Fatwas on Inheritance (mirath) 24 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

The museum's record of Inheritance (mirath)

  • Deducting a broker's fee from the price of heirs' land

    A question about land jointly owned by heirs and sold through a broker, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that the broker's fee is deducted from the price before division, each heir bearing it in proportion to his share, provided all the heirs agreed to sell through the broker. The Department answered that heirs are joint owners of the estate, and in joint ownership each partner bears costs in proportion to his share, since liability follows gain; the broker's fee is a cost of dividing the estate, and it quoted Zakariyya al-Ansari's Asna al-Matalib that a divider's fee is split by shares, not by heads. It said that if the sale was made with the permission of the father's wife's heirs, they bear the broker's fee with the other heirs, since a broker works only for a fee, and what is customary counts as if stipulated. It concluded that the broker's fee is deducted from the land's price before division if all the heirs agreed to sell through him, and this applies to the father's wife's heirs too, as long as they agreed to the sale.

    Original page

  • An agent dividing an inheritance without the other heirs' knowledge

    A question about an agent dividing an inheritance without the other heirs' knowledge, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that the estate belongs to all the heirs according to their shares, and that the agent may not hide the estate's size, divide it other than by the legal shares, or deprive anyone of his share. The Department answered that everything the deceased leaves, whether money, land, property or anything else, belongs to all the legal heirs, male and female, according to their fixed shares; no heir or anyone else may take anything from the estate without the explicit permission of all of them, nor deal with another's share without his permission. It said the heirs may appoint one of themselves as agent for the distribution, but the agent may not conceal any information about the estate's size, divide it other than by the legal division, or withhold any heir's share, because he is bound to carry out the rules of the law in distributing the inheritance. It quoted al-Imrani in al-Bayan that there is no agency in inheritance except in dividing and receiving it. It concluded that no heir may withhold anyone's legal share, and whoever does so is sinning.

    Original page

  • Delaying the division of an inheritance and the rent of inherited flats

    A question about delaying the division of an estate of property and flats while some brothers need their shares and the mother takes all the rent, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department answered that an estate is divided as soon as possible, that no heir claiming his share may be refused, and that it is kindness to secure the mother a decent income without neglecting the heirs' rights. The Department answered that an estate should in principle be divided after the death as soon as possible, to avoid disputes and lost rights; if the heirs agree to keep the property as it is, owning it jointly each according to his share, that is permitted, but none of them may refuse division when one of them claims his share. It said that everything a person owns becomes the property of all the heirs after his death, that each heir may claim his right to the rent from let property and flats, and that making this claim is not disobedience to parents. It advised the parties to resolve the matter through dialogue and, if that fails, said an heir may take it to court. It said it is kindness for the heirs to provide their mother with a source of income for a decent life, with moderation and balance and without neglecting the others' rights, and that maintenance of poor parents falls on their well-off children, citing article 197 of Jordan's Personal Status Law No. 15 of 2019.

    Original page

  • Zakat on inherited gold left undivided for years

    A question about gold left by a grandmother that stayed undivided for thirty years, in which Jordan's General Iftaa Department set out the Shafi'i view that zakat for all past years is due on receipt and the Maliki view that the zakat year starts from receipt, and allowed the heirs to follow either view. The Department answered that a deceased person's wealth leaves his ownership on death, its zakat year is cut off, and it passes into the heirs' ownership, starting a new year from the moment of death; if the estate is divided, each heir reckons the year on his own share if it reaches the minimum. It said that if the wealth stays jointly held and undivided and reaches the minimum, which it gives as 85 grams of 24-carat gold, the Shafi'is hold its zakat due every year, so each heir pays the past years' zakat at 2.5% on receiving his share, because his ownership never lapsed; it quoted al-Khatib al-Shirbini in Mughni al-Muhtaj on zakat on seized or lost wealth once it returns to its owner. It reported that the Malikis require receipt and the passing of a year, so there is no zakat on inherited wealth for the years before it is received and the heir starts a new year after receipt, citing al-Dasuqi's gloss on al-Sharh al-Kabir that the relied-upon position is that of al-Mudawwana, which counts receipt. It concluded that heirs who wish to take the more cautious course may follow the Shafi'is and pay zakat for the past years, while those who follow the Malikis and start the year from the day they receive their shares, given how long the wealth was held, do nothing wrong.

    Original page

  • A bequest disinheriting an undutiful son

    A questioner asks about a man who died after leaving a bequest that his undutiful son be denied inheritance. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta, in a fatwa issued under Grand Mufti Nazir Ayyad, answered that undutifulness to parents is forbidden and a major sin, but it does not cancel rights; inheritance passes to the heir by force of law, without the choice of heir or deceased, so the bequest is invalid and the son takes his share unless one of the recognised impediments to inheritance applies; he should make up for his father after his death by seeking forgiveness for him, giving charity on his behalf and keeping his ties of kinship.

    Original page

  • Burning the deceased's clothes before the fortieth day

    A questioner asked about burning the deceased's clothes before forty days pass. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22206) answered that preserving the deceased's clothes is obligatory — they are part of the estate for the heirs, to be used by whoever wants them or given in charity — and that burning them has no basis, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Some inheritance rules for conjoined twins

    A questioner asked about the inheritance rules for conjoined twins. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21512) answered by setting out that parasitic-type conjoined twins — one properly formed body carrying additional organs — have their own ruling, which the answer details.

    Original page

  • Is a deferred debt due when the creditor dies before its term?

    A questioner asked about paying a deferred debt when the creditor dies before its term. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21650) answered that the debtor must pay when the term falls due — not at the creditor's death — so the heirs cannot demand early payment, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Distributing a life-insurance sum when beneficiaries were named

    A questioner asked how to distribute a life-insurance sum when the deceased named the beneficiaries without fixing each one's share. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 20758) answered by setting out how the distribution is made.

    Original page

  • The guarantor's duty when the debtor dies leaving enough money

    A questioner asked about the guarantor paying a due debt when the debtor died leaving money enough to cover it. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21081) answered that the debt falls due on his estate as a first charge; the ruling on the guarantee then is set out in the answer.

    Original page

  • Must the guarantor's heirs pay a guaranteed deferred debt on his death?

    A questioner asked whether the guarantor's heirs must pay the guaranteed deferred debt upon his death. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21559) answered that a debt guarantee does not lapse at the guarantor's death: the obligation passes to his estate and the creditor's claim to the heirs within its limits — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The bequest of one with no heir of his entire estate to a charity

    A questioner asked about a person with no heir bequeathing his entire estate to a charity. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21634) answered that a responsible person without an heir may bequeath his whole estate in life and the disposition is valid in the sharia — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Heirs paying a debt a man claims on the deceased

    A man claimed a debt against a deceased person and the heirs asked about paying it. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21741) answered that a debt claim on the dead is not accepted without the claimant's proof — with an exculpatory oath if it reaches court; if no proof is established the case has its ruling, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Heirs continuing instalments on a flat after the owner's death

    A questioner asked about heirs continuing instalments on a flat after the buyer's death. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22005) answered that the instalments the deceased fell behind on during his life are immediate debts paid out of the estate; the answer sets out the rules of inheritance and debt in this case.

    Original page

  • The decisiveness of the inheritance verse

    A questioner asked about the standing of the inheritance verse in the Qur'an. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 22037) answered that the inheritance verse in Surat al-Nisa' counts among the verses decisive in transmission and meaning on which the rules of the fixed shares rest; the answer sets out the standing of the science of inheritance.

    Original page

  • Do trademark and trade-name benefits pass by inheritance?

    A questioner asked whether a trademark and trade name pass by inheritance. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21846) answered that the trademark and trade name count as property carrying property's rulings — sale and the like — and on the owner's death they are inheritance for his heirs, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The obligatory bequest for grandchildren who inherit as agnates

    A questioner asked about the obligatory bequest for grandchildren. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21945) answered that a son's son is entitled to an obligatory bequest equal to what his father would have received had he been alive at the progenitor's death, capped at a third — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The partnership when one partner dies

    A questioner asked about the partnership when one partner dies. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21714) answered that a partner's death is among the causes of the partnership's dissolution — though its continuation is not barred if the parties agree and consent — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Liability for a deposit the deceased disclosed but the heirs could not find

    A questioner asked about a deposit the deceased's cousin left with him for safekeeping until his return from travel; the man told his sons of it before his death, then they could not find it. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21638) answered by setting out the ruling on liability for that deposit.

    Original page

  • Paying the wife's deferred mahr from her late husband's dues before distribution

    A widow asked about taking her deferred mahr from her late husband's outstanding dues before their distribution. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta (Grand Mufti Dr. Nazir Muhammad Ayyad, fatwa no. 21737) answered that such dues, if they were his established rights in life whose payment was delayed until his death, are his estate; the answer sets out where the deferred mahr falls within that.

    Original page

  • Intellectual property rights in research works after the author's death

    A question from a man whose father had an account on a website holding his research papers and had shown him the account and its password before his death, asking whether these papers form part of the inheritance or are his own property; Dar al-Ifta al-Misriyya answered that an author's economic rights last for his lifetime and fifty years after his death, that the rights to benefit from the research the father left are part of his property, enter his estate and pass to his heirs, and that no one heir has an exclusive claim to them without a valid cause transferring ownership before death, such as sale, gift or bequest. Dar al-Ifta explained that preserving property is among the universal aims of sharia, as al-Ghazali says, and that intellectual property and authors' rights are rights established for their holders in sharia and custom as a form of property, since property includes tangible things, uses and rights; it quoted Ibn Sida, al-Zabidi, al-Mazari, al-Juwayni, al-Rafi'i, Ibn Qudama and al-Buhuti that uses are property like tangible things, said that intellectual production is used, traded and valued by custom and so has the status of property, and referred to Egypt's Intellectual Property Law 82 of 2002, articles 140 and 160. It said that a father's permitting his son to view his research or manage his account does not make the son its owner, because ownership arises only through one of the recognised causes of ownership listed by al-Zayla'i, al-Mawardi and Ibn al-Rif'a; at most the father entrusted the son with it during his lifetime, so if he died without transferring ownership it is part of the estate, and the rights of use are divided among the heirs according to their shares.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 227 (23/11) on the effect of the marriage contract on the spouses' property

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 23rd session in Medina (19–23 Safar 1440, 28 October – 1 November 2018). It ruled that each spouse has an independent financial personality and therefore the right to dispose of what he or she owns of property and rights, for consideration or as a gift; that whatever each owns, whether through the marriage contract or apart from it, is that spouse's private property and passes on death to his or her heirs; that if the spouses willingly and freely agree between themselves to divide their property there is no sharia objection, but it may not be imposed on them as a binding specification; that where the marital relation ends by divorce, judicial divorce or khul' and causes the wife harm, she has the right to resort to a court claiming compensation for the harm suffered — a contemporary application of the mut'a right the lawgiver established for the divorced woman; and it called for the establishment of state or civil institutions to care for divorced women and meet their needs.

    Original page

  • IIFA resolution 253 (25/15) on the role of bequests as an effective instrument against poverty and for the circulation and flow of wealth in Islamic law

    A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 25th session in Jeddah (29 Rajab – 3 Sha'ban 1444, 20–23 February 2023) on the role of bequests as an effective instrument against poverty and for securing the circulation and flow of wealth in Islamic law. After reviewing the submitted research, discussing it at length and hearing the members' and experts' views, the Academy decided to defer a ruling on the matter for further research and study, recommending that a specialised seminar be held on it.

    Original page

  • Testifying that a man was the deceased's son so he could inherit, then learning he was adopted

    A question from a man who testified before a judge that a certain person was the son of a deceased man so that he could inherit, when the person was in fact adopted and registered in the family record as a son because the deceased could not have children; the questioner had earlier believed him to be a real son, then regretted it and asked whether this was false testimony and whether he owes an expiation. The fatwa centre of IslamWeb answered that false testimony is testimony contrary to the truth and among the gravest of major sins by the hadith of Abu Bakra in Sahih al-Bukhari, and that its criterion according to Ibn Hajar is describing a thing contrary to what it is; so if at the time of his testimony he testified contrary to what he knew, he gave false testimony and must hasten to repent and seek forgiveness, and part of his repentance is to go to the court where he testified and declare his testimony void and that the person he testified for has no blood relationship with the deceased, as al-Iqna fi Hall Alfaz Abi Shuja states that repentance from a verbal sin is by speech, saying of false testimony 'my testimony is void and I regret it', together with restoring what was wrongfully taken from a person; and that this testimony may have many harmful consequences, since the person would inherit another's wealth and be attached to a particular family, so he should hasten to set right what he spoiled.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer