Fatwas on The vow (nadhr) and its rulings 9 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of The vow (nadhr) and its rulings

  • Vow and expiation money left unspent for years in a charity's account

    A question from a charity that collects vows and expiations and has held some of the money for years without spending it, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that the charity is an agent forbidden to delay delivery without excuse; if delayed, the money must be delivered at once with repentance, and if lost it must be made good. The Department answered that charities act as agents for those who owe expiations and vows in delivering them to those entitled, so those running them must hasten to do so and may not delay without excuse; the money is a trust that must be safeguarded. It cited al-Shirwani's glosses on Tuhfat al-Muhtaj, reporting from al-Tatimma that an expiation is due immediately if the broken oath was itself a sin, and al-Khatib al-Shirbini in Mughni al-Muhtaj that the recipients' need is immediate, so one who delays is sinful and liable if the money is lost. It said that an agent who delays delivering any expiation or vow without excuse is sinful and must hasten to deliver it to clear his liability, with repentance and seeking forgiveness, and is liable to make it good if it is lost through his failure. It concluded that delaying delivery of expiations and vows to those entitled without a legal excuse is forbidden; if they have been delayed, they must be delivered immediately with repentance, and if lost they must be made good.

    Original page

  • Performing a vowed umrah before the vow's condition is met

    A question from someone who vowed an umrah if he received money owed to him and then performed it before receiving the money, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that the safer course is to wait for the condition, and that someone who acted early and cannot repeat the act is discharged on the Hanbali view. The Department answered that a vow is a commitment to an act of devotion the sharia does not require, which must be fulfilled once made, and that scholars differ on fulfilling a conditional vow before its condition is met. The Shafi'is allow a financial vow to be fulfilled early but not a bodily one, and count hajj and umrah as bodily, quoting Zakariyya al-Ansari's Asna al-Matalib, and Imam al-Haramayn al-Juwayni's Nihayat al-Matlab that proxy hajj is a concession for necessity. The Hanafis hold that what is done before the condition is voluntary and must be repeated, quoting al-Shurunbulali's Maraqi al-Falah, while the Hanbalis allow early fulfilment, quoting al-Buhuti's Kashshaf al-Qina'. It concluded that the safer course is for the person to wait until the condition is met, so that he is discharged by consensus, but if he has already performed the vowed act and cannot repeat it, he may be judged discharged on the Hanbali view.

    Original page

  • Vowing to fast a whole year

    A question about vowing to fast a whole year, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that a vow for a specific year excludes the Eids, the days of tashriq, Ramadan and days of menstruation and postnatal bleeding with no make-up, and that a vow for an unspecified year binds continuity if stipulated and requires making up those days except menstruation and postnatal bleeding. The Department answered that whoever vows to fast a specific year does not include in the vow the Eid, the days of tashriq, Ramadan, or days of menstruation and postnatal bleeding, and these days are not made up. It said that whoever vows to fast an unspecified year must fast continuously if he stipulated continuity, does not fast the days of Eid, Ramadan and menstruation, but must make up those days except the days of menstruation and postnatal bleeding. It quoted the Hashiya of al-Bajuri on Ibn Qasim's commentary (2/606) that Ramadan admits no other fast and that Eid and tashriq admit no fast at all, so they are excluded by the law from a specific-year vow and do not break continuity, noting there the disagreement of al-Rafi'i over menstruation and postnatal days in a specific year, and the view of Ibn al-Rif'a that menstruation days in an unspecified year must be made up as in Ramadan.

    Original page

  • A vow to fast a month, consecutiveness not required

    A man vowed to fast a month upon Libya's liberation, fasted fifteen days then stopped, and asked whether consecutiveness is required or the days may be split. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86132, 12 December 2011) answered that whoever vows to obey God should obey Him — a vow to fast is an obedience-vow and must be fulfilled; since he did not stipulate consecutiveness it is not binding, and completing the count suffices.

    Original page

  • The vow

    A questioner asked about a vow he had made. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 87070, 6 July 2012) answered that he must fulfil it because it is a vow of obedience, not of disobedience; that he may not eat of it nor feed his children from it according to the majority of scholars; and that it goes to the zakat recipients such as the poor and needy and the like.

    Original page

  • Vows uttered during afflictions

    A questioner who keeps promising God certain acts if He delivers him from affliction — sincerely meaning them, then not doing them — asked about it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86169, 18 December 2011) answered that whoever vows to obey God should obey Him and whoever vows to disobey Him should not disobey; his is a conditional vow, which is disliked — a vow brings nothing but draws something out of the miser — yet since its object is obedience it must be fulfilled; whoever cannot fulfil his vow is released by an oath's expiation. He advised fulfilling his vows, gauging them by his best judgment, paying an oath-expiation out of caution for what lapsed, and leaving off such vows in future. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • A vow conditioned on God's will

    A questioner asked about a vow he conditioned on God's will, saying 'I have vowed to God a sheep's slaughter, God willing.' Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21494) answered that nothing is due from one who attached the exception to the vow — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The expiation of a vow for one unable to fulfil it

    A questioner asked about the expiation of a vow for one unable to fulfil it. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22536) answered that a Muslim must fulfil the vow as it stands so long as he is able; if he cannot for a disability expected to lift, no expiation is due for the present — and the answer sets out when expiation becomes obligatory and what it is.

    Original page

  • Does a promise to give charity on getting a job count as a vow, and what if one is unsure?

    A question from a man who, in great distress, prayed to God promising that if he were accepted for a job he would give twenty per cent of his salary in charity and raise the share as his salary rose; he cannot be sure whether he used the word 'vow', was accepted, forgot what he had said for about three years while keeping up a monthly charity, then feared it might have been a vow and was terrified by the verse on breaking a promise to God. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that saying 'I promise You, Lord, that if I get a job I will give such-and-such in charity' is not by itself a vow, because a vow is concluded only by a wording that conveys commitment, and a mere promise becomes a vow only when accompanied by an intention, in which case it is an allusive form, and a vow is concluded by allusive wording on the correct view, quoting al-Khatib al-Shirbini in Mughni al-Muhtaj and al-Ramli in Nihayat al-Muhtaj. It ruled that where he is in doubt whether he uttered the word 'vow' or had the intention at the time of the promise, the default is that he did not, so nothing is binding on him, relying on the principle of presuming the original state and the freedom of one's obligations as set out by al-Izz ibn Abd al-Salam in Qawa'id al-Ahkam; if he becomes certain that he vowed in express words or by allusion with intention, he must fulfil it, what he has already given with the intention of fulfilling the vow counts, and he completes the rest, because a vow must be fulfilled and may not be released except through complete inability, according to the hadith that whoever vows to obey God should obey Him.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer