Fatwas on Qadar (divine decree) 13 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
- Calamities befalling unaccountable animals
A questioner raised the atheists' doubt that unaccountable animals suffer calamities with no afterlife compensation. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86371, 22 January 2012) answered that God's acts are never without wisdom — some grasped, some not; though beasts bear no obligation, on the Last Day retaliation is exacted for the hornless ewe from the horned one as the sunna records, so it is possible that part of what befalls them in this world — besides being a punishment or trial for their owners — is a worldly penalty for them too; and the injustice God forbade Himself is placing a thing out of place and withholding a due.
- Does supplication change destiny
A questioner asked whether supplication changes destiny. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81834, 9 July 2010) answered that God legislated and commanded supplication — 'call upon Me, I will answer you' — and that supplication is itself part of decree: when the servant takes the lawful means and prays, that is repelling decree by decree if God wills it; it is established in the hadith that a servant may be denied provision for a sin he commits, that nothing repels decree but supplication and nothing lengthens life but piety — all inscribed in the Mother of the Book.
- A dream that warned of the dreamer's death
A questioner told of a young man who dreamt he would die in a road accident, and it came to pass — did God inform him or what? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81850, 12 July 2010) answered that it may be as he says, though they cannot assert it; the matter returns mostly to the dreamer's righteousness or lack of it.
- Supplicating to change one's fate from misery to felicity
A questioner cited al-Tabari's tafsir that Companions and Successors used to ask God to change their fate — bringing them from written misery to felicity. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86498, 29 February 2012) answered that everything of decree is foreknown, forewritten in the Tablet and willed, God being the Creator of all; but some decrees are determined and some suspended, and among the suspended are those hanging on supplication, charity and keeping kinship — which adorn houses and lengthen lives — God having known and written the determined, the suspended and what they hang on.
- Praying for a mother's long life, and decree
A questioner asked whether praying for his mother's long life opposes decree and whether God would lengthen it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82478, 8 September 2010) answered that praying for her life to be lengthened in obedience is not objectionable; some scholars explain that decrees are of two kinds — determined and suspended — and the suspended include those hanging on the supplicant's prayer, or on charity and kinship which adorn houses and lengthen lives per the hadith, all inscribed in the Mother of the Book; better than praying for long life is praying for salvation from punishment, per Umm Habiba's hadith in Muslim.
- Intrusive thoughts whispering disbelief
A questioner described intrusive thoughts he cannot repel, making him feel he is an unbeliever and driving toward a conviction that man is compelled. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86920, 29 May 2012) answered that he had already given himself the gist: God wrongs people in nothing — a truth above every whisper, attested by reason, revelation and nature; God does not judge by His prior knowledge but by deeds that come forth, having given His servants the instruments of responsibility and sent messengers with tidings and warnings; none is punished before the proof stands; and he should not despair at such passing thoughts, for their like passed over some Companions too.
- Istikhara and the servant's will in choosing a path
An architecture student — whose grades could have taken her to dentistry — chose engineering by her own wish, then doubted her choice. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79020, 28 May 2009) answered that the servant has a will, certainly, but it does not escape God's will — 'you will nothing unless God wills it'; she should not enter the philosophical quarrel over destiny: what matters is that the servant who turns to something, seeks God's guidance over it, finds it eased and proceeds should not grieve at what follows — she spent her capacity and made her effort; striving is on her, reaching the goal is not; and should fortune fail her on this path, let her believe what struck her is good, of the kind by which God expiates slips and raises ranks.
- A miserable or happy marriage and divine decree
A questioner asked whether a marriage's misery or happiness belongs to destiny. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82370, 28 August 2010) answered that everything God created is by decree — the wretchedness of the wretched and the felicity of the happy befell by His decree and the Pen ran in the first Book; the believer's affair is all good, gratitude in ease and patience in hardship; yet decree is no excuse for neglecting means — if the woman neglected the lawful means of choosing a partner, not choosing on the basis of religion and character or stubbornly refusing her guardians and counsellors, she should blame only herself and not reproach decree; decree is consolation, not a plea for squandering means.
- The successive guardians before and behind
A questioner asked about Ibn Abbas's reading of the 'successive guardians' who keep a servant by God's command, and how guarding works when the matter is already written. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86511, 2 March 2012) answered that the meaning, plainly, is that God decreed causes in the universe and made a cause for everything: He made the guardians a cause of preservation, as He made the angels a cause of victory at Badr though He could have granted victory Himself without causes — and as He told Maryam to shake the palm trunk though He could have sent His provision without any cause.
- Contentment with God's share in choosing a major
A second-year architecture student who chose her department by preference — though her grades admitted her to dentistry — and then regretted it asked for guidance. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79118, 7 June 2009) answered that nothing in existence befalls except by God's decree; having done her duty of istikhara and consultation, she should be content with God's share for her — perhaps the thing she dislikes holds much good, per 'it may be you hate a thing and God makes much good in it'.
- Obsessive doubt over divine decree
A sufferer of obsessive doubts over divine decree asked whether he may stop holding faith in qadar before projects since it weakens him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86499, 29 February 2012) answered that faith in decree is a pillar of iman and that yielding to misreading is the error: everything was created by decree and decree is repelled by decree — illness by treatment, hunger by food; faith in decree never means neglecting means — one takes them well in the station of means and disowns power and might in the station of reliance, as detailed.
- Why did God create me knowing I would sin
A questioner asked why God created him knowing he would work evils and end in the Fire — does that not contradict mercy embracing all things? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77963, 25 February 2009) answered that God's knowledge is an attribute that discloses things; God does not reckon His servants by what He knows of them but by the deeds they actually show; the askers of this question equate the compelled and the voluntary deeds of servants — plain stubbornness, like equating the feverish shiver with the body's chosen movement toward obscenity; God gave His servants the tools of responsibility — hearing, sight and heart — and reckons them thereby, and had He taken any away He would have dropped the charge to its measure; and the people of Paradise remain eased to the deeds of Paradise's people and the people of the Fire to the Fire's deeds, as detailed.
- Why does God not intervene at a crime
A questioner who saw a murdered woman and her little daughter driven mad by the sight asked why God did not intervene and spare the child, and whether a supplication wards off crime. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81607, 3 June 2010) answered that God created everything by measure and does what He wills — everyone among people wills what he cannot do or does what he does not will, but God alone does what He wills; He is not questioned about what He does, yet His acts are never sundered from His wisdom whether we grasp it or it escapes us; good is in His hands and evil is not attributed to Him, and it is not for anyone to say 'why did God not do such-and-such' — that is not courtesy with God. Recorded as AMJA's answer.