Ibn Abbas's Debate with the Khawarij

مناظرة ابن عباس للخوارج

38 AH

Ali ibn Abi Talib (may God be pleased with him) sent Abdallah ibn Abbas to argue with the Khawarij at Harura after they had taken to reading the Qur'an and pronouncing judgement on the people by it. He went out to them in a red turban and cloak and said: I come to you from the cousin of the Messenger of God ﷺ, and engaged them in Qur'anic disputation 1. He asked: what do you hold against the cousin of the Messenger of God? They said three things: he let men arbitrate in God's religion; he fought without taking captives or spoils; and he struck the title Commander of the Faithful from his name. He answered each from the Qur'an: arbitration like the two men who judge an offering for a game killed while consecrated and the arbitrators appointed over a quarrelling couple; the enemy he fought were a rebellious faction whose slain were not mutilated; and on the title he said he was easier to satisfy than God's Prophet, for you accepted 'Muhammad the Messenger of God' written at al-Hudaybiyya, which the polytheists erased to 'Muhammad son of Abdallah'. Two thousand of them returned and entered Ali's army; six thousand held out and were killed at al-Nahrawan 2.

Depth

At a glance

Era
The Rashidun Caliphate

Summary

The most famous intra-Muslim debate of the first generation: Ibn Abbas walks into the Khawarij camp at Harura, argues them down with the Qur'an and the Prophet's precedent, and two thousand of them return. 1 2

The sending

The Khawarij had seceded from Ali after the arbitration at Siffin and settled at Harura. Ali spoke to them and they would not return, so he told Ibn Abbas to go. Ibn Abbas said: I came to them in the finest dress the people of the House wore — a red turban. They said: welcome, Ibn Abbas, what is this turban? I said: what divides you and me is good; I come from the cousin and son-in-law of the Messenger of God, on whom revelation descended, and they know its interpretation better than you — I put my case to you and you argue back. Some said: do not argue with Quraysh, for God says 'they are a quarrelsome people'; but they let him speak 1.

The three objections and the answers

He asked: what do you hold against the cousin of the Messenger of God? Three things, they said. First, he let men arbitrate in God's religion though God says 'judgement belongs to God alone.' He answered: God made men judge in the case of 'whoever kills game while consecrated shall pay the like of what he killed, judged by two just men among you' — a judgement by men over a rabbit or game; is the judgement of men over the blood of Muslims and the mending of relations not worthier than a judgement over a rabbit? And for the wife estranged from her husband, 'if you fear a breach between them, send an arbitrator from his family and an arbitrator from hers.' Have I brought you out of this or not? They said: no 3.

Second: he fought without taking captives or spoils; if those he fought were God's friends they were wrongly fought, and if enemies, captivity and plunder were lawful. He answered: whom do you fight? Your mother Aisha, or others? Would you make your mother's captivity lawful as the captivity of foreigners? If you say she is your mother then she is, as God said, of the Mothers of the Believers; if you say she is not, you have disbelieved in her. Have I brought you out of this or not? No 3.

Third: he erased from himself the title Commander of the Faithful — if not the believers' commander he is the unbelievers' commander. He answered: of this I have what will please you. You heard that on the day of al-Hudaybiyya Ali wrote 'this is what Muhammad the Messenger of God agreed,' and the polytheists said: had we known you were God's Messenger we would not have kept you from the House; so the Messenger of God said 'erase it, Ali — God, you know I am Your Messenger — erase it and write son of Abdallah.' By God, the Messenger of God was better than Ali, and he erased his own name and did not erase himself from prophethood. Have I brought you out of this or not? No 3 4.

The return

Two thousand of them returned and entered Ali's ranks; six thousand held out, rose against the Uthmaniyya, and the affair of al-Nahrawan took its course 5. The debate thus stands as the model of arguing with the Qur'an itself against those who raised its slogan.

Bibliography

  • Imam Ahmad, al-Musnad, the hadith of Ibn Abbas on his argument with the Khawarij.
  • Ibn Kathir, al-Bidaya wa-l-Nihaya, the events of 38 AH.

Connections

Explore the connections

Had participant
Abdullah ibn Abbas· Ali ibn Abi Talib

People and things also explored

Ali appoints the sons of al-Abbas and Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr as governors· Ali burns people in Kufa who claimed he was God· Ali declines to keep Muawiya in office· The Hijra· Reported advice to Ali by Ibn Abbas and al-Mughira on keeping or removing Uthman's governors· Ibn ʿAbbās quits Basra for Mecca (40 AH)· The Prophet's last counsels in his final illness· The Companions

Sources

  1. Musnad Ahmad , 1/342-343
  2. al-Bidaya wa-l-Nihaya — Ibn Kathir , 7/283-284
  3. Musnad Ahmad , 1/343
  4. al-Bidaya wa-l-Nihaya — Ibn Kathir , 7/283
  5. al-Bidaya wa-l-Nihaya — Ibn Kathir , 7/284
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “Ibn Abbas's Debate with the Khawarij”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/event/ibn-abbas-khawarij-debate/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-16.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Time

Eras, timelines, this day in history, any year in the Islamic world.
Related

Ali appoints the sons of al-Abbas and Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr as governors

Ali gave the provinces to several sons of his cousin al-Abbas: Abdallah in Basra, Ubaydallah in Yemen and Bahrain, Qutham in Mecca and al-Ta'if, Tammam in Medina, and with them Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr, his step-son, in Egypt. The book sets this among a list of forty-one governors and holds that Ali and Uthman both appointed kin when their competence was clear, not for kinship alone.