Fatwas on Destruction or damage of property (itlaf) 4 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of Destruction or damage of property (itlaf)

  • A child eating at an open buffet without paying

    A question on an eight-year-old who ate with his father at an open buffet that charges for anyone aged five or over, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that eating at an open buffet is permitted, but the permission covers only the person who paid, so the father should go back to the restaurant and ask to be excused or pay what is owed. The Department answered that eating at an open buffet is permitted even though people eat different amounts, since the uncertainty is slight, governed by custom and does not lead to dispute; it quoted al-Nawawi's al-Majmu' on scholars tolerating slight uncertainty. It said the permission lets the payer eat himself; it does not transfer ownership of the food to him, so he may not feed others, and the father may not feed his son without the restaurant's permission, since its allowance is limited to children under five. It concluded that the father should go to the restaurant's management, tell them what happened and ask to be excused, and pay for what the boy ate if they ask, since anyone who consumes another's property without right is liable for it.

    Original page

  • Taking insurance compensation for road-accident injuries

    A question from someone injured in a road accident about taking compensation from the insurance company, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that compensation for harm is lawful, so there is no objection to taking it for real harm, without deception or lying. The Department answered that compensation for material harm is lawful in fiqh and that jurists have set out the grounds that require it; it pointed to the Qur'an's establishing blood money for accidental killing, and quoted al-Mawardi's al-Hawi al-Kabir that whoever destroys something is liable for it. It said compensation falls on whoever directly caused the harm or brought it about, since the act is what creates liability, quoting al-Ramli's Nihayat al-Muhtaj that whoever destroys another's property or misuses it owes its replacement and the hire. It concluded that there is no objection to taking compensation from insurance companies when it is for real harm caused by the accident, with no deception or lying involved.

    Original page

  • The liability of a technician working in a repair shop

    A question from the owner of a computer repair shop who asked a technician working for him to repair a customer's device; during the repair the internal control board and some other parts were damaged, causing large losses, and he asked who bears them. Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that the technician, in his relationship with the shop owner, is a private hireling, since he works exclusively for him during working hours, and his rule is that he is not liable for what is damaged in his hands except through transgression or negligence: if he departed from the established practices of the trade or was careless and took no precautions, he is liable to the shop owner for what was damaged, otherwise he bears no liability, and whether transgression or negligence occurred is referred to people of expertise. Dar al-Ifta characterised the transaction as a hire among three parties: the customer who hires, the shop owner who is a common hireling working for the public and liable by contract for customers' devices damaged by his own act or that of his workers, and the technician who is a private hireling liable only for transgression or negligence; it quoted al-Kasani, Ibn Maza, al-Mudawwana, al-Dardir, al-Ramli, Ibn Qudama and al-Buhuti on the private hireling's non-liability without transgression, and Ibn Shas, al-Mardawi and al-Ba'li on the common hireling's liability to the owner for what is damaged in the hands of his private hireling, explaining the difference by the fact that the common hireling is liable by the contract, not by the act of damage, as the Ottoman Majalla also states.

    Original page

  • A tailor's liability for cloth spoiled in his hands

    A question about a tailor who took a valuable piece of cloth to cut it into a garment of agreed specifications, made an error in the pattern measurements while cutting, and spoiled the cloth so that it was no longer fit for the garment; Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that what is spoiled in a tailor's hands while cutting and measuring is his liability in sharia, and that the rule is to compensate with cloth of the same specifications as the one he ruined, or, if a like cannot be obtained, with its value on the day of the damage. Dar al-Ifta explained that hiring a person for a known task is permissible without disagreement, distinguished the private hireling who works for one employer for a fixed period from the common hireling who takes work from the public, such as dyers, fullers and tailors, quoting the definitions of al-Samarqandi in Tuhfat al-Fuqaha and of the Ottoman Majalla, and ruled that the majority of jurists in the four schools hold the common hireling liable for what is spoiled by the work of his hands, because this serves the interests of both craftsmen and owners of goods, while leaving him unliable would open the way to the loss of people's property; it cited the report that Ali ibn Abi Talib used to hold fullers and goldsmiths liable, saying that nothing else would set people right, and quoted al-Sughdi, Ibn Shas, Qadi Abd al-Wahhab, al-Khatib al-Shirbini and al-Buhuti. It then explained that the rule in compensation is that fungibles are compensated with their like and non-fungibles with their value, moving to value only when a like cannot be had, as al-Izz ibn Abd al-Salam says, and that the value is reckoned on the day of the damage, as Ibn Nujaym and Ibn Hajar al-Haytami say.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer