Fatwas on Dalil (evidence in the principles of jurisprudence) 4 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
The museum's record of Dalil (evidence in the principles of jurisprudence)
- Acting on preponderance in worship
A questioner said he had found no proof permitting reliance on conjecture in worship, only proofs forbidding it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77894, 19 February 2009) answered that zann is the outweighing of one side of possibility, unlike doubt which is the mind's equal wavering between two things; among fiqh's proofs some are certain in transmission and indication, and some conjectural in one or the other where one side outweighs without reaching certainty — yet acting on the preponderant is agreed among scholars; conjecture is blameworthy generally in the creed-chapter, which is built on certainty.
- The conditions of excusable coercion
A questioner asked whether the coerced is excused unconditionally, and whether one who says 'in that case I would have done it' — aloud or in himself — is excused. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77741, 7 February 2009) answered that coercion-questions are delicate and branching; the essence: sharia coercion is forcing another into an act he neither wills nor accepts, and the conditions for the coerced to be excused are the coercer's power to carry out his threat, the coerced's fear of it, the threat being killing, loss of a limb or what ranks as such — distress removing consent — that the coerced would have refrained but for the coercion, that the act's object is definite, and that he has no way out, as detailed.
- Necessity and hardship — al-Suyuti's two kinds of mashaqqa
A questioner asked whether 'necessity' means hardship, and what roughly delimits hardship since it cannot be pinned except approximately by the sharia's rules. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 619, 23 May 2005) answered that among the fiqh maxims are 'hardship brings ease' and 'when a matter narrows it widens'; al-Suyuti delimited the hardship that brings ease into two kinds: a hardship worship is rarely free of — cold in wudu and washing, fasting in fierce heat and long days, travel inseparable from hajj and jihad, the pain of penalties — which never drops the duties at any time; and a hardship occurring only sometimes, which is subject to consideration since the law regards people's states — as the answer details.
- IIFA resolution 257 (2/26) on istishab (presumption of continuity) and its applications in contemporary cases
A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 26th session in Doha (6–10 Dhu al-Qa'da 1446, 4–8 May 2025). It defined istishab as ruling that a state of affairs continues in a later time because it was established in an earlier time, absent anything requiring change, and ruled that it is a sharia evidence that creates no new ruling but sustains an existing one. The jurist takes the ruling of a new case from the presumption of continuity in negation and affirmation: if the doubt concerns its lapse, the default is its continuance; if it concerns its establishment, the default is that it is not established. The resolution stated its importance for ijtihad in worship, financial transactions, personal status, sharia policy and the judiciary, and set three controls: predominant belief that no contrary evidence or cause exists after exhaustive search, regard for the general and particular objectives of the sharia, and that only those qualified for ijtihad may apply it to cases.