IIFA resolution 226 (23/10) on predominance and subordination in financial transactions: their cases, controls and conditions

قرار مجمع الفقه الإسلامي الدولي 226 (23/10) بشأن الغلبة والتبعية في المعاملات المالية: حالاتهما وضوابطهما وشروط تحققهما

A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 23rd session in Medina (19–23 Safar 1440, 28 October – 1 November 2018), adopting the final wording of recommendations from its seminar with the Islamic Development Bank Group (Jeddah, 25–26 Safar 1436), reworked under resolution 214 (22/10) and in view of resolutions 30, 188 and 196. It ruled: first, reaffirming resolution 30 that trading a security (share, sukuk or unit) when the pooled money has not yet begun operating is exchanging money for money, governed by the rules of currency exchange, and if the assets turn into debts the rules on disposing of debts apply. Second, the principle of subordination (the subordinate takes the ruling of what it follows) is established in the sharia and may govern trading securities provided the dominant element exists — its criterion being the presence of an activity, work and a responsible entity (institution or company) turning over the money; the security may then be traded regardless of the share of cash and debts in its assets as those are subordinate, not independent, provided the dominant element persists through all stages of trading. Third, where securities do not represent a trading activity but common ownership in financings from a financial institution, mixed assets of cash, debts, tangibles and usufruct may be traded at the agreed price provided tangibles and usufruct predominate — its criterion exceeding half (50%). Fourth, the permissibility may not be made a device or trick to securitise and trade debts, as by adding tangibles and usufruct to fabricate predominance. It applied the two principles to sukuk and investment units: the underlying contract must fulfil its sharia elements; trading is permissible when tangibles, usufruct or services predominate after subscription closes and activity begins, while before it the rules of exchange and debts apply; and it detailed the rulings on sukuk of ownership of usufruct of identified assets, usufruct of assets described in obligation, and service-ownership sukuk before and after re-leasing.

Depth

At a glance

This entry is a record so far, without an article. The facts and connections below come from the museum's data.

Connections

Explore the connections

About
Nuqud (money in fiqh)· Usury (riba)

People and things also explored

IIFA resolution 222 (23/6) on the perks a bank grants current-account clients from the sharia perspective· IIFA resolution 224 (23/8) on hedging in financial transactions: the controls and rulings· IIFA resolution 238 (24/9) on hedging operations in Islamic financial institutions· IIFA resolution 248 (25/10) on the rulings on contemporary applications of debt rollover and compound and hybrid sukuk· Economy and balance in the Qur'an· Sale of debts and deferred pricing· Currency exchange (sarf)· Exploiting the need of the needy

Sources

  • International Islamic Fiqh Academy

Original page

Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “IIFA resolution 226 (23/10) on predominance and subordination in financial transactions: their cases, controls and conditions”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/work/fatwa-iifa-226-predominance-subordination-financial-transactions/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-16.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Words

Qur'an, hadith, poetry, and the languages and scripts of Muslim peoples.
Related

IIFA resolution 222 (23/6) on the perks a bank grants current-account clients from the sharia perspective

A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 23rd session in Medina (19–23 Safar 1440, 28 October – 1 November 2018). It defined the current account as a record of sums a client gives the bank — Islamic or conventional — which he may withdraw at any time by known means such as cheques, transfers and cash withdrawal, the deposits being guaranteed in the bank's liability and used for its benefit as the laws regulate. On its legal characterisation it reaffirmed resolution 86 (9/3): demand deposits (current accounts) at Islamic or usurious banks are, in juristic terms, loans. It defined banking perks as the additional rights a bank grants current-account holders to attract and keep them — either for the client's benefit alone or for both parties. Perks for the client alone that are immaterial — priority service, periodic advisory bulletins, statements, solvency certificates, ATM privilege cards — are permissible, not being a usurious financial increase but the borrower's (the bank's) help to the lender (the client) in collecting his right. Material perks — appliances, electronics, air tickets exceeding the account's balance, conditioned or not — are forbidden where given because of the loan, in view of its size and term, as being of the kind of usurious increase; but where given to every new client in any account they count as advertising and marketing expense and are permissible so long as unconnected to the loan's size and term. As for mutual perks: those connected to deposit and withdrawal operations, such as cheque books and ATM cards, are permissible since the benefit covers bank and client with no harm to either; those benefiting both but unrelated to deposits and withdrawals, such as preferential pricing on currency exchange and transfer fees, are treated in detail in the resolution.