Fatwas on Sunna (the way, the practice of the Prophet, and the legal grades of the recommended) 3 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of Sunna (the way, the practice of the Prophet, and the legal grades of the recommended)

  • Answering the claim that recording the sunna was forbidden

    A questioner cited an article claiming the Prophet forbade recording the sunna, citing the hadith 'write nothing from me but the Quran'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82899, 19 October 2010) answered that the article is a chain of errors and falsehoods: the ummah, early and late, agreed on the sunna's authority, countless verses indicate it and plain reason confirms it — how would the details of prayer, zakat and hajj be known from the Quran alone? God appointed for the sunna master memorisers who vetted it as assayers vet coins, fulfilling in them 'We sent down the Reminder and We are its guardians'; he reminded the questioner that this knowledge is religion — mind whom you take your religion from — and that scavenging for religious knowledge online is no path to guidance. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Praying in shoes — lawful, with a note on today's mosques

    A questioner asked how the sunna of praying in shoes is clarified. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21984, 14 October 2012) answered that there is no harm in praying in shoes — for the command to differ from the Jews who do not pray in their sandals — but the mosques in the Prophet's day were not carpeted as they are today, the answer weighing present-day mosque cleanliness.

    Original page

  • Trimming the beard — the default is letting it grow

    A questioner asked about trimming the beard generally — not to a fistful — having heard one of the four imams permitted it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76957, 27 November 2008) answered that the default is letting the beard grow, except when it grows unsightly; then what removes the unsightliness is taken, the rest remaining on the default of letting grow — and the report that the Prophet used to take from his beard's length and breadth was not established.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer