What jurists mean by a sound and a weak opinion

القول الصحيح والضعيف عند الفقهاء

A questioner asked what jurists mean by 'sound' and 'weak' opinions, the criterion of soundness, whether acting on either of two sound views is valid, and the wording of the need-sermon. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77736, 7 February 2009) answered that soundness in jurists' opinions is relative — sound to one mujtahid may not be to another — but a mujtahid calling a view sound means it is what evidence-examination requires and reflection witnesses; the measure of soundness is the view's agreement with the proof under his adopted principles; a diversity-difference allows acting on either view, but a contradictory difference requires seeking the preponderant and acting on what one's judgment holds nearer the right and more in keeping with the Lawgiver's intent; a lay questioner is referred to his mufti for the weighing.

Depth

At a glance

This entry is a record so far, without an article. The facts and connections below come from the museum's data.

Connections

Explore the connections

About
Fiqh· Taqlid

People and things also explored

Putting the weightier first, and the layman's following· Judgement on one witness and the claimant's oath· The four kinds of muftis· Bughat (rebels against the imam)· Bay' al-istijrar (sale on running account)· Bay' al-ta'ati (sale by conduct)· Itq (manumission)· Kasad al-nuqud (when money stops circulating or changes in value)

Sources

  • Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (amjaonline.org)

Original page

Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “What jurists mean by a sound and a weak opinion”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/work/fatwa-amja-sound-vs-weak-opinion/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-17.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Words

Qur'an, hadith, poetry, and the languages and scripts of Muslim peoples.
Related

Putting the weightier first, and the layman's following

A questioner asked whether the weightier must come first, and whether he may follow Ibn Humam al-Hanafi's view that patching between madhhabs is valid absolutely. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78360, 27 March 2009) answered that when two matters conflict, scripture and reason both commend advancing the weightier: two benefits unattainable together — prefer the weightier; two harms unavoidable — ward off the graver first, the sharia being built on securing and completing benefits and disabling and minimizing harms; as for taqlid, the sound view is that the layman has no madhhab of his own — his madhhab is that of his mufti: when an issue befalls him he raises it to one he trusts in religion and learning, acts on the fatwa and is cleared, God not having bound him to seek one particular imam's opinion.