Fatwas on Shirk (associating partners with God) 11 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
The museum's record of Shirk (associating partners with God)
- Scholars congratulating Christians on their feasts
A questioner asked whether scholars congratulating Christians on their feasts have any precedent or proof. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78925, 20 May 2009) answered that the default is kindness and equity toward covenant non-Muslims, into which some counted among the learned fold congratulations on their feasts — but that is open to question, since the sound view is that feasts are among the rites, per 'for every community We appointed a rite they observe'; sharing in them or congratulating on them is not permissible, while kindness and equity continue in all else. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Wearing gemstones and amulets against evil spirits
A questioner asked about wearing gemstones — emerald, ruby, diamond — or hanging them to repel evil spirits and draw luck, and about writing verses for that purpose. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86951, 9 June 2012) answered that hanging gemstones or anything else to ward off evil spirits is unlawful, since none brings good or repels harm but God, citing the hadiths that whoever hangs an amulet has committed shirk and that ruqya-of-that-kind, amulets and love-charms are shirk, and closing with counsel to resort to God with good opinion and earnest prayer. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The mushrik and the kafir — al-Ma'ida and al-Baqara reconciled
A questioner asked the precise difference between the mushrik and the kafir, and how to reconcile al-Ma'ida's permitting women of the People of the Book with al-Baqara's forbidding marriage to the idolaters until they believe. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77277, 28 December 2008) answered that al-Ma'ida is among the last revealed, and its permitting Book-women despite shirk's meaning holding in them makes it a specification of al-Baqara; some scholars reconcile another way — the People of the Book, though the meaning of shirk holds in them, are not the ones this name turns to unqualified: it turns to those who hold no heavenly religion, as in 'the disbelievers among the People of the Book and the idolaters are in hellfire forever'.
- Falsehood has no logic
A questioner brought a forum piece reasoning about the misguidance of the jinn and their polytheists in terms of their 'logic'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81567, 27 May 2010) answered that he is, by such premises, judging the error of the jinn and polytheists by logic — and when has the straying had logic? Did cow-worshippers or Buddha-worshippers or devil-worshippers have one? God bred many of jinn and men for hell — hearts that do not understand, eyes that do not see, ears that do not hear — so they will say on Judgment Day 'had we listened or reasoned we would not be among the people of the blaze'; let him leave this logical indulgence about them — falsehood has no logic, only whim, bewilderment and confusion. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- The nullifiers of faith and their consequence
A questioner asked what the nullifiers of faith are, what follows for one who nullified his faith, and whether a Muslim's prayer is valid while his faith is voided. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21863, 14 August 2007) answered that the nullifiers are faith's corrupters, invalidators and frustrators — faith is nullified by apostasy as wudu is by ritual impurity; the chief ones: shirk in lordship, shirk in divinity, shirk in the names and attributes, and objecting to, holding oneself above, denying, rejecting, mocking or ridiculing the sharia's rulings; the one who nullifies his faith leaves the community — no prayer or deed of his stands until he renews his faith. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Raising symbols of shirk in the mosque to win hearts
A dawa worker in America who visits churches to present Islam asked about inviting non-Muslims to the mosque while the brothers raised banners of shirk to soften their hearts. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81615, 5 June 2010) answered that letting non-Muslims perform their worship in our mosque when their time comes, to soften hearts, is one thing; taking the initiative to raise those banners of shirk is another — no interest requires it and no ijtihad encompasses it; it is sheer falsehood that must be answered and denounced without causing greater harm, and he referred to the recommendations of the Assembly's course on interfaith dialogue. Recorded as AMJA's answer.
- Saying 'you helped me with this after God'
A question whether one may say to a person 'it was you who helped me with such-and-such after God', in which Ibn Baz answered that there is no harm in it, nor in saying 'were it not for God and then you', 'this is from God and then from you', or 'you helped me after God with such-and-such'; what is not permitted is joining with the conjunction 'and', as in 'were it not for God and you', 'this is from God and you', or 'what God wills and you', since it is this 'and' that is impermissible, whereas 'then' and 'after' are unobjectionable.
- IIFA resolution 121 (13/3) on zakat on shares held to benefit from their dividends
A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 13th session in Kuwait (7–12 Shawwal 1422, 22–27 December 2001), completing its resolution 28 (4/3) on zakat on company shares, which provided that where the company has not paid zakat, the shareholder must pay zakat attributable to his shares if he can work it out from the company's accounts; otherwise, if he holds shares to benefit from the annual yield rather than to trade, he pays zakat on them as income-yielding assets — no zakat on the share principal, only on the yield after a year. It then set out the detailed rulings for computing zakat on shares held for their dividend and its controls in that light.
- IIFA resolution 122 (13/4) on diminishing partnership in the light of recent contracts (deferred)
A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 13th session in Kuwait (7–12 Shawwal 1422, 22–27 December 2001), after reviewing the research on diminishing partnership in the light of recently devised contracts and the members' and experts' discussion. It deferred deciding the topic to a later session for further study and research. Recorded as a deferral, not a final ruling; the subject was later settled in resolution 136 (15/2) at the Muscat session.
- IIFA resolution 130 (14/4) on modern companies: holding companies and others and their legal rulings
A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 14th session in Doha (8–13 Dhu al-Qa'da 1423, 11–16 January 2003). It defined companies of capital as those formed on the partners' capital regardless of each shareholder's independent personality, with tradable shares; classified them into the joint-stock company (capital divided into equal tradable shares, liability limited to the share), the share partnership limited by shares (joint partners bearing full solidary liability alongside limited partners whose liability is capped at their holdings), the limited-liability company, and the holding company. It then set out the legal rulings for their formation, share dealings and the controls on their activity.
- IIFA resolution 136 (15/2) on diminishing partnership (musharaka mutanaqisa) and its legal controls
A collective resolution of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its 15th session in Muscat (14–19 Muharram 1425, 6–11 March 2004). It defined diminishing partnership as a novel transaction comprising a partnership between two parties in an income-yielding venture in which one undertakes to buy the other's share gradually, whether from his share of income or other resources. Its basis: a contract concluded by both, each contributing a capital share in cash or valued tangibles, profit distribution stated, loss borne in proportion to the share. Its distinguishing feature: a binding promise by one party only to acquire the other's share, the other retaining an option, sale contracts being concluded for each portion, even by exchanged notices. It then set out controls for its formation, management and the graduated purchase.