Fatwas on Nafaqa (maintenance) 5 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
- A married daughter who reduced her financial help to her mother
A question about a married daughter who reduced what she gave her widowed mother, after which the mother cut her off, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that reducing support for a valid reason is not undutifulness, that a needy mother's maintenance falls on all her children, and that the mother may not sever ties with her daughter. The Department answered that Islam calls for kindness to parents and helping them with effort and money, and courtesy towards them, especially in old age. It said a needy mother's maintenance is shared among her sons and daughters to the extent of her needs, citing article 197 of Jordan's Personal Status Law, which obliges a child of means to maintain poor parents, so some children may not bear it alone if all are able. If the mother's needs are met, she may not load her daughter with more than she needs, and in any case she may not cut off her daughter or order her children to do so, since that is ordering the severing of kinship ties; it quoted Ibn Hajar al-Haytami's al-Zawajir on what makes cutting kin forbidden. It concluded that the daughter should stay kind and obedient to her mother, and that reducing support in the way described is not undutifulness if she is excused by an income that does not suffice.
- Taking zakat while holding an emergency fund
A question from partners in a grocery who saved an emergency fund while their salaries fall short, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that zakat is due on saved money that reaches the threshold and completes a year, and that the payer may not take his own zakat for himself. The Department answered that whoever owns the threshold amount for a full year must pay zakat to those entitled to it, whatever the reason for saving the money, and that God set out its recipients in the Qur'an. It said the payer may not pay it to himself, since that is neither paying nor transferring ownership, so he cannot be payer and recipient at once; nor may he give it, as relief for poverty, to those he must maintain; it quoted al-Khatib al-Shirbini's al-Iqna' on this. It concluded that the payer may not take his own zakat for himself, nor give it as poverty relief to dependants such as parents, wife and young children, while he holds savings he can spend from.
- The consolation gift (mut'a) for a wife who sought divorce because of harm
A question about a woman who brought a case before the judge seeking divorce from her husband for harm, and whether she is entitled to the consolation gift (mut'a) after divorce or whether her request counts as consent to the divorce that forfeits it; Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that the mut'a is money a husband pays to a wife he divorces after consummation, amounting to at least two years' maintenance according to his means, assessed by agreement or, in dispute, by the court, and that it is conditional on the divorce not coming from the wife or being caused by her, so that if the divorce was with her consent it lapses, but if it came at her request because she was harmed it does not lapse, since the consent that forfeits it is absent. Dar al-Ifta explained the meaning of the mut'a from al-Kharashi's commentary and Mughni al-Muhtaj; that it is obligatory by agreement for a woman divorced before consummation with no dower named, recommended in other cases according to the majority of Hanafis, Malikis and Hanbalis in one report, and obligatory according to the Shafi'is and in a view of Ahmad chosen by Ibn Taymiyya; that its amount depends on the husband's means by the text of the verse of al-Baqara; and that the four schools hold it to lapse in any separation that comes from the wife or is caused by her, such as khul', quoting al-Kasani, Ibn Juzayy, al-Rafi'i and Ibn Qudama. It referred to article 18 bis of Law 25 of 1929, added by Law 100 of 1985, which grants a wife divorced without her consent a mut'a of at least two years' maintenance, and to a 1997 ruling of the Egyptian Court of Cassation that a wife's resort to the judge for divorce on grounds of harm does not amount to consent to the divorce.
- Giving zakat to a needy divorced wife for her medical treatment
A question about whether a zakat payer may give his zakat to his divorced wife so that she can have a necessary operation she cannot afford; Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that if the divorce is revocable the zakat does not count when paid to her from the share of the poor and needy, because she remains in the position of a wife for as long as her waiting period lasts and her maintenance, including medical treatment, is his duty, which makes her well-off in that respect; if she qualifies for zakat on a ground other than poverty, such as being a debtor, he may give it to her; and if the divorce is final, whether of the lesser or the greater kind, she has become a stranger to him and he may pay her from his zakat whenever she meets one of the descriptions of the eight categories, her entitlement being all the stronger when she is both needy and ill. Dar al-Ifta quoted Imam al-Haramayn that a revocably divorced woman is a wife while in her waiting period, Ibn al-Mundhir on the scholars' consensus that a man does not give his wife zakat, Ulaysh, al-Shawkani and Egypt's Personal Status Law 25 of 1920 that treatment falls within maintenance, al-Khatib al-Shirbini that one may give to those he must maintain from the shares of the other categories, Ibn al-Qattan on the consensus that whoever distributes his zakat among the eight categories has discharged his duty, and al-Kasani and al-Shatibi on the purpose of zakat in helping the weak and preserving lives exposed to ruin.
- Repaying a wife's gold sold at her husband's request: by weight or by value?
A question from a wife whose dower, fixed in dinars, was spent on gold for her according to her country's custom; her husband later asked her to sell part of it for a need, promising to return it, and she sold the rest of her own accord to finish building their house on the understanding that he would return it too; the price of gold has since multiplied, so she asked whether she recovers the dower's value in dinars or the value of the gold, whether the engagement gift counts as part of the dower, and whether the husband must pay for her medical treatment. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that if the husband borrowed the gold itself from her and then had it sold, it is a debt he owes and he must return its like, not its value, whatever the change in its price, because debts are repaid in kind, as the Islamic Fiqh Academy resolved in Kuwait in 1988, unless the two agree on payment of its value, which is then assessed on the day of payment according to the hadith of Ibn Umar; the dinars in which the dower was named are irrelevant, since they were exchanged for gold that became her property. If instead she sold the gold herself and lent him the cash, the debt is the sum of money, with no regard to its gold value, as the Fiqh Encyclopaedia states. As for the engagement gift, whether counted as part of the dower or as a separate gift, it becomes the wife's sole property once the marriage is contracted and consummated, and if sold for the husband's need with a promise of return it is a debt like the rest of the gold. On the husband's bearing the cost of his wife's treatment, the centre noted a difference of opinion and referred to an earlier fatwa in which it said the view that it is obligatory on him is well founded in this age.