Fatwas on The dead person (mayyit) and the rules of the funeral 4 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
The museum's record of The dead person (mayyit) and the rules of the funeral
- Cremation where Muslim burial is opposed
A question about cremation where Muslim burial is opposed, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that cremating a corpse is forbidden because it degrades the dead and violates their dignity, and that a way must be found to bury the dead according to the Shari'a, even by moving the body to another area. The Department answered that Islam honours the human being alive and dead, including by washing, shrouding, praying over and burying the dead, citing Surat al-Isra' 17:70 and a hadith narrated by Abu Dawud in his Sunan whose meaning is that breaking a dead person's bone is like breaking it while alive. It said burning the corpse is forbidden because it harms, demeans and degrades the dead and erases the features of the body, noting that jurists disallowed carrying out retaliation in a way that ruins the body, and quoting al-Juwayni in Nihayat al-Matlab (16/147) that some Shafi'is disallowed retaliation by poison to protect the corpse, since the body of the dead is inviolable. It concluded that a way must be found to bury the dead in accordance with the Shari'a, even if that requires moving the body to another area where burial is possible.
- Moving a deceased person's remains to a family cemetery
A question about moving a deceased person's remains to a family cemetery, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that a grave may not be opened and the remains moved while the deceased's bones remain in it, and that difficulty of visiting is not a necessity that permits exhumation, since one can pray for the deceased from afar and visit at longer intervals. The Department answered that the deceased has sanctity and dignity, citing Surat al-Isra' 17:70, and that graves may not be opened or removed while the bones of the dead remain in them; bones decay only after hundreds of years, as observed in the country. It cited, as evidence that the dead have the same sanctity as the living, a hadith narrated by Abu Dawud whose meaning is that breaking a dead person's bone is like breaking it while he is alive, and a hadith narrated by Muslim whose meaning is that sitting on an ember that burns through one's clothes to the skin is better than sitting on a grave; part of the deceased's dignity is that his grave not be opened or his sanctity violated. It said the place where a person is buried counts as an endowment for him, and burial in a public cemetery is better so that more people pray for and visit the dead; since he was buried in a private cemetery, there is no need or necessity to move him near his family so they can visit and pray for him, since prayer can be made from afar, and visits can be made at longer intervals if they are difficult. It concluded that the grave may not be opened unless the remains have fully decayed.
- Muslim workers building a Christian cemetery
A question whether Muslim labourers may work on building a Christian cemetery in which Christian dead will be buried; Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that Muslim workers may build and prepare cemeteries for non-Muslims, including the Christians of their country and others, since this is kindness and good dealing, the principle in dealing with non-Muslims being justice and kindness by the text of the verse of al-Mumtahana; it is among the rights of protected non-Muslims and a sign of God's honouring of the human being in the verse of al-Isra. The Sunna, the reports of the early Muslims and the jurists' statements allow a Muslim to lend a hand, whether for pay or voluntarily, to non-Muslims in what upholds human dignity, including their burial: the Prophet ordered Ali to bury Abu Talib, who died outside Islam, as in al-Nasa'i's Sunan, and Ibn Abbas said of a Christian with a Muslim son that the son should have followed his bier and buried him. The Department quoted al-Juwayni in Nihayat al-Matlab that shrouding and burying a non-Muslim who has no guardian of his own faith is a collective duty on the Muslims, al-Shirbini in Mughni al-Muhtaj that the sounder view is that shrouding and burying a protected non-Muslim is obligatory from the treasury and then on the Muslims, and al-Buhuti in Kashshaf al-Qina' that there is no harm in digging a grave for a protected non-Muslim for a fee; so there is no blame on a Muslim who works on non-Muslim cemeteries.
- Burying the dead in a coffin inside the grave
A question about placing the dead in a coffin when necessary, as for a drowned person or one whose body has begun to decay, and whether he is buried in the grave together with the coffin; Shaykh Ibn Baz answered that a drowned person carried from one country to another is placed in the grave without harm, that if taking the body out of the coffin is feared to harm people it stays in it and is not taken out, while if it does no harm the body is taken out and laid in the niche of the grave; but if taking it out would hurt people and its smell would distress them, it is buried in the coffin and that suffices. He closed with a prayer for success and for soundness of intention and action.