IslamWeb fatwa centre (islamweb.net) 14 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

  • Working in booking hotel rooms for attendees of various conferences

    A question from an executive employee whose job is to research conferences held in various countries and find cheaper hotel rates for attendees, passing the information up to his superior; some conferences may concern forbidden matters such as alcohol-industry conferences or fashion shows, and some hotels have casinos or bars, though he books only rooms. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that researching hotel prices and booking rooms for conference attendees is permissible work, being intermediation and guidance to a permissible benefit, the renting of lodgings, so the salary earned is lawful; but where it is known or strongly suspected that a conference's subject is forbidden, booking hotels for its attendees is facilitation of and assistance in the forbidden, prohibited in the verse of al-Ma'ida; for conferences whose subject is permissible or unknown there is no blame in booking for their attendees and no duty to investigate, nor is this barred by the presence of wrongdoing in those hotels, since the contract concerns the benefit of lodging. It ruled that he may continue in the work while avoiding assistance to forbidden conferences, and if his manager orders him to book for a conference he knows or strongly suspects to be forbidden he should decline, since no created being is obeyed in disobedience to the Creator; his salary is not judged forbidden so long as most of his work is permissible, and as a precaution he should give in charity a share of his salary matching the time he spent booking for forbidden conferences in the past, to clear his conscience.

    Original page

  • What to do with cashback earned on a riba-based credit card

    A question from an engineer living in a Western country who took out an American Express credit card to raise his credit score before learning that signing its contract is impermissible because of the riba-based penalties on late payment; he always paid on time, stopped using the card when he learned the ruling, and the company then paid him a cashback reward for his earlier use. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that he may not benefit from this cashback, because the issuing bank grants it for use of the forbidden card, so it is a conditional reward tied to the void contractual relationship and not an unconditional gift, and it takes on the same prohibition; forbidden benefits may not be exchanged for consideration. It quoted al-Qarafi in al-Dhakhira that forbidden benefits are not matched by consideration, and Ibn Aqil in Kitab al-Funun that Ahmad's school forbids the price of every forbidden thing, arguing from the hadith that when God forbids a thing He forbids its price. It required him to dispose of the money by spending it on the interests of Muslims and giving it to the poor and needy, and said that keeping and using the card is not permitted unless he needs it and finds no alternative free of sharia objections.

    Original page

  • Showing joy at a wedding with the daff, without extravagance

    A question from a fiancé whose fiancée wants a lawful, unmixed wedding in a hall with the daff and songs and no instruments, where the custom at women's weddings is not to observe modest dress and backbiting is common; he asked who bears the sin of such violations if they warn the guests about dress and backbiting, and feared that spending on the celebration might be misusing the provision God had given him. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that there is no blame in holding the celebration in the hall and no harm in some entertainment and beating the daff, citing the hadith 'announce this marriage', the hadith that what separates the lawful from the unlawful is the daff and the voice at a wedding, the report that entertainment at weddings was permitted, Aisha's hadith 'was there no entertainment with you, for the Ansar love entertainment', and Ahmad's statement, as quoted by Ibn Qudama, that it is recommended to make a marriage public and beat the daff for it and that there is no harm in verse at a wedding. It ruled that those who backbite or commit violations bring nothing upon the questioner if he does not approve and has warned and forbidden them, quoting Ibn Taymiyya on the difference between one who hears wrong while passing by and one who sits listening without objecting, and the saying that whoever witnesses a sin and hates it is as one absent from it. It advised avoiding affectation, extravagance and excess, citing the verses on squandering and extravagance, Umar's words 'we were forbidden affectation' and Salman's hadith forbidding excessive trouble for a guest, and reducing costs that lead to debt.

    Original page

  • Delaying payment in a currency exchange

    A question on whether a money-changer may defer handing over the sum after an exchange. The IslamWeb fatwa centre answered that when one currency is sold for another both must be handed over in the same sitting, citing the hand-to-hand hadith in Muslim's collection; delaying receipt of either counter-value, or any part of it, beyond the sitting is not permitted because it is a form of riba al-nasi'a, and it referred to further fatwas on riba al-nasi'a and riba al-fadl.

    Original page

  • Dreaming that one has uttered blasphemy

    A practising questioner dreamt that he had cursed God, a few days after overhearing someone do so in a phone call, and asks what the ruling is. The IslamWeb fatwa centre answered that he is not held to account for anything he sees himself saying or doing in a dream, because the sleeper is free of legal responsibility until he wakes, citing the hadith that the pen is lifted from three.

    Original page

  • Testifying that a man was the deceased's son so he could inherit, then learning he was adopted

    A question from a man who testified before a judge that a certain person was the son of a deceased man so that he could inherit, when the person was in fact adopted and registered in the family record as a son because the deceased could not have children; the questioner had earlier believed him to be a real son, then regretted it and asked whether this was false testimony and whether he owes an expiation. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that false testimony is testimony contrary to the truth and among the gravest of major sins by the hadith of Abu Bakra in Sahih al-Bukhari, and that its criterion according to Ibn Hajar is describing a thing contrary to what it is; so if at the time of his testimony he testified contrary to what he knew, he gave false testimony and must hasten to repent and seek forgiveness, and part of his repentance is to go to the court where he testified and declare his testimony void and that the person he testified for has no blood relationship with the deceased, as al-Iqna fi Hall Alfaz Abi Shuja states that repentance from a verbal sin is by speech, saying of false testimony 'my testimony is void and I regret it', together with restoring what was wrongfully taken from a person; and that this testimony may have many harmful consequences, since the person would inherit another's wealth and be attached to a particular family, so he should hasten to set right what he spoiled.

    Original page

  • Joining the imam for the last rak'a of the sunset prayer

    A question about someone who prayed the last rak'a of the sunset prayer with the imam. The IslamWeb fatwa centre answered that if he caught the bowing he has caught one rak'a and has two left; if he joined after the third bowing, in prostration or the final tashahhud, he completes with the imam and then prays three rak'as after the imam's closing salutation; the different shape of the made-up prayer does no harm, and he gains the reward of congregation, though less than one who joined from the start.

    Original page

  • Joining two prayers because of the symptoms of a medical test

    A question from a patient about to undergo a small-intestine bacterial overgrowth test, in which he is given a sugar solution that may cause diarrhoea, cramps and gas for hours or a whole day; he asked whether it is established that the Prophet joined two prayers in reality and whether he may join them because of these symptoms. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that it is established in Sahih Muslim from Ibn Abbas that the Prophet joined the noon and afternoon prayers and the sunset and night prayers in Medina without fear or rain, so as not to burden his community; some scholars read this as an apparent joining, but a number of careful scholars held it to be a real joining for illness or need, as al-Nawawi reports from Ahmad, Qadi Husayn, al-Khattabi, al-Mutawalli and al-Ruyani, and a group of imams allowed joining when resident for a need, for one who does not make it a habit. It ruled that the questioner may join the noon and afternoon prayers, and the sunset and night prayers, by advancing or delaying as is easier for his condition, to ward off the hardship of acute diarrhoea, recurrent gas and the burden of cleansing and ablution for each prayer; that medical treatment and tests are legitimate and he need not forgo the test; and that if the symptoms last through the whole time of the two prayers he is treated like those with a permanent excuse, such as urinary incontinence, so he purifies himself, performs ablution and prays the two prayers joined, unharmed by what leaves his body, quoting al-Buhuti in Kashshaf al-Qina' on the permission for a woman with chronic bleeding and those like her to join prayers on the strength of the hadith of Hamna.

    Original page

  • Rules for a male doctor examining and touching female patients

    A question about working in a medical profession that requires touching women without desire for the purpose of diagnosis, where female staff exist but the doctor cannot refuse to examine female patients because of the law in a Western country or the embarrassment and hardship of doing so in a Muslim country; the fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that the default is that a woman treats a woman and a man treats a man, that this default is departed from only for necessity or need, and that fear of death is not always required, ordinary medical need being enough, because the prohibition of looking and touching during treatment is a prohibition of means to block a path to harm, and what is forbidden in that way becomes permitted for a preponderant interest. It quoted this from Ibn Taymiyya in Majmu' al-Fatawa and Ibn al-Qayyim in Rawdat al-Muhibbin. It ruled that if the questioner needs this work and cannot refer the patient to a female doctor because of the hospital's rules, or would be harmed by refusing, there is no blame on him in examining women, while observing the rules: using a barrier during examination and touching, not touching the skin directly unless diagnosis through a barrier is impossible, confining looking and touching to the place the diagnosis requires, and avoiding unlawful seclusion; it quoted al-Buhuti in Kashshaf al-Qina' that a doctor may look at and touch what need requires, in the presence of a mahram or husband.

    Original page

  • Medical experiments on human beings

    A question on whether medical experiments on human beings are permitted and what their limits are. The IslamWeb fatwa centre's answer addressed the dissection of the dead: the sanctity of a Muslim remains after death, and he is owed washing, shrouding, the funeral prayer and burial; dissection is permitted only for a recognised benefit or a necessity, and only to that extent; it cited parallels from the early jurists, among them the Hanafi and Shafi'i view, with others, that a dead woman's abdomen may be opened to deliver a foetus whose life is hoped for.

    Original page

  • The merit of keeping the regular sunna prayers

    A question on the merit of the regular sunna prayers. The IslamWeb fatwa centre answered that their merit is great, citing the hadith of Umm Habiba in Muslim's collection that whoever prays twelve voluntary rak'as each day will have a house built in Paradise, and al-Tirmidhi's version that lists them: four before the noon prayer and two after it, two after the sunset prayer, two after the night prayer and two before the dawn prayer, then gave what is reported on the merit of particular ones.

    Original page

  • Does a promise to give charity on getting a job count as a vow, and what if one is unsure?

    A question from a man who, in great distress, prayed to God promising that if he were accepted for a job he would give twenty per cent of his salary in charity and raise the share as his salary rose; he cannot be sure whether he used the word 'vow', was accepted, forgot what he had said for about three years while keeping up a monthly charity, then feared it might have been a vow and was terrified by the verse on breaking a promise to God. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that saying 'I promise You, Lord, that if I get a job I will give such-and-such in charity' is not by itself a vow, because a vow is concluded only by a wording that conveys commitment, and a mere promise becomes a vow only when accompanied by an intention, in which case it is an allusive form, and a vow is concluded by allusive wording on the correct view, quoting al-Khatib al-Shirbini in Mughni al-Muhtaj and al-Ramli in Nihayat al-Muhtaj. It ruled that where he is in doubt whether he uttered the word 'vow' or had the intention at the time of the promise, the default is that he did not, so nothing is binding on him, relying on the principle of presuming the original state and the freedom of one's obligations as set out by al-Izz ibn Abd al-Salam in Qawa'id al-Ahkam; if he becomes certain that he vowed in express words or by allusion with intention, he must fulfil it, what he has already given with the intention of fulfilling the vow counts, and he completes the rest, because a vow must be fulfilled and may not be released except through complete inability, according to the hadith that whoever vows to obey God should obey Him.

    Original page

  • Repaying a wife's gold sold at her husband's request: by weight or by value?

    A question from a wife whose dower, fixed in dinars, was spent on gold for her according to her country's custom; her husband later asked her to sell part of it for a need, promising to return it, and she sold the rest of her own accord to finish building their house on the understanding that he would return it too; the price of gold has since multiplied, so she asked whether she recovers the dower's value in dinars or the value of the gold, whether the engagement gift counts as part of the dower, and whether the husband must pay for her medical treatment. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that if the husband borrowed the gold itself from her and then had it sold, it is a debt he owes and he must return its like, not its value, whatever the change in its price, because debts are repaid in kind, as the Islamic Fiqh Academy resolved in Kuwait in 1988, unless the two agree on payment of its value, which is then assessed on the day of payment according to the hadith of Ibn Umar; the dinars in which the dower was named are irrelevant, since they were exchanged for gold that became her property. If instead she sold the gold herself and lent him the cash, the debt is the sum of money, with no regard to its gold value, as the Fiqh Encyclopaedia states. As for the engagement gift, whether counted as part of the dower or as a separate gift, it becomes the wife's sole property once the marriage is contracted and consummated, and if sold for the husband's need with a promise of return it is a debt like the rest of the gold. On the husband's bearing the cost of his wife's treatment, the centre noted a difference of opinion and referred to an earlier fatwa in which it said the view that it is obligatory on him is well founded in this age.

    Original page

  • Which facial hair counts as the beard, and the rules for trimming it

    A question from a young man whose beard has not yet grown in fully, only the sideburn hair reaching an inch or two below the ear, asking whether this hair counts as the beard and is subject to its rulings, and how much he may trim given his uneven appearance; the fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered by distinguishing the kinds of hair: the temple hair level with the top of the ear belongs to the hair of the head, not the beard, so there is no harm in shaving or trimming it, while the hair level with the ear canal and the hair below it on the cheek belong to the beard, quoting al-Buhuti's definition of the bounds of the face, the cheek hair and the temple, and Ibn Hajar al-Haytami in al-Tuhfa that what descends from the temple towards the beard is cheek hair with the beard's ruling, and that the beard is the hair growing on the chin together with the cheek hair. It ruled that hair level with the top of the ear may be trimmed and shaved, whereas the hair of the cheeks and what is level with the ear canal belongs to the beard, which on the stronger view must be left to grow and may not be shaved, though taking from it to improve one's appearance is unobjectionable; the permissible amount is what achieves the purpose of removing the harm of an ugly appearance, since harm is to be removed, and if he bears with it and leaves it untrimmed, that is good.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer