Scholars congratulating Christians on their feasts

تهنئة النصارى بأعيادهم عند بعض العلماء

A questioner asked whether scholars congratulating Christians on their feasts have any precedent or proof. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78925, 20 May 2009) answered that the default is kindness and equity toward covenant non-Muslims, into which some counted among the learned fold congratulations on their feasts — but that is open to question, since the sound view is that feasts are among the rites, per 'for every community We appointed a rite they observe'; sharing in them or congratulating on them is not permissible, while kindness and equity continue in all else. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

Depth
Wing

Words

Qur'an, hadith, poetry, and the languages and scripts of Muslim peoples.
Related

Millet

Millet is the Turkish rendering of Arabic milla, meaning religion, religious community and nation, three senses used side by side in the Ottoman Empire until the Tanzimat and after. The Encyclopaedia of Islam stresses that the so-called millet system was not one institution but a set of largely social arrangements varying with time and place, and that the word was not used exclusively or consistently for non-Muslim communities before the nineteenth century.