Fatwas on Contracts (al-'uqud) 17 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of Contracts (al-'uqud)

  • A university lecturer's duty to follow working-hours instructions

    A question on a lecturer objecting to being required on campus four days a week, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that he must follow administrative instructions issued by those with authority to issue them. The Department answered that parties to contracts of exchange must honour their terms, citing the hadith that Muslims are bound by their conditions, unless a condition plainly contradicts the sharia by permitting the forbidden or forbidding the permitted. It said teaching loads, in hours and days, are governed by regulations applied by officials with delegated authority, so as long as an official acts within his powers and in the interest of teaching, his organisational decisions must be followed. It added that anyone who feels wronged should take the matter to the competent bodies rather than resort to defiance or quarrelling, whose harm outweighs any benefit, and concluded that the lecturer must follow the instructions so long as they accord with the laws and regulations.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 103 (11/6) on the maintenance contract

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 11th session in Manama (25–30 Rajab 1419, 14–19 November 1998). It ruled that the maintenance contract is a novel, independent contract governed by the general rules of contracts, its characterisation and ruling differing with its forms; in essence it is an exchange contract in which one party undertakes to inspect and repair a machine or other thing, periodically or as emergencies arise, for a known period against a known consideration — the maintainer undertaking either work alone or work and materials. It listed its forms: a stand-alone contract where the maintainer provides work only, or work plus trivial materials the parties do not reckon, is classified as hire-of-work ijara and is lawful provided the work and wage are known; it then gave the remaining forms and their rulings and controls.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 107 (12/1) on supply contracts and tenders

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 12th session in Riyadh (25 Jumada II – 1 Rajab 1421, 23–28 September 2000). It defined a supply contract as one under which a party undertakes to deliver known goods periodically over a set period to another party against a specific amount deferred in whole or part; ruled that where the subject matter requires manufacture it is istisna' governed by resolution 65 (7/3); and where it is fungible goods described in the debtor's obligation and deliverable at a term, either the price is paid in full at contract — taking the rules of salam under resolution 85 (9/2) — or it is deferred. It then addressed tenders/bids and their legal controls.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 109 (12/3) on the penalty clause

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 12th session in Riyadh (25 Jumada II – 1 Rajab 1421, 23–28 September 2000). It defined the penalty clause, in law, as the contracting parties' agreement on estimating compensation due for harm if the other party fails to perform his undertaking or delays it; reaffirmed its earlier resolutions — on salam (85 (9/2)) that a penalty for delay in delivering the salam commodity is impermissible as it is a debt and no increase may be stipulated on debts at delay, and on istisna' (65 (7/3)) that a penalty clause may be included per the parties' agreement unless necessity excuses. It then generalised: the penalty clause is permissible in all financial contracts except where the subject is itself a debt, with controls on estimating compensation and excuse by necessity.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 110 (12/4) on hire-purchase ⁦(ijara ending in ownership)⁩ and ijara sukuk

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 12th session in Riyadh (25 Jumada II – 1 Rajab 1421, 23–28 September 2000). It fixed the line between lawful and unlawful forms of ijara ending in ownership: the prohibition marker is two different contracts concluded at the same time on the same asset in the same period; permissibility requires two separate, independent contracts — the sale concluded after the ijara, or a promise of ownership at term's end (an option counting like a promise) — the ijara being real and not a veil for a sale; risk of the asset resting on the owner not the lessee; any insurance on it being cooperative-Islamic and borne by the owner; ijara rules applying throughout the term and sale rules on transfer; and non-operating maintenance on the lessor. It listed prohibited forms — a lease converting automatically into a sale without a new contract, a sale suspended on full rental payment, a long-deferred sale with a condition-option for the lessor — and addressed ijara sukuk.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 129 (14/3) on the contracting ⁦(muqawala)⁩ and construction contract: its nature, characterisation and forms

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 14th session in Doha (8–13 Dhu al-Qa'da 1423, 11–16 January 2003), mindful of the contract's role in industry, finance and the Islamic economy. It defined muqawala as a contract whereby one party undertakes to make a thing or do work against a consideration undertaken by the other; ruled it lawful whether the contractor supplies work and material (the jurists' istisna') or work alone (hire-of-work ijara) — referring the first form to resolution 65 (7/3) on istisna' and requiring in the second that the wage be known in amount and manner. It then treated the contract's forms, conditions and modifications.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 132 (14/6) on adhesion contracts

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 14th session in Doha (8–13 Dhu al-Qa'da 1423, 11–16 January 2003). It defined adhesion contracts as a modern Western legal term for agreements marked by: the contract relating to goods or services all people need (water, electricity, gas, telephone, mail, public transport); the offeror's legal or de facto monopoly over them, or a control leaving competition narrow; the offeror alone setting the contract's details and terms with no right of the other side to discuss, cancel or amend them; and the offer being uniform, standing and addressed to the public. It ruled that the adhesion contract is concluded by the meeting of deemed offer and acceptance, and treated its ruling, controls, and the permitted and prohibited terms in it.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 148 (16/6) on commercial sponsorship ⁦(kafala tijariyya)⁩

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 16th session in Dubai (30 Safar – 5 Rabi al-Awwal 1426, 9–14 April 2005). It distinguished sharia suretyship (joining the guarantor's liability to the debtor's in a claim over debt, asset or person) from commercial kafala (an arrangement letting a non-citizen use a licence to practise trades or set up enterprises). Its forms include: the licensed citizen consenting to a non-citizen using the licence for his own fully financed activity, the citizen contributing neither capital nor work yet appearing as the business owner; and the citizen partnering with the non-citizen where laws permit, sharing profits. It then ruled on each form, its controls, and what is prohibited as evasion and commercial concealment.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 157 (17/6) on mutual promising and collusion in contracts

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 17th session in Amman (28 Jumada al-Ula – 2 Jumada al-Akhira 1427, 24–28 June 2006), after reviewing its resolutions 40–41 (5/2 and 5/3). It ruled: mutual promises are in principle binding in conscience, not enforceable at law; mutual promises to contract as a device against riba — such as collusion on 'ina or promising a sale-and-loan — are prohibited; where a sale cannot presently be concluded because the seller does not own the object and a general need exists to bind both parties to a future contract by law or international commercial custom (as with documentary credit for imports), the mutual promise may be made binding on both by government legislation or by their express agreement in the contract; and a binding promise in this case does not take the rule of a sale deferred to the future — ownership does not pass by it and the sale is concluded only by renewed consent or the sale terms upon maturity — with the consequences for rights and obligations set out.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 228 (23/12) on the proposals of the committee formed by the Academy's secretariat to examine certain sukuk questions

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 23rd session in Medina (19–23 Safar 1440, 28 October – 1 November 2018), after presenting to the council the minutes of the committee formed by the Academy's secretariat (meeting of 9 Rabi' I 1438, 8 December 2016) to examine objections raised against some of its sukuk resolutions. It decided to hold a scholarly seminar, for which specialists would be commissioned to research two questions and produce recommendations for the next session: first, whether leasing an asset back to its seller counts among the forbidden 'ina sales as stated in resolution 188 (20/3); and second, the extent to which it is possible to undertake to redeem the sukuk of a lease ending in ownership at their nominal value, given that the issuer and the beneficiary so agreed at issuance, as stated in resolution 178 (19/4).

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 230 (24/1) on smart contracts, how they are activated and rescinded ⁦(a study of smart contracts and their connection to digital currency)⁩

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 24th session in Dubai (7–9 Rabi' I 1441, 4–6 November 2019). It reaffirmed in all its clauses its resolution 52 (6/3) on the ruling on concluding contracts by modern means of communication (sixth session, Jeddah 1410/1990), which applies to electronic contracts as distinct from smart contracts. It defined a smart contract as a self-executing contract between two parties built on the peer-to-peer idea (without an intermediary) through a decentralised distributed network (blockchain) and carried out in tokenised (cryptographic) currencies such as Bitcoin and others, executed through private centralised or public decentralised platforms that mostly use cryptocurrencies. It decided to defer a ruling pending a specialised seminar on smart contracts and a ruling on cryptographic currencies, in order to study all their aspects, recommending that technical specialists in blockchain and cryptocurrencies be invited.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 232 (24/3) on FIDIC contracts

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 24th session in Dubai (7–9 Rabi' I 1441, 4–6 November 2019). It defined FIDIC contracts as a set of model engineering construction contracts that regulate the relation between the employer (or whoever stands in his place) and those executing the contract, to complete a project whose construction elements are numerous so that it is delivered ready for its intended use. It held that these contracts are lawful in the sharia provided the sharia rulings and controls are observed, analogising them to the contracts of istisna' (manufacture), ijara (lease) and muqawala (contracting); that disputes arising under them are settled by recourse to arbitration under its resolution 91 (9/8); that a penalty clause may be applied where execution is delayed beyond the set date under its resolution 109 (12/3); and that any addition to the price due to changed conditions of execution or an amendment to the subject-matter of the contract is compensation for harm.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 241 (25/3) on the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on the rulings on transactions, contracts and financial obligations

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 25th session in Jeddah (29 Rajab – 3 Sha'ban 1444, 20–23 February 2023), as a companion to its resolution 240 (25/2) on the pandemic's effect on worship, family and offences. It ruled that COVID-19 is among the emergency excuses allowing contractual obligations to be revisited by deferral, rescission or discharge; that the injured party in contracts whose conclusion or execution is suspended may cancel and recover the deposit and earnest margin, or agree to suspend execution or reduce their obligation; that the pandemic has no effect on residential rent once the leased property has been used, the rent remaining a debt on the insolvent tenant; that a penalty clause may not be enforced when the pandemic caused the delay; that under state supervision salaries may be redistributed or cut in proportion to reduced working hours and lost benefit; that recourse to commercial insurance is allowed to the extent of need where Islamic cooperative insurance is unavailable; that arrears on financing contracts whose instalments the pandemic disrupted should be settled justly; and that comparable epidemics take the same rulings. It recommended organised humanitarian initiatives against bankruptcy's effects and support for least-developed countries, displaced people and refugees, and donations from companies, banks and benefactors.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 247 (25/9) on the controls for applying the objectives of the sharia in directing contemporary financial transactions

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 25th session in Jeddah (29 Rajab – 3 Sha'ban 1444, 20–23 February 2023), reaffirming its resolution 167 (5/18) on the sharia objectives and their role in deriving rulings. It defined the objectives of the sharia in financial transactions as the meanings and ends the sharia seeks through them — justice in dealings, the circulation, flow, transparency, preservation and growth of wealth. It ruled that sharia councils and bodies should keep them in view with their controls when applying them to cases and new events, the chief controls being: they may not contradict stronger recognised evidences; their kinds and ranks must be observed — primary versus subordinate, universal versus particular, certain versus probabilistic — the probabilistic never preferred to the certain, the particular to the universal, the subordinate to the primary; the five universal objectives must be kept in view when applying transaction objectives; objectives must be distinguished from means, so a means does not overturn its end nor is an established end abandoned to block a means; they may inform drafting, interpreting and settling disputes of modern contracts under pandemics and emergencies in light of justice, flow, transparency and stability; they serve to verify the substance of contemporary transactions against mere form; and their outcomes must be weighed. It recommended that universities give more attention to the objectives in study and teaching and direct specialists to master contemporary economics and finance.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 248 (25/10) on the rulings on contemporary applications of debt rollover and compound and hybrid sukuk

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 25th session in Jeddah (29 Rajab – 3 Sha'ban 1444, 20–23 February 2023). It defined debt rollover as converting an established debt into a larger one in exchange for an extension of term — a form of settling debt with debt — reaffirmed its resolutions 101 (11/4) on the sale of debt and loan bonds and 158 (17/7) on settling debt with debt, and ruled that every form of rollover that increases the debtor's debt in exchange for extended term, or serves as a device to that end, is the prohibited settling of debt with debt; and that the contracting parties' power to amend contracts is bound by the sharia so that no increase on an established debt accompanies a longer term — whether arising from murabaha, istisna', salam or otherwise — and nothing violates what consensus has forbidden, namely riba on debts. On hybrid and compound sukuk it deferred a ruling for further research. It recommended recourse to its resolution 218 (23/2) on insolvency and bankruptcy, called on Islamic financial institutions to help defaulting debtors with financing plans that let them recover and repay, and called on sharia boards to abide by its resolutions on the sale, settlement and rollover of debt.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 254 (25/16) on renewing consideration of new issues in contemporary applications of lease ending in ownership

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 25th session in Jeddah (29 Rajab – 3 Sha'ban 1444, 20–23 February 2023). After reviewing its earlier resolutions on the subject — 44 (5/6) on lease ending in ownership, 110 (12/4) on the same and on ijara sukuk, 115 (9/12) on inflation and the change in currency value, 228 (23/12) on sukuk questions and 238 (24/9) on hedging in Islamic financial institutions — and the submitted research, it decided to defer a ruling on the new issues in contemporary applications of lease ending in ownership for further research and study, recommending a specialised seminar.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 255 (25/17) on the letter of guarantee and documentary credit

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 25th session in Jeddah (29 Rajab – 3 Sha'ban 1444, 20–23 February 2023) on the letter of guarantee and documentary credit. After reviewing the submitted research and hearing the discussions, the Academy decided to defer a ruling on the matter for further research and study, recommending that a specialised seminar be held on it.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer