Fatwas on Tadlis (concealment of a defect in a contract) 8 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of Tadlis (concealment of a defect in a contract)

  • Buying counterfeit brand goods

    A question about buying counterfeit brand goods, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that goods bearing a stolen trademark may not be dealt in; goods bearing a look-alike mark may be bought for personal use if the seller does not lie or deceive, but not for resale; and copying a design alone is governed by intellectual-property law. The Department answered that Islam commands honesty in dealings and forbids cheating and forgery, citing a hadith narrated by Ibn Majah and al-Tirmidhi whose meaning is that the honest, truthful merchant will be with the martyrs on the Day of Resurrection; in principle everyone should have his own innovation in his field and avoid imitation as far as possible. It distinguished between kinds of imitation. Goods bearing a stolen trademark are forbidden, since they involve lying and misrepresenting reality and infringe trademark rights, which are valued financial rights that must be protected. Goods bearing a mark that resembles the original and may deceive people are judged by the purpose of purchase: buying them for personal use is permitted provided the seller does not lie or deceive to promote them, but buying them to trade and sell to consumers is not permitted, because many people are taken in and believe them to be genuine. Imitating only the design, without any trademark, is governed by the laws on intellectual-property rights. It quoted Islamic Fiqh Academy resolution 43 (5/5) that trade names, trademarks, authorship and invention are private rights of their owners with recognised financial value that may not be infringed, advised the public to tell genuine from counterfeit goods, and reminded traders to fear God in their dealings.

    Original page

  • Entry fees for a car auction

    A question about buying a car at an auction that requires a refundable deposit, a fee on its refund and charges taken by the organising company, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that auction sales are permitted within their limits, that entry fees are allowed up to the actual cost, and that the broker company's charge is permitted. The Department answered that jurists permit auction sales provided they avoid najash, bidding up the price by someone with no intention to buy in order to trap others, and tadlis, deception that leads a person into a mistake that prompts him to contract. It said there is no objection to an entry fee limited to the actual cost, since it is an administrative expense, citing decision No. 73 of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy permitting an entry fee no higher than the actual value of the conditions booklet. It said fees the seller takes beyond the actual cost amount to consuming people's wealth unjustly, while what the broker companies organising the auction charge is part of the actual cost and is unobjectionable as a broker's fee. It concluded that if the auction fees are taken by the broker company rather than the seller, this is permitted, provided najash and tadlis are avoided.

    Original page

  • Opening new accounts to get a first-purchase discount

    A question about opening new accounts to get a first-purchase discount, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that a Muslim must be truthful, and that opening a new account for the same buyer must respect the site's rules; if it breaches them it is not permitted. The Department answered that a Muslim must be truthful in word and deed, citing Surat al-Anfal 8:27, Surat al-Tawba 9:119 and a hadith it attributes to al-Bukhari whose meaning is that whoever cheats the Muslims is not of them. It said that opening a new account for the same buyer must respect the website's instructions; if it breaches them, it is not permitted.

    Original page

  • Taking a reward or discount code for reviewing products on shopping sites

    A question on the cash rewards and discount codes shopping sites offer for product reviews, which Jordan's General Iftaa Department permitted provided the review is honest. The Department answered that a sum the site grants for reviewing the purchase experience is unobjectionable if the review is genuine and truthful, since it is a reward from the site. It said a discount code offered by the site itself is part of its promotions to attract customers without anything in return, making it a gratuitous transaction in which uncertainty is excused. Reviewing products without using them or checking their quality, in the hope of a reward, it described as misleading and deceiving buyers, a false review akin to lying and fraud and contrary to sincere counsel; it required that any manipulation or deception be avoided and that the review be honest and truthful.

    Original page

  • Selling spoiled or expired goods

    A question about selling spoiled or expired goods, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that selling spoiled or expired goods, or tampering with their dates, is forbidden; a seller whose goods cause someone's death is a transgressor owing blood money (diya) and expiation, and the authorities may impose deterrent discretionary penalties. The Department answered that Islam urges what is wholesome and forbids replacing it with the unlawful in spending and trade, citing Surat al-Baqara 2:267, Tafsir Ibn Kathir (1/697) on not turning from the lawful to the unlawful, and a hadith narrated by Ahmad and Ibn Majah that there is to be no harm and no reciprocal harm; this includes banning the sale of spoiled or expired food and tampering with production or expiry dates. It said that a trader who knows goods have expired is forbidden to sell them since they usually cause harm, that taking their price is consuming people's wealth wrongfully, citing Surat al-Nisa' 4:29, and that it is forbidden cheating, citing a hadith narrated by Muslim whose meaning is that whoever cheats does not belong to the Prophet's community. It said that if such goods cause a death and this is medically established, the one who caused it is a transgressor and transgression entails liability, like someone who places stones on a public road; deceiving buyers by selling spoiled goods as sound is a kind of coercion, quoting al-Juwayni in Nihayat al-Matlab (16/127) that selling poisoned food to someone likely to eat it resembles coercion because it leads to death. It concluded that a seller who knew the danger owes blood money and expiation as the cause if the food kills an eater who did not know, and likewise if he did not know it was spoiled, since the printed expiry date counts as notice to him; the authorities may impose deterrent discretionary penalties on those who sell such goods.

    Original page

  • Students using ChatGPT to prepare research

    A question about students using ChatGPT to prepare research, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that a student may not have the technology produce the core intellectual effort of a research paper and present it as his own, since that is lying and cheating, but may use it for formal tasks such as gathering information and sources and proofreading. The Department answered that ChatGPT is an interactive model based on artificial intelligence, developed by the American company OpenAI and launched in November 2022, which can be used to create content, write articles and help with research; the ruling on using it for research and assignments depends on the kind of effort involved. The original effort that is the point of the work, namely formulating information, drawing conclusions, ordering ideas and discussing open questions, may not be produced with this technology and attributed to oneself to mislead supervisors, since research is a means of assessment, and this earns an undeserved grade and puts the student on a par with those who worked hard. It cited a hadith agreed upon by al-Bukhari and Muslim whose meaning is that one who pretends to have what he was not given is like one wearing two garments of falsehood, Surat al-Tawba 9:119, and a hadith narrated by Muslim whose meaning is that whoever cheats us is not of us, calling this lying, cheating and forgery. As for formal effort, such as using search engines, gathering information, statistics and sources, and proofreading, there is no objection to using any artificial-intelligence tool that gives the research strength and scholarly authenticity. The Department advised students and researchers to avoid lying, cheating and forgery, to keep their own personal effort in writing their studies, and to use these technologies in ways pleasing to God.

    Original page

  • Sham purchases of merchants' goods to boost their sales, for a fee

    A questioner asked about making sham purchases of merchants' goods to increase their sales, taking a fee for it. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20671) answered that it involves several prohibitions, including formality in the purchase — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Selling goods close to expiry through price promotions

    A question on selling goods close to their expiry date at a discount without telling buyers why, which Egypt's Dar al-Ifta permitted on conditions. Dar al-Ifta answered that this is permitted if the goods are sound, fit for consumption and free of anything harmful to the consumer's health, with the expiry date left printed on them, neither altered nor obscured. It said that if any of these conditions is missing the sale is forbidden and the buyer has the option to return the goods. It based this on the principle that sales are permissible so long as there is full mutual consent and no fraud or concealment, noting that the Malikis required the seller to disclose how old the goods are and how long he has held them.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer