Fatwas on Iman (faith) 51 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
- The report ascribed to Abu Hanifa that Abu Bakr's and Iblis's faith are one
A questioner asked about a report transmitted from Abu Hanifa via al-Fazari that Abu Bakr's faith and Iblis's faith are one. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87079, 8 July 2012) answered that the report — if authentic — has nothing to do with what slanderers claim: iman is applied to knowledge, to assent, to humble submission, or to all of these; Abu Hanifa — if the report is sound — meant to note that two opposites may meet in one aspect without the others: Abu Bakr is the summit of faith and Satan the head of disbelief, yet they share the root of knowing God, as Mecca's polytheists acknowledged lordship — and the difference between them is the answer spells out.
- The Ahbash group's strife among Ethiopia's Muslims
A questioner asked about the Lebanese Ahbash group stirring strife among Ethiopia's Muslims and dividing their ranks, in his account with official support. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85691, 18 October 2011) answered that their ruling had been set out — their method being innovation in creed and approach and misguided in many creed and practice matters, in AMJA's view — and quoted the Saudi Permanent Committee's answer on Abdullah al-Harari al-Habashi calling him a head of innovation and misguidance and holding it a duty to warn against the group, as quoted. Recorded as AMJA's answer citing the committee.
- Calamities befalling unaccountable animals
A questioner raised the atheists' doubt that unaccountable animals suffer calamities with no afterlife compensation. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86371, 22 January 2012) answered that God's acts are never without wisdom — some grasped, some not; though beasts bear no obligation, on the Last Day retaliation is exacted for the hornless ewe from the horned one as the sunna records, so it is possible that part of what befalls them in this world — besides being a punishment or trial for their owners — is a worldly penalty for them too; and the injustice God forbade Himself is placing a thing out of place and withholding a due.
- A group's apostasy in Minnesota, and dawa's two missions
A questioner reported a group in Minnesota who had left their religion and begun speaking against the religion and the Prophet. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81733, 23 June 2010) answered with sorrow at their apostasy — preferring blindness to guidance — citing the verse that God will bring a people He loves and who love Him should any turn back from their religion; they lose only themselves and do not harm God. He reminded that dawa outside Muslim lands has two missions: preserving Islam among its people — the top priority — and calling non-Muslims to it, and hoped the questioner would not despair of restoring them through sincere effort and knowing their circumstances closely, as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The best generation is mine — answering the objector
A questioner cited 'the best of generations is mine, then those who follow them' — asked if it is sound in that wording, and reported an impure-creed objector belittling the Companions' society. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77839, 15 February 2009) answered that the hadith is established in the two Sahihs from Abu Hurayra in that very wording, received by the ummah with acceptance and consensus on its meaning; a few hypocrites in the Companions' society do not lower their rank, nor do rare lapses diminish its worth — so rare they became famous for being told; the apostasy emerged in Abu Bakr's time, not the prophetic era, and even so it opened to the Muslims gates of servitude and brought many of them to the highest paradise. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- A Christian's ten questions on Islam
A Christian reader of the site's articles put ten questions, including paradise in Islam and the corruption of the Gospel. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21842, 20 July 2006) answered among them that after Muhammad's mission no believer's faith stands nor his tawhid is sound except by believing in his prophethood once he hears of him and his call reaches him — 'Islam' naming every believer of the earlier nations and, specially, Muhammad's followers; and the Gospel's corruption is plainer than needing proof: the Gospel writers themselves are unknown, no one knows who translated or transmitted them by connected chains, let alone the contradictions among them admitted by Christian scholars themselves. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The passing whisper and the settled doubt
A chronic whisperer — unsure whether the grave thoughts against faith he entertained or uttered were whispering or meant — asked what to do. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77887, 19 February 2009) answered that he had answered him before: be gentle with yourself and do not weary it with hardship; passing whispers — cast them off, give them no heed and do not indulge them, saying 'praise God who turned his plot into whispering'; if they become a settled established state, seek their cure with the godly among the scholars and bearers of the sharia he knows.
- Raising the crescent with the cross for national unity
A questioner asked about raising a crescent-with-cross emblem for national unity in lands where Muslims and Christians live together. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83460, 3 January 2011) answered that the cross is a Christian emblem its people may raise — Muslims being commanded to leave them and their creed be — but the Muslim holds the crucifixion claim false by the verse, so he cannot raise an emblem he believes void; that does not detract from the duty of national solidarity against security breaches and sectarian tension, and the two groups may fly the flag of the state sheltering them all. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Cursing one who died a disbeliever
A questioner asked whether one who died a disbeliever may be cursed and testified to be among the people of the Fire. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81528, 22 May 2010) answered that the texts show whoever dies in disbelief is among the people of the Fire — 'nor those who die as disbelievers; for them We prepared a painful punishment' — but that is a general ruling to be believed in generally; it does not license cursing an individual nor testifying that a specific person is in the Fire, except one for whom evidence came naming him, just as believing that whoever dies faithful enters Paradise does not license testifying that for an individual unless proof names him. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Cursing religion then repenting
A questioner asked about a man who uttered a curse-word against religion — whether his wife is thereby separated, whether cursing the religion of lifeless things disbelieves, and whether advising him to wash, re-proclaim and repent suffices. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84229, 15 April 2011) answered that the word is grave — disbelief from its sayer, and likewise cursing the religion of inanimate things since everything glorifies His praise; but the wife is separated only upon persisting in disbelief: whoever seeks forgiveness and turns back, his wife is not separated and no new marriage contract is demanded, since the Companions did not demand of repenting apostates a renewal of their contracts. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Deeds within faith — the Murji'a and the Sunnis
A questioner interested in the shaykh's thought asked about the Murji'a's separating deeds from faith. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21858, 10 July 2007) answered that the essence is: deeds are a condition of faith's completeness, except what the proof shows to be a condition of its validity — and this does not contradict saying faith is word and deed, for the Murji'a excluded all deeds from the name of faith and the Khawarij drew all into faith's root while the Sunnis stand between: faith is word and deed, but some deeds enter faith's root, some its obligatory completeness, some its recommended completeness — the revealed proofs distinguish each.
- Defining faith — word and deed explained
A questioner raised a difficulty in defining faith in sum as word and deed, detailed as the heart's word, the tongue's word, the heart's deed, the tongue's deed and the limbs' deed. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21834, 18 January 2006) answered that it is simple: the definition describes faith in itself, apart from what is believed — faith in God is the heart's affirming Him, the tongue's declaring Him, and the heart's, tongue's and limbs' acting accordingly; faith in the angels, books, messengers, Last Day and decree runs the same way; whoever leaves acting on any of that is deficient in faith, not outside it entirely — as the answer details.
- Delaying hajj while able, and takfir
A questioner asked whether one who postpones the hajj though able is a disbeliever, as the Friday preacher said. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82871, 15 October 2010) answered that scholars differ on whether hajj is due at once or may be deferred — two well-known opinions, the sounder being immediacy for whoever is able in body and wealth — yet that does not mean declaring the postponer a disbeliever or equating him with the denier, something he had only read in this very question; perhaps the preacher's zeal carried him away, and the questioner should quietly ask the speaker for clarification without stirring clamour, and busy himself with what benefits him. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Answering those who deny the Fire after the reckoning
A questioner asked for the answer to those denying the Fire after the reckoning — like Jehovah's Witnesses holding that after it comes either eternal life for believers or annihilation for the rest. Dr. Hatim al-Haj (fatwa no. 82870, 15 October 2010) answered that reason proves the return and reward and punishment, but their duration and eternity lie beyond reason's power of denial or proof, known only through the truthful Prophet's report; Islam is the religion whose proof is manifest and whose root does not contradict sound reason, so the details are sought in it alone — with the rest of the answer as written. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The descent of Isa at the end of time
A questioner asked about the return of Isa son of Maryam at the end of time. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77611, 28 January 2009) answered that the Messiah's descent is among the major signs of the Hour — 'he is knowledge for the Hour' meaning Isa's descent — and many hadiths reaching mutawatir record it, among them the two-Sahihs report of Abu Hurayra: 'by Him in whose hand is my soul, the son of Maryam will soon descend among you as a just ruler; he will break the cross, kill the swine and lift the jizya'; it is among the established tenets of Sunni creed, proven by decisive texts.
- Whisperings of the soul and God's mercy
A psychologically exhausted questioner who prays and fasts feared his deeds were unacceptable. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86572, 14 March 2012) answered that God pardons this ummah for what its souls whisper so long as it is not acted or spoken; that even if he committed or uttered some ill then repented, no sin is too great for repentance per the verse that whoever does ill or wrongs himself then seeks God's forgiveness finds Him forgiving and merciful; he was told to leave the whisperings, to know his Lord is the most merciful, think well of Him and never despair of His mercy — for God forgives all sins.
- A doubt about mocking a Companion
A questioner feared he had mocked a Companion's name or done something requiring him to re-utter the testimony, dreading his state at death. The site's sharia section (fatwa no. 78824, 12 May 2009) answered that he should put his doubt before people of knowledge to be answered so it does not settle in him; if it is whispering, he should stop, refuse its indulgence, seek refuge in his Lord, multiply good deeds, keep the company of the righteous and hold to the Quran — thereby he is safe and nothing is on him.
- Supplicating to change one's fate from misery to felicity
A questioner cited al-Tabari's tafsir that Companions and Successors used to ask God to change their fate — bringing them from written misery to felicity. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86498, 29 February 2012) answered that everything of decree is foreknown, forewritten in the Tablet and willed, God being the Creator of all; but some decrees are determined and some suspended, and among the suspended are those hanging on supplication, charity and keeping kinship — which adorn houses and lengthen lives — God having known and written the determined, the suspended and what they hang on.
- Asking God for beauty of face and limbs
A questioner asked whether one may pray for beauty of face, appearance, limbs and form, and whether God could grant it in our time. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23301, 14 July 2008) answered that a servant may ask his Lord whatever he wishes of this world's and the next's good, so long as his prayer contains no sin and no kinship-cutting — and what he mentioned holds none of that; let him pray certain of answer, thinking well of his Lord, who is generous and bountiful.
- The criteria of faith and takfir
A questioner asked: since one who says or does shirk is not declared a disbeliever except under takfir's criteria — does faith too have criteria, if someone says the word of faith? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77697, 4 February 2009) answered that the default for anyone ascribing to Islam who has not clearly engaged a nullifier is that he is a Muslim, the ruling leaving him only with certainty meeting takfir's conditions and clearing its barriers; the Prophet rebuked Usama ibn Zayd for killing a man after he uttered the testimony, alleging he said it sheltering from the sword — 'did you split open his heart?'; whoever ascribes to Islam is a Muslim, and if he engages a nullifier, the meeting of takfir's conditions and absence of barriers is examined. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Why Abraham is clothed first on the Last Day
A questioner asked why Abraham is advanced before others in being clothed on the Last Day. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83370, 21 December 2010) answered that the first of God's servants clothed that day is the Friend of the Merciful, father of the prophets, Abraham — per Ibn Abbas's hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari 'the first of creation clothed on the Last Day is Abraham the Friend' — with Ibn Hajar noting al-Bayhaqi's addition of a chair placed right of the throne; the scholars give his precedence to none before or after fearing God more than he, so his clothing is hastened as reassurance, and possibly because he was first to wear the sarawil, as recorded.
- Does iman increase and decrease with deeds
A questioner asked whether the iman that increases with obedience and decreases with sin is the heart's assent and knowledge, or whether it is the limbs' deeds that grow and shrink. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83183, 24 November 2010) answered that the heart's works vary in decrease and increase just as the limbs' works do: the prophets' assent is not like others', the assent of Companions who saw the miracles is not like that of those told later, and the prophets' humble devotion and love is not like others' — as self-evident in all intangible things like intelligence, courage and nobility.
- Whispered thoughts are pardoned
A chronic whisperer who kept returning to the same topic in new shapes asked whether anything is on him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78061, 4 March 2009) answered that his whispers had wearied him and they had answered before: God has pardoned this ummah for what its selves whisper, so long as it does not act on or utter it; he should not indulge the whispers but cut them at the root and say 'praise be to God who turned his plot into mere whispering' — it will not harm him, God willing.
- Intrusive thoughts whispering disbelief
A questioner described intrusive thoughts he cannot repel, making him feel he is an unbeliever and driving toward a conviction that man is compelled. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86920, 29 May 2012) answered that he had already given himself the gist: God wrongs people in nothing — a truth above every whisper, attested by reason, revelation and nature; God does not judge by His prior knowledge but by deeds that come forth, having given His servants the instruments of responsibility and sent messengers with tidings and warnings; none is punished before the proof stands; and he should not despair at such passing thoughts, for their like passed over some Companions too.
- Islam and the theory of evolution
A questioner asked whether Islam is the truth and what it says of the theory of evolution. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87496, 27 September 2012) answered that Islam is the clear truth by the texts' testimony, and that evolution is in his view empty talk refuted by the western academies themselves, pointing to God's creating creation in stages as stated. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Drawing a cross sign in jest
A questioner said a humorous relative had drawn a cross sign on his chest in jest and he feared it was disbelief. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86565, 13 March 2012) answered that no sin is too great for repentance — his remorse is repentance, his fear of what he may have fallen into and his eagerness to shed its consequence are repentance; let him keep to good deeds and good company; and he taught that a man may fall into disbelief over a jest, as the hypocrites' verse 'you have disbelieved after your belief' came down — while repeating that no sin is too great for repentance. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Is information a creed
A questioner asked whether information counts as creed, noting people with much knowledge about Islam. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77891, 19 February 2009) answered that the matter's first, axis and sum is knowledge — 'know that there is no god but God' — for action without knowledge is impossible, as knowledge without action is madness; knowledge of God, His angels, books, messengers, the Last Day and decree is creed — but this creed must then lead you to action, else it is evidence against its holder and ruin on Judgment Day: some orientalists amassed much information on Islam that never led them to faith, so it is evidence against them, and Abu Talib knew Muhammad was on truth, saying 'I have known Muhammad's religion to be the best religion of people'.
- The claim that the Mahdi is alive now
A questioner asked about a circulating piece claiming the Mahdi is alive and providing and attacking its evidence. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85679, 16 October 2011) answered that the Mahdi is a reality, not a myth — hadiths on him are sound, reaching mutawatir in meaning for some scholars, among them Ibn Masud's hadith of filling the earth with equity and justice; the hadiths fix no time except that he emerges before the Dajjal; declaring him alive now by name is guessing at the unseen and saying of God without knowledge, not to be indulged. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- A new Muslim raising doubts in a small community
A small community in Mexico — their mosque the state's only one — asked about a recent Muslim among them who kept raising doubts about the religion. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83681, 3 February 2011) answered that saying flatly there are no fixed truths people know and knowledge is God's alone is wrong: they hold for certain that Muhammad is true, the Quran true, Islam true, and the Companions the masters of God's friends in this ummah, the best being Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali; the man's excuse may be that he is a new Muslim of little reading, so they should embrace him with a broad chest, gentle manners, beautiful patience and goodly debate, as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- A mother who curses religion unknowingly
A sixteen-year-old whose loving parents have divorced twice asked about his mother, who curses religion not knowing it leads to disbelief. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85782, 28 October 2011) praised his dutifulness, urged him to persist in advising them and to make clear the gravity of cursing religion as a nullifier of Islam; as for the past, done in ignorance of its ruling, he hopes it does not affect the marriage between them — but letting the state continue ruins their world and hereafter, so he should be among their counsellors and tend their hereafter as they tended his childhood world. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The Muslim who takes his own life
A questioner asked whether a Muslim suicide equals the disbeliever in punishment — eternal fire with no exit. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80094, 30 September 2009) answered that suicide is among the gravest major sins, with severe warnings — Muslim's report that whoever kills himself with an iron will pierce his belly with it in hellfire forever, and God's word about the wounded man who slit his hand, 'My servant hastened to Me with his soul; I have forbidden him Paradise'; yet suicide is not disbelief expelling from the community — it is among the major sins within God's will on Judgment Day, forgiven if He wills or punished if He wills — and he told of al-Tufayl ibn Amr al-Dawsi dreaming of one covering his hands, for whom the Prophet prayed forgiveness. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Saying 'my heart tells me God's pleasure and anger'
A questioner asked about the saying 'I know when God is pleased with me and when angry — my heart is my guide'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81395, 1 May 2010) answered that uttering it unqualified is open to question: it is sound in one respect — that sin is what wavers in your breast and you hate people to see, per Muslim's hadith 'righteousness is good character, and sin is what wavers in your breast and you hate for people to see', and Ahmad's 'righteousness is what the soul rests in and the heart is at peace with, sin what the soul does not rest in even if the muftis give you fatwa' — and he detailed the other respect in which it fails. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The fate of one who died without hearing of Islam
A questioner asked about one who died a non-Muslim never having heard of Islam, or only lies and forgeries against it — paradise or fire? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80434, 10 November 2009) answered that such a one's case is that of the people of the interval: he will be tested on the plain of Judgment Day — God kindles a fire for them and commands them to enter; whoever obeys finds it cool and safe, whoever disobeys enters the Fire — God best knowing what they used to do. The chapter holds a group of hadiths to this meaning, which al-Hafiz Ibn Kathir cited at 'We never punished until We sent a messenger', judging some of them sound as other scholars stated. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Falsehood has no logic
A questioner brought a forum piece reasoning about the misguidance of the jinn and their polytheists in terms of their 'logic'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81567, 27 May 2010) answered that he is, by such premises, judging the error of the jinn and polytheists by logic — and when has the straying had logic? Did cow-worshippers or Buddha-worshippers or devil-worshippers have one? God bred many of jinn and men for hell — hearts that do not understand, eyes that do not see, ears that do not hear — so they will say on Judgment Day 'had we listened or reasoned we would not be among the people of the blaze'; let him leave this logical indulgence about them — falsehood has no logic, only whim, bewilderment and confusion. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The nullifiers of faith and their consequence
A questioner asked what the nullifiers of faith are, what follows for one who nullified his faith, and whether a Muslim's prayer is valid while his faith is voided. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21863, 14 August 2007) answered that the nullifiers are faith's corrupters, invalidators and frustrators — faith is nullified by apostasy as wudu is by ritual impurity; the chief ones: shirk in lordship, shirk in divinity, shirk in the names and attributes, and objecting to, holding oneself above, denying, rejecting, mocking or ridiculing the sharia's rulings; the one who nullifies his faith leaves the community — no prayer or deed of his stands until he renews his faith. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Praying for beauty of form
A questioner asked whether a Muslim may pray for beauty — improvement of his form — if his nose is large or his head crooked. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23368, 23 July 2008) answered that a servant may ask his Lord whatever carries no sin and no kinship-cutting and is not among the rationally impossible; seeking improvement of form is none of those, and when his Lord wills a thing He carries it out — but he reminded him that beauty is not in the physical alone: what settles on a face of faith's bloom and piety's light is a beauty the limpid-souled perceive, compensating its owners for whatever lacks elsewhere; he asked God to grant him beauty of form and of character and contentment with what he was given.
- The claim that the Quran was distorted
A questioner asked AMJA's view of reports alleged to affirm the Quran's distortion, and the status of a scholar who says the Quran is distorted — whether he counts as a disbeliever. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82168, 13 August 2010) answered that God undertook the Quran's preservation — 'We sent down the Reminder and We are its guardians' — and the whole ummah agrees on its preservation and immunity, that it is what lies between the covers of the mushaf which Muslims pass down and recite east and west; whoever claims it is distorted while of sound mind has cast off the noose of Islam from his neck. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Repenting a sin one thought not major
A questioner asked about one who repented a sin he believed not major — is he still held to what passed, and what increases good deeds? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21872, 29 October 2007) answered that the repentant of a sin is as one without it; he counselled abundance of seeking forgiveness and doing good, for good deeds do away with evil ones.
- Creatures' right upon God, and recurring doubts
A questioner raised recurring doubts harming religion and asked for detailed answers. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86832, 8 May 2012) opened that creatures hold no right upon God except what God Himself made binding: He bound Himself to aiding the believers and to not punishing whoever associates nothing with Him, per Mu'adh's hadith in the two Sahihs — a right due by His perfect words and true promise, not a creature's claim on God like one creature's on another — then pursued the remaining answers, as recorded.
- Seeing the Prophet in a dream
A questioner asked whether the hadith 'whoever sees me in a dream has truly seen me' ties such visions to a certain rank. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78162, 11 March 2009) answered that whoever sees the Prophet in the form the Shamail books describe has seen truly, for the devil cannot take his shape; the vision indicates well-being in religion and tidings of a good ending, God willing — hopefully a prelude to a complete vision — so he should strive in worship, multiply blessings upon him and hope well.
- The Balance on Judgment Day — one scale or two
A questioner asked whether the Balance is one or two, whether it has two pans and a tongue, and the meaning of 'We set the just balances for Judgment Day — no soul is wronged at all'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21574, 8 April 2008) answered that the Sunnis believe the balance set on Judgment Day — by which good and evil deeds are weighed — is real, with two pans: good deeds on one, evil on the other, the deeds' records weighed between them, a balance weighing to a gnat's weight — 'whoever does an atom's weight of good will see it, and whoever does an atom's weight of evil will see it'; and the verse 'though it be a mustard-seed's weight, We bring it; sufficient are We as reckoners'.
- The gradations of loyalty to disbelievers
A questioner raised the verse forbidding taking fathers and brothers as allies, noting that loyalty has many facets including love, which has kinds. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84114, 2 April 2011) answered that 'loyalty toward God's enemies' is an ambiguous expression of uneven degrees: some of it is disbelief, some falls short, though all of it is forbidden; what counts as disbelief is absolute allegiance, or allegiance on account of religion — loving or aiding them for their faith and their transgression against God's command; kindness and equity toward peaceable non-Muslims do not enter forbidden loyalty. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Obsessive whisperings about the divine being
A sufferer of obsessive whisperings about the divine being — thoughts he cannot utter nor tell whether intended, leaving him feeling he has no faith — asked for help. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83510, 9 January 2011) answered that what he finds is Satan's toying to sadden him; the duty is not to follow the whisperings, to cut them at their start and to say praise be to God who reduced his plot to whispering; resisting them and standing firm is a sign of pure faith by Muslim's hadith 'that is manifest faith' with al-Nawawi's and al-Khattabi's explanations, as detailed.
- Obsessive doubt over divine decree
A sufferer of obsessive doubts over divine decree asked whether he may stop holding faith in qadar before projects since it weakens him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86499, 29 February 2012) answered that faith in decree is a pillar of iman and that yielding to misreading is the error: everything was created by decree and decree is repelled by decree — illness by treatment, hunger by food; faith in decree never means neglecting means — one takes them well in the station of means and disowns power and might in the station of reliance, as detailed.
- Watching programmes containing words of disbelief
A questioner who watches documentaries and foreign cartoons — which may utter words of disbelief such as 'nature's wrath' or swearing by other than God, though he disavows them in his heart — asked about it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82416, 2 September 2010) advised him to guard his time rather than waste it on cartoons and the like, and to occupy himself with higher things; occasional viewing for recreation or for the scientific benefit of documentaries is acceptable if free of other objectionable content, and their false words do not harm him so long as he disavows them in his heart and has enough understanding of the religion to tell truth from falsehood in what they say. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Hating the whispers is plain faith
A questioner who grows angry and receives whispers when a religious duty proves hard asked about it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77661, 2 February 2009) answered that the futile whispers he finds in himself deserve no attention and no utterance — let him seek refuge in God and ask Him to turn them away, they will not harm him; in the chapter stands the Companions' saying 'we find in ourselves things too grave to speak', the Prophet asking 'you really find that?', and on their yes, 'that is plain faith' — the hadith meaning that hating, detesting and recoiling from the whispers is plain faith, not their existence; should some turn into settled doubts, seeking their cure becomes required.
- Attributing rainfall to seas and the anwa' stars
A questioner asked about attributing rainfall to the abundance of seas and the anwa' (rain-bringing star settings). Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22281) answered that whoever attributes the existence of rain to the abundance of seas or the efficacy of the anwa' in themselves, ascribing the act to those things, holds a blameworthy belief; the answer marks the line between acknowledging outward causes and believing in them.
- The meaning of jealousy in respect of God
A questioner asked the meaning of the jealousy mentioned in the hadith in respect of God. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22457) answered that the jealousy attributed to God is a figurative jealousy carried upon the sense that God hates indecencies and therefore forbade them to His servants, as the answer details in construing the text.
- The prohibition of reviling the Companions
A questioner asked about the ruling on reviling the Companions. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22038) answered that honouring the Companions, magnifying their standing and preserving their sanctity is a sharia obligation shown by the revealed texts, and maligning them is forbidden — as the answer details.
- Are those who die in road accidents counted as martyrs?
A questioner asked about those who die in road accidents. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22010) answered that whoever dies in a road or traffic accident or from its injuries is counted among the martyrs of the Hereafter — provided there was no negligence on his part — as the answer details.
- Being Faithful Muslims and Loyal Americans
A resolution of the Fiqh Council of North America by Dr. Muzammil Siddiqi, adopted at the general-body meeting in Virginia (24–25 September 2011), on being faithful Muslims and loyal Americans together — as the resolution states.