Sects and schools
Family: Unity, division and dissent · 183 entries
Entries on this theme
Concept · 31
The probity of the Companions ('adalat al-sahaba)
A Sunni principle of hadith science: all the Companions are of established probity by the vindication of God and His Messenger, so the probity of the Companion who carries a hadith to the Prophet is not investigated, only that of those after him. Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi sets it out in al-Kifaya, citing Qur'anic verses, hadiths on the merit of the first…Ahl al-Ahwa (the people of deviant opinions in Islam, and the rules on their testimony, narration and prayer behind them)
Ahl al-ahwa are those whose opinions deviate: the word hawa is the soul's inclination against what the law requires; they are Muslims who have strayed from the middle path, such as the Jabriyya, the Qadariyya, the Mu'attila and the Mushabbiha. They differ from the atheists and materialists, since they remain Muslims who believe in God and His Prophet. One…The people of the qibla and not declaring takfir for sin
al-Tahawi's principle of calling the people of the qibla Muslims and believers so long as they accept what the Prophet brought, and of not declaring any of them an unbeliever for a sin unless he declares it lawful.The division of the community (al-iftiraq al-ummah)
The division of the community into sects as Sheikh Omar Abdelkafy raises it: a caller's question on the hadith of the seventy-three groups, his distinction between community and sect, and his call to unity and charitable judgement, with the figures and some sayings not sourced in the recording.Suhba (companionship with the Prophet: who is a Companion, how companionship is proved, the uprightness of all Companions, and the ruling on insulting them)
When the word is used alone in law it means companionship with the Prophet. A Companion is, in Ibn Hajar's view, one who met the Prophet as a believer and died in Islam. Companionship is proved by reports that reach the level of widespread transmission, by general reputation, by a report from a Companion or a Successor that someone was a Companion, or by…Ghayba (occultation)
Ghayba — the Twelver belief that the imam may withdraw from sight without ceasing to exist; for the twelfth imam this is the occultation of the Mahdi, who 'conceals himself in his time... then appears like a meteor in the darkness of night'.Hadr (blood and value wasted: no retaliation, no compensation)
Hadr means waste or nullity; as a technical term, a hadr soul is one for which there is neither retaliation, diya nor expiation. The principle is that a human life is protected, but an apostate is an exception agreed by the jurists: the imam or his deputy executes him, and if someone other than the imam kills him without authorisation there is no…Hawa (desire, and the duty to resist it)
Hawa in the technical sense is the inclination of the soul towards pleasures it relishes, without the call of the law. It differs from shahwa (appetite) in that hawa concerns opinions and beliefs, while shahwa concerns obtaining pleasurable things. Hawa that agrees with the law is praised, and that which opposes it is blamed; the law forbids following the…Ilm al-kalam (speculative theology)
Ilm al-kalam — the new discipline of speculative theology that coalesced in the first Abbasid era; Ahmad Amin traces its rise to internal causes (the Qur'an's own engagement with rival creeds, the post-conquest turn to reflection) and external ones (foreign cultures and religions).The Imamate
In the Encyclopaedia of Islam, the imamate is the supreme leadership of the Muslim community after the Prophet's death, and the article sets out its theological and legal theory among the Sunnis, Mu'tazila, Zaydis, Twelver Imamis, Isma'ilis and Kharijis, each as its own followers state it. Sunni doctrine makes appointing an imam obligatory on the community,…The imamate and its conditions in the preface of Sirat al-Hadi, the Zaydi position
The book's preface, narrated through Muhammad ibn Sulayman al-Kufi, sets out a Zaydi position: the imamate belongs to the descendants of al-Hasan and al-Husayn, obedience is due to the one of them who rises with the sword calling to the Book and the sunna, just, ascetic and brave, and one who sits at home under unjust rulers is not a rightful imam.Infallibility of the Imams (Twelver Shi'a)
Twelver Shi'i doctrine that the imams are infallible from childhood to death, and that infallibility is a condition of the imamate. Presented here as the position the author rebuts, with the Shi'i sources and the author's rebuttal both recorded.Istihsan (juristic preference)
Istihsan in legal theory is disputed in its very definition: an argument that arises in the jurist's mind but is hard to express; departing from one analogy to a stronger one; or restricting an analogy by something stronger. Al-Shawkani reports it attributed to the Hanafis and Hanbalis and rejected by the majority; the Zahiri Ibn Hazm rejects it as…Latency and manifestation (kumun), al-Nazzam's doctrine
The doctrine of the Mu'tazili Abu Ishaq al-Nazzam that things lie latent in bodies before they appear — fire in wood and stone, oil in sesame, blood in man — and that burning is the coming-out of a thing's own fires; his pupil al-Jahiz set it out in Kitab al-Hayawan with al-Nazzam's arguments against Dirar ibn 'Amr and the 'people of accidents', and 'Abd…The twenty-eight schools in al-Muqaddasi
Al-Muqaddasi's classification of the schools 'in use in Islam today' in his time into twenty-eight, in seven groups of four: four in law, four in theology, four with both law and theology, four of the hadith folk, four extinct, four rural, and four absorbed by four of their kind; the classification is his own.The doctrine of the awaited Mahdi (al-mahdiyya)
The Mahdiyya — the awaited twelfth imam who fills the earth with justice; opposed in the Umayyad claim to a 'Sufyani' and absorbed in the Abbasid coining of a 'Mahdi' of their own.Mut'a (temporary marriage)
Mut'a — fixed-term marriage for a fee; Ahmad Amin surveys the hadiths (licensed in travel and need, then forbidden, with Umar's emphatic prohibition and the four imams' ijma') against the Shi'i retention via al-Baqir and al-Sadiq.Raj'a (the return to the world)
Raj'a — the doctrine that after the Mahdi's appearance the imams and their opponents return to this world for retribution, then die and rise on Judgement Day; earliest attributed to Ibn Saba'.The reports of "the man of Yemen" in the preface of Sirat al-Hadi
The preface gathers reports and verses attributed to Ali, Muhammad al-Baqir and others that foretell the rising of a man of the Prophet's family in Yemen after 280 AH, and the narrators then point to al-Hadi, after saying they looked at those who had risen before him and found the qualities in none.Sabi'a (the Sabians: who they were, whether they are People of the Book, and the rulings on their land, blood money, food and marriage)
The Sabians are a people whose religion the jurists classed in different ways: whether they are People of the Book. Abu Hanifa and Ahmad in one report count them among the People of the Book, while Abu Yusuf, Muhammad, most Malikis and one Shafi'i view count them among the others because they worship the stars; the Shafi'is distinguish those who differ from…Shar' man qablana (the law of earlier prophets, and whether it binds us)
The shar' in language is the clear road to water; in the technical sense it is the religion God established for His servants, and 'those before us' are the messengers before our Prophet. The revealed laws share one root in belief, and the usulis differ on whether the law of earlier prophets binds us: the Hanafis, Malikis and Hanbalis hold it binding on us…Shu'um (ill omen) and tatayyur (taking omens)
In language shu'um is ill, and tashaum is expecting ill; the Arabs used to take omens from birds that flew by, to left or right, and the law forbade this with the words there is no tatayyur and no hamah. Some Hanbalis hold tashaum disliked but not fal, and others hold omen-taking among the grave sins. The hadith names three things where ill omen lies: the…Shudhudh (an irregular view or report, and acting on it)
In language shudhudh is separation from others, and a shadh is one who stands apart or leaves the group. In the usage of the Hanafis and Malikis a shadh view is one opposed to the prominent, preferred or sound view; in the usage of the hadith scholars a shadh report has a single chain in which a reliable or unreliable narrator stands alone. Acting on a…Shu'ubiyya
Shu'ubiyya — the anti-Arab-chauvinist tendency of the first Abbasid era: Ahmad Amin distinguishes three positions in the Arab–mawali quarrel and shows the name settled on those who denied Arab superiority, from 'people of equality' (al-Aqd al-Farid) to those who belittled the Arabs entirely (Lisan al-Arab).Siyasa (governance under the law, in the Mawsu'a)
In language siyasa is the upkeep of a thing in the way that sets it right. The technical sense has two meanings: a general one, the government of the state and of power, meaning the guidance of people to what saves them and the management of their affairs; and a penal one, where the ruler acts for a benefit he sees without a specific text. The Hanafis,…Disavowal (tabarri) of the Companions in Twelver Shi'a sources
Twelver Shi'i sources, as the author quotes them, hold that most Companions apostatised after the Prophet, except a few, and require disavowal of Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Mu'awiya and the Prophet's wives. Presented here with the Sunni rebuttal (the Companions' adala and the prohibition of insulting them) and the author's account of what Ali and the imams of…Taqiyya (dissimulation)
Taqiyya — the Shi'i doctrine of protective dissimulation: 'nine-tenths of religion is taqiyya' in al-Kulayni's report; the secret system by which imams' followers concealed their designs, and which generated the esoteric reading of speech.Tariqa (Sufi order)
The tariqa in later usage is the organized Sufi path attached to a shaykh and his way; Trimingham surveys the ramification of its main lines, and bibliographical works like Kashf al-Zunun attribute orders to their eponyms — Naqshbandiyya, Qadiriyya, Mawlawiyya.Ta'wil in the Qur'an
What the word ta'wil means in the Qur'an and in scholarly usage. Rashid Rida holds that in the Qur'an it means outcome, what a matter comes to. In al-Sawa'iq al-Mursala Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya distinguishes three senses: the reality to which speech refers in the world, its sense in the Qur'an and Sunna; explanation and exposition, the usage of the exegetes…The Twelve Imams (Twelver Shi'a)
Twelver Shi'i doctrine that the imamate passes by explicit designation (nass) of God through the Prophet, through twelve named imams from Ali ibn Abi Talib to Muhammad ibn al-Hasan. The author lists the imams and rebuts the scriptural and hadith arguments used for the doctrine.Zandaqa (heresy)
Zandaqa — the accusation of freethinking/heresy that ran through the first Abbasid era, levelled truly and falsely; Ahmad Amin frames the struggle between doubt and faith as an all-out war fought by ruse, sword and disputation alike.
What is missing? Tell us · A theme is open when it has a reviewed guide, 10 questions, 25 entries across 5 classes, and voices from several traditions and regions.