete the earlier recommendations to hold seminars on loyalty-and-disavowal, the hadith of the saved sect and what is built on it, and takfir for non-comprehensive application of the sharia's rulings; it addressed the youth of the community, warning them of the claims of deviant thought and extremism, directing them to sound useful knowledge on a middle course; scholars and callers to engage the youth and carry out the duty of enjoining right and forbidding wrong on the middle course; governments to provide means and remove obstacles to reaching the youth and guiding them through scholars and leaders of thought; and benefiting from successful experiences of dialogue with holders of straying thought, such as the counselling experience in Saudi Arabia.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 221 (23/5) on intellectual and practical measures to confront excess, extremism and what is called terrorism in these days in every field

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 23rd session in Medina (19–23 Safar 1440, 28 October – 1 November 2018). It ruled that extremism in all its forms and kinds is forbidden by the texts of the Book and the Sunnah, the prohibition growing graver when it leads its adherent to attack lives, honour, property, minds and religions. It issued thirteen recommendations, among them: raising the standard of religious discourse in mosques in content and method, tied to lived reality; improving the living and professional level of imams and muezzins with qualifying courses for mosque workers; establishing Quran centres in every state under distinguished specialists in the readings and Quranic sciences with the latest teaching means against extremist thought; selecting competent muftis for the cities and regions of each state, adopting collective ifta for public new events to revive collective ijtihad, and legislating to bar the unqualified from issuing fatwas with deterrent penalties; updating study courses toward a culture of human-rights respect and rejection of violence, extremism and atheism, recognising the other's right to diversity; building curricula consonant with the community's creed and fundamentals, joining authenticity with contemporaneity and correcting misconceptions about Islam; calling media institutions to adopt the discourse of moderation and rely on facts; correcting the distorted concepts of legal terms such as jihad, the caliphate, loyalty-and-disavowal and sovereignty that the young are exploited with in conflicts; introducing courses rejecting violence, crime and bigotry and strengthening awareness of the sanctity of blood, property and honour; a comprehensive cultural programme sponsored by the state to correct the view of Islam and entrench its fundamentals; an educational policy fostering tolerance, citizenship, critical thinking and respect for the other opinion; benefiting from successful experiences in countering extremism; and opening dialogue with holders of extremist thought to refute their doubts and return them to moderate social life and coexistence.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 236 (24/7) on the role of religious education in strengthening peace

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 24th session in Dubai (7–9 Rabi' I 1441, 4–6 November 2019), after reviewing the recommendations of the international scholarly seminar 'The Role of Religious Education in Strengthening Peace' it held in Rabat with ICESCO (17–18 Sha'ban 1440, 23–24 April 2019). It issued twenty clauses, including: attention to the Quran and Sunnah and the educational method drawn from them; continuing conferences, seminars and international dialogue forums to present the moderate Islamic culture; member states forming committees to study religious-education curricula and imbue them with the values of peace, dialogue and coexistence; including education for peace in curricula; stressing God's honouring of the human being as human, with the right to a dignified life, education and health; highlighting skills and concepts that reinforce tolerant religious and national values; spreading Arabic-language programmes for non-speakers; publishing educational curricula through modern media to correct the image of Islam and Muslims; partnership between scholars of religion and educational specialists in preparing curricula; coordination between media, educational, outreach, cultural and youth institutions to strengthen identity, national belonging and respect for other opinions; developing the training of religious counsellors; continuous in-service qualification of religious-education teachers; developing teaching methods suited to the knowledge-media generation and entrenching the values of dialogue and debate; preparing and translating foundational studies on education for moderation; establishing research centres to answer the calls of extremism, takfir and atheism and refute them in the sharia; seminars on using social media for the values of peace and moderation; strengthening a culture of peace in religious-education programmes; teaching comparative jurisprudence and comparative religion in a way that shows the sharia's flexibility and acceptance of the other; developing religious-education curricula; and presenting the correct concepts regarding women in Islam and including them in curricula.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 239 (25/1) on the ruling on religious and worldly education for males and females in Islam

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 25th session in Jeddah (29 Rajab – 3 Sha'ban 1444, 20–23 February 2023). It defined education in Islam as acquiring the values, principles, knowledge and skills that help a person worship God and cultivate the world, and ruled that educating males and females in beneficial sciences is a right owed by the family, society and state in every kind and stage of education; that the required education covers whatever serves the five necessary interests and the need-based and ameliorative interests, religious and worldly alike; that spending on it is a sharia duty; and that it is not lawful to deprive either male or female of any kind of beneficial education. It recommended addressing anomalous fatwas that bar women from learning, rebutting the arguments for depriving women of education, and urging governments to enable the education of males and females, girls' education in particular. It drew on its earlier resolutions 38 (4/13), 164 (18/2), 169 (18/7) and 236 (24/7) and on the General Secretariat's statement on the suspension of girls' education in Afghanistan (22 December 2022).

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution on the Academy's scholarly projects

    IIFA's third-session resolution (Amman, October 1986) approving, with amendments, the Academy's scholarly projects: the economic fiqh encyclopedia, the dictionary of fiqh terms, the fiqh-rules reference, the codification of fiqh-ruling evidences, the revival of fiqh heritage, and their financial regulations.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution on the fiqh-rules reference project

    IIFA's fourth-session resolution (Jeddah, February 1988) on the fiqh-rules reference (ma'lamat al-qawa'id al-fiqhiyya) project: it adopted the project's final drafting and agreed stages and tasked the secretariat with implementation, choosing between the committee's two options for stages one and five.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution on the Facilitating Fiqh project

    IIFA's fourth-session resolution (Jeddah, February 1988) on the Facilitating Fiqh project: it adopted the plan in the supervising committee's report with the proposed amendment and tasked the secretariat with following up its implementation.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution on the planning division's proposed topics and seminars

    IIFA's sixth-session resolution (Jeddah, March 1990) on the planning division's proposed topics and seminars: the proposals are to be heeded, with the secretariat delegated to choose per interest — especially items suggested at the previous session — and to prepare the proposed seminars prioritising topics already raised.

    Original page

  • Recommendations of IIFA's seventh session on intellectual invasion

    The recommendations of IIFA's seventh session (Mecca, May 1992) on what it terms intellectual invasion, as published by the Academy's secretariat on its site — recorded as the Academy's own text.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution regulating commissioned research and its discussion

    IIFA's eighth-session resolution (Brunei, June 1993) regulating commissioned research: once the submission term ends the secretariat may confine itself to papers received within it; unsolicited papers are not accepted; and session discussion is confined to what the secretariat sets, as detailed.

    Original page

  • May one ask artificial intelligence for a fatwa?

    A question about turning to artificial-intelligence applications for answers on sharia matters and relying on their rulings, in which IslamQA answered that artificial intelligence is a permissible tool in principle, but that it may not be asked for fatwas nor relied upon in religious matters, because it lacks the qualifications of a mufti, namely understanding of the religion and of reality and the other conditions set out by al-Shafi'i and Ibn al-Qayyim, and because its answers are generated automatically from data that may be of unknown origin, mistaken or fabricated, may carry the biases of its trainers, and do not account for the way discretionary rulings change with custom and circumstance. The site distinguished artificial intelligence from fatwa websites, where real people answer, and said that a scholarly researcher may use it to gather material, find sources, summarise and understand reality provided every quotation is verified, and that a layman may use it to get a general idea or to ask for links to fatwas he then consults himself, as a smart search engine, but may not act on a fatwa the system generates by itself. It set out two contemporary approaches, outright prohibition or a distinction between fixed rulings that apply equally to everyone, where its answers may be used under four conditions, and rulings built on custom and circumstance, where they may not; the site judged the prohibiting approach the stronger in the present state of the technology.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer