IslamQA (islamqa.info) 7 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
- A brother advising his sister who does not wear hijab
A brother says his adult sister does not wear hijab, that their father, who runs the household, wants it so and has mistreated him for advising her, and asks whether he is sinning and how to deal with her. IslamQA answered that a brother does not bear sin merely because his adult sister goes uncovered, provided he has given the advice he is able to give; he should call her with wisdom and gentleness, attend to strengthening her faith and correcting her ideas, and keep up his ties with her rather than cutting them.
- May one ask artificial intelligence for a fatwa?
A question about turning to artificial-intelligence applications for answers on sharia matters and relying on their rulings, in which IslamQA answered that artificial intelligence is a permissible tool in principle, but that it may not be asked for fatwas nor relied upon in religious matters, because it lacks the qualifications of a mufti, namely understanding of the religion and of reality and the other conditions set out by al-Shafi'i and Ibn al-Qayyim, and because its answers are generated automatically from data that may be of unknown origin, mistaken or fabricated, may carry the biases of its trainers, and do not account for the way discretionary rulings change with custom and circumstance. The site distinguished artificial intelligence from fatwa websites, where real people answer, and said that a scholarly researcher may use it to gather material, find sources, summarise and understand reality provided every quotation is verified, and that a layman may use it to get a general idea or to ask for links to fatwas he then consults himself, as a smart search engine, but may not act on a fatwa the system generates by itself. It set out two contemporary approaches, outright prohibition or a distinction between fixed rulings that apply equally to everyone, where its answers may be used under four conditions, and rulings built on custom and circumstance, where they may not; the site judged the prohibiting approach the stronger in the present state of the technology.
- Is there a book giving the most cautious view on disputed questions?
A questioner asks for a fiqh book that gives, for every disputed question, the evidence and the most cautious view that takes one out of the disagreement, not only the preferred view. IslamQA answered that acting on caution is not always meritorious or always required, and that it knows of no single book that gives the most cautious view on every question of fiqh, setting out a definition of caution and quotations from scholars on legitimate scrupulousness.
- Is eating bread without a condiment forbidden?
A question on whether any prohibition on eating bread without a condiment has come down. IslamQA answered that it found no established hadith on this, that the basic ruling is that bread may be eaten alone or with whatever condiment is at hand, and that no one need go to trouble to obtain one, noting that the Prophet ate as his people ate, from whatever was available.
- Wiping over nail gel used to stop compulsive skin-picking
A woman who has for years compulsively picked the skin around her nails, causing wounds and infections, finds that a layer of gel on the nails curbs it, and asks about keeping it on during ablution and the full bath. IslamQA answered that the rule is to remove whatever keeps water from the nails, but if the gel is needed to prevent this harm and no suitable alternative is available, it may be kept and wiped over, on the ruling for a splint, for as long as the need lasts, while she seeks treatment for the compulsion.
- Why invoking blessings on the Prophet is increased on Friday
A question on why Friday is singled out for invoking blessings on the Prophet. IslamQA answered that invoking blessings on him is prescribed at all times, and what is particular to Friday is the encouragement to do it often, because of the merit of the day and because, as reported in the sunna, the blessings are presented to him on that day in a special way; scholars have suggested further wisdoms, and the basis remains obedience whether or not the wisdom is grasped.
- Are the practices of natural disposition (sunan al-fitra) five or ten, and what are they?
A question about reconciling Abu Hurayra's hadith that the practices of natural disposition are five with Aisha's hadith that they are ten, and about listing them all with the ruling on each; IslamQA answered that the number in the hadith is not a limit and its implication is not binding, as al-Nawawi and Ibn Daqiq al-Id say; that Aisha's hadith is disputed as to whether it is traced to the Prophet, Ahmad, al-Nasa'i and al-Daraqutni having faulted it so that the preserved version is a saying of Talq ibn Habib, alongside the hadith of Ammar ibn Yasir in Ahmad and Abu Dawud; and that the practices mentioned in the hadiths total fifteen, as Ibn Hajar says: circumcision, shaving the pubic hair, trimming the nails, plucking the armpits, trimming the moustache, letting the beard grow, the tooth-stick, rinsing the mouth, sniffing water into the nose, expelling it, washing the finger joints, shaving the pubes, cleansing after relieving oneself, sprinkling water, and parting the hair. It then set out the ruling on each: circumcision is obligatory for men and an honour for women according to Ibn Qudama and Ibn Uthaymin, lapsing where death is feared; shaving the pubic hair, trimming the nails, plucking the armpits and trimming the moustache are agreed Sunna practices, though Ibn Hazm, Ibn al-Arabi and Ibn al-Qayyim held trimming obligatory; letting the beard grow is obligatory and shaving it forbidden according to the majority; the tooth-stick is Sunna by consensus; washing the finger joints is recommended; rinsing the mouth and sniffing water are obligatory in ablution according to the Hanbalis and Ibn Taymiyya; expelling the water is Sunna; cleansing after relieving oneself is obligatory according to the majority; sprinkling is recommended for one troubled by doubts; parting the hair is Sunna and better than letting it hang according to Ibn Abd al-Barr; and leaving these practices beyond forty days is disliked according to the Shafi'is and Hanbalis and forbidden according to the Hanafis, a view chosen by al-Shawkani and Ibn Baz.