Fatwas on Taqlid 3 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of Taqlid

  • What jurists mean by a sound and a weak opinion

    A questioner asked what jurists mean by 'sound' and 'weak' opinions, the criterion of soundness, whether acting on either of two sound views is valid, and the wording of the need-sermon. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77736, 7 February 2009) answered that soundness in jurists' opinions is relative — sound to one mujtahid may not be to another — but a mujtahid calling a view sound means it is what evidence-examination requires and reflection witnesses; the measure of soundness is the view's agreement with the proof under his adopted principles; a diversity-difference allows acting on either view, but a contradictory difference requires seeking the preponderant and acting on what one's judgment holds nearer the right and more in keeping with the Lawgiver's intent; a lay questioner is referred to his mufti for the weighing.

    Original page

  • Putting the weightier first, and the layman's following

    A questioner asked whether the weightier must come first, and whether he may follow Ibn Humam al-Hanafi's view that patching between madhhabs is valid absolutely. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78360, 27 March 2009) answered that when two matters conflict, scripture and reason both commend advancing the weightier: two benefits unattainable together — prefer the weightier; two harms unavoidable — ward off the graver first, the sharia being built on securing and completing benefits and disabling and minimizing harms; as for taqlid, the sound view is that the layman has no madhhab of his own — his madhhab is that of his mufti: when an issue befalls him he raises it to one he trusts in religion and learning, acts on the fatwa and is cleared, God not having bound him to seek one particular imam's opinion.

    Original page

  • May one ask artificial intelligence for a fatwa?

    A question about turning to artificial-intelligence applications for answers on sharia matters and relying on their rulings, in which IslamQA answered that artificial intelligence is a permissible tool in principle, but that it may not be asked for fatwas nor relied upon in religious matters, because it lacks the qualifications of a mufti, namely understanding of the religion and of reality and the other conditions set out by al-Shafi'i and Ibn al-Qayyim, and because its answers are generated automatically from data that may be of unknown origin, mistaken or fabricated, may carry the biases of its trainers, and do not account for the way discretionary rulings change with custom and circumstance. The site distinguished artificial intelligence from fatwa websites, where real people answer, and said that a scholarly researcher may use it to gather material, find sources, summarise and understand reality provided every quotation is verified, and that a layman may use it to get a general idea or to ask for links to fatwas he then consults himself, as a smart search engine, but may not act on a fatwa the system generates by itself. It set out two contemporary approaches, outright prohibition or a distinction between fixed rulings that apply equally to everyone, where its answers may be used under four conditions, and rulings built on custom and circumstance, where they may not; the site judged the prohibiting approach the stronger in the present state of the technology.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer