Fatwas on The contract (aqd): elements, offer and acceptance, and its kinds 7 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of The contract (aqd): elements, offer and acceptance, and its kinds

  • Court compensation for an employee who left a fixed-term contract

    A question about court compensation for an employee who left a fixed-term contract, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that the employee may claim the rights labour law guarantees him and take the compensation the judge awarded, except the legal interest, if his claim involved no lying or forgery. The Department answered that the principle is that a contract is the law of the contracting parties, so its terms must be respected, citing Surat al-Ma'ida 5:1 and a hadith that al-Bukhari cites in suspended form with certainty, whose meaning is that Muslims are bound by their conditions. It said the employee may claim the compensation that labour law sets for arbitrary dismissal, since the law was made to protect the interests of both worker and employer, a ruler's measures are tied to the public interest, and the law has the standing of general custom; what is customary counts as stipulated, so its provisions are implicitly part of every employment contract in the country. It concluded that he may take what the judge awarded under the law, provided there was no lying or forgery, except the legal interest; piety suggests that if he sees the award as larger than the harm he suffered, he takes the equivalent of his harm and leaves the rest.

    Original page

  • A sale with a condition of free maintenance for the product's expected life

    A question from a seller of used household appliances whose customer stipulated maintenance of the devices he bought for their expected lifespan after the warranty had expired; Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that a buyer's stipulating that the seller maintain the devices throughout their known and agreed expected life, for a known consideration, is permissible in sharia and does not contradict the nature of the contract. Dar al-Ifta recalled the general conditions of contracts, namely capacity, consent, the absence of excessive uncertainty and freedom from forbidden conditions, citing the hadith that Muslims are bound by their conditions except one that forbids the lawful or permits the forbidden; it defined the expected life by the Consumer Protection Agency's decision 1/4 of 2022, and characterised the transaction as a sale with a condition, which the majority of Malikis, Shafi'is and Hanbalis allow so long as the condition does not contradict the contract or lead to uncertainty, quoting Ibn Rushd, al-Kharashi, al-Zurqani, al-Nawawi, Ibn Rajab and al-Hajjawi. To forestall dispute it required that the parts and work covered be specified, whether spare parts are included or only the cost of repair, and whether a known consideration is paid, on the strength of the rule that there is no harm and no reciprocating harm, and it referred to resolution 103 (6/11) of the Islamic Fiqh Academy, which treated maintenance stipulated on the seller for a known period as a permissible sale with a condition.

    Original page

  • Subletting a rented flat to someone other than its owner

    A question about a man who rented a residential flat and wished to let it to someone other than its owner; Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that a tenant may sublet the rented property without blame in sharia, provided the second lease causes no damage to the property, that the property is of a kind whose use does not vary from person to person, and that the second rent may exceed the first, though it is preferable that the tenant has added something to the property that justifies asking more, to avoid the disagreement of those jurists who require it; all of this is conditional on not breaching the agreement with the owner and on complying with the laws that govern the tenancy and their restrictions. Dar al-Ifta set out the legitimacy of leasing from the Qur'an, the Sunna and consensus, attributed the permissibility of a tenant's subletting to the majority of Hanafis, Malikis, Shafi'is and, on the sounder view, Hanbalis, and to a group of early jurists, and explained it by the tenant's having acquired ownership of the use through the first lease, so he may dispose of it, and by the analogy that a lease is like a sale and sold goods may be resold once taken into possession. It reported the Hanafi condition that where the second rent is higher the tenant must have improved the property, otherwise he gives the excess in charity, quoted al-Kasani, Ibn Maza, al-Hattab, al-Shirazi and al-Buhuti, and referred to article 593 of the Egyptian Civil Code and to article 18 of Law 136 of 1981, which allows the owner to seek eviction when a tenant under an old-rent contract sublets without express written permission.

    Original page

  • Transferring a land-allocation place for a premium

    A question about a woman who reserved a plot of land with the authority of one of Egypt's new urban communities and paid the reservation deposit, then was offered by another person to take her place in the allocation in return for refunding what she had paid plus an extra sum known as an 'over'; Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that transferring the place and taking the money without going through the competent authority and before meeting its conditions is forbidden, because it circumvents the rules and infringes the right of the next person in line, while taking the premium is valid in sharia if it happens after the authority approves the transfer and the regulations are met, with both parties consenting. Dar al-Ifta explained that the city authority belongs to the New Urban Communities Authority, created by Law 59 of 1979, and quoted Cabinet Decree 2904 of 1995 forbidding disposal of the land within ten years of receipt without the written approval of the authority's head. It grounded the validity of a consensual transfer in the hadith that a Muslim's property is lawful only with his willing consent and in the default validity of contracts and conditions, and grounded the prohibition of the roundabout transfer in the prohibition of legal devices (hiyal), quoting Ibn Hazm, Ibn Qudama, al-Shatibi and al-Khattabi.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution on concluding contracts by modern communication devices

    IIFA's sixth-session resolution (Jeddah, March 1990) on contracts by modern communication: contracting between present parties requires unity of session, offer matching acceptance, and immediacy per custom; where absent parties use an instantaneous medium, their contract carries the ruling of present parties, as the resolution details.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution on the istisna' (manufacture-order) contract

    IIFA's seventh-session resolution (Mecca, May 1992) on istisna': the manufacture-order contract — covering work and a described item owed — binds both parties once its pillars and conditions hold; it requires specifying the manufactured item's kind, type, quantity and required features plus a stated term; the whole price may be deferred or instalments set, as detailed.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution on the arbitration principle in Islamic fiqh

    IIFA's ninth-session resolution (Abu Dhabi, April 1995) on arbitration in Islamic fiqh: arbitration is the agreement of two disputing parties to empower one who settles their dispute by a binding ruling applying the sharia; it is lawful between individuals and in international disputes; it is a non-binding contract either party may withdraw from until the arbitrator begins — with the rest detailed.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer