Fatwas on Bid'a (religious innovation) 10 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
- The Ahbash group's strife among Ethiopia's Muslims
A questioner asked about the Lebanese Ahbash group stirring strife among Ethiopia's Muslims and dividing their ranks, in his account with official support. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85691, 18 October 2011) answered that their ruling had been set out — their method being innovation in creed and approach and misguided in many creed and practice matters, in AMJA's view — and quoted the Saudi Permanent Committee's answer on Abdullah al-Harari al-Habashi calling him a head of innovation and misguidance and holding it a duty to warn against the group, as quoted. Recorded as AMJA's answer citing the committee.
- The aqiqa hair custom
A questioner asked about some Muslims' aqiqa custom of collecting the boy's shaved hair in a paper placed in the shroud when he dies. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86468, 22 February 2012) answered that they know of no evidence for it and that, as far as their knowledge goes, it is among the newly invented practices that should be done away with. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- A litany praying for named saints — a Moroccan wird reviewed
A questioner cited the litany of Morocco's al-Adl wal-Ihsan movement praying by name for the saints — al-Junayd, al-Fudayl ibn Iyad, Bishr al-Hafi, Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani and others. Dr. Walid ibn Idris al-Munaysi (fatwa no. 2085, 10 November 2006) answered that among those named are righteous saints, straying misleaders, and some whose state is not truly known; he therefore disapproves of using this prayer — all the more since it was not the Prophet's way to keep daily litanies praying for saints or righteous men by name, and the best guidance is his guidance; the transmitted general prayer suffices: seeking forgiveness for believing men and women, and 'our Lord, forgive us and our brothers who preceded us in faith, and place not in our hearts any rancour toward the believers'.
- Celebrating the Prophet's birthday
A questioner who learned from Sunni shaykhs that celebrating the Prophet's birthday is an impermissible innovation met objectors with interpretations. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78159, 11 March 2009) answered that the turning of some toward such interpretations away from the path of the righteous forebears should not grieve him: far and near know worship is textual, and those who perform these celebrations do so as devotion and worship — yet the virtuous generations were free of them, and they loved the Prophet more and knew his sunna and way better; as for dreams, they cannot establish a sharia ruling, especially where the virtuous generations ran otherwise — he should not dispute beyond an open argument and occupy himself with what benefits him of worship. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Praying behind an innovating imam in Europe
A Muslim resident of a European country who moved next to a mosque prayed its five prayers behind two imams trained in particular schools. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21853, 29 January 2007) answered that whoever's prayer is valid for himself is valid for others, and a Muslim's prayer stands unless he clearly engages a nullifier of Islam expelling him beyond dispute; leaving prayer behind innovators or sinners is of the order of disciplining them and warning against their sedition, not because the prayer itself is void — the forebears did not declare individual Jahmites disbelievers though they called some of their tenets disbelief or shirk; so if prayer behind innovators can be left without a greater corruption, it should be — guarding the sunna and deterring the innovator and the commonalty. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The Qubaysiyyat — the standing committee's fatwa on them
A commenter objected to the shaykh's ruling on the Qubaysiyyat, claiming its material came only from the Ahbash. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21832, 26 June 2006) answered that what was said of the Qubaysiyyat is not what the Ahbash alone disparage them with — though enmity exists between the two groups — for the Saudi standing committee for ifta issued fatwa no. 16011 dated 18/5/1414 AH against them, the committee having no link to the Ahbash; the answer reproduces its text. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Opening the mushaf for guidance — sortilege, not consultation
A questioner described his habit when a problem comes: opening the mushaf at random and taking the verse his eye lands on as God's answer. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21852, 16 December 2006) answered that it is true the worshipper converses with his Lord in prayer and finds God's command and prohibition in the Qur'an — but sortilege with the Qur'an in the manner described has no basis; it belongs to the order of divining by arrows, a bid'a among innovations and a wrong among wrongs.
- The Tablighi Jamaat — Sunnis in general, with cautions
A questioner asked whether the Tablighi Jamaat are Sunnis and whether going out with them is lawful, or innovators to be shunned, having grown numerous in Egypt. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21845, 25 August 2006) answered that the Tablighi Jamaat is an Islamic preaching and exhorting body of the Sunnis in general, whose members serve the call to God and carry Islam's virtues to Muslims and non-Muslims; it was founded by Shaykh Muhammad Ilyas al-Kandahlawi of India (1303–1364 AH), and among their virtues are sincerity — whose signs are seen on them — and a high resolve in preaching; the answer then details particular sharia reservations about them. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- What is the misguided innovation
A questioner who keeps hearing 'innovation' from the shaykhs and students asked for an explanation of the misguided innovation. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78452, 3 April 2009) answered that bida is whatever is newly made in the religion, not of it, intended as worship of God — or as al-Shatibi defined it, a contrived religious way resembling the lawful, the following of which aims at exaggeration in worshipping God; whatever is of this kind is blameworthy per 'every novelty is innovation, every innovation misguidance', and among the finest and most useful books on the matter is al-Shatibi's al-I'tisam.
- Who are the Qubaysiyyat
A questioner asked who the Qubaysiyyat are, they vehemently denying what is written about them online. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21839, 14 May 2006) answered that the Qubaysiyyat are a female esoteric Sufi order named after Munira al-Qubaysi, a contemporary Syrian woman; they preach an extravagant Sufism and many innovations, and disclose their true business to a novice only after she has spent long with them and they feel her full loyalty; each country's circle has an 'anisa' — a sheikha — the great anisa being Munira herself in Syria, her disciples extravagant in venerating her, as in many Sufi orders. Recorded as AMJA's answer.