Sects and schools
Family: Unity, division and dissent · 183 entries
Entries on this theme
Question · 33
Did Adam argue from destiny against Moses to excuse his sin?
The two Sahihs relate the debate of Adam and Moses, ending 'So Adam prevailed over Moses'. Ibn Taymiyya says many took it that Adam argued from destiny to deny blame for his sin, and so split into three parties: one rejected the hadith, such as Abu Ali al-Jubba'i; one interpreted it in ways he holds unsound; and one made it a proof that sinners are free of…Did al-Hasan al-Askari leave a son? The awaited Mahdi of the Imamiyya in Minhaj al-Sunna
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli stated that the twelfth imam, Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, is the Mahdi promised in the hadith. Ibn Taymiyya replied that al-Tabari, Abd al-Baqi ibn Qani' and other genealogists and historians recorded that al-Hasan al-Askari had no offspring; that an orphaned child cannot be an infallible imam; that his occultation achieved none of the…Does the science of kalam go back to Ali?
Among Ali's virtues al-Hilli listed that the science of kalam derives from his sermons and that all people are his pupils in it; Ibn Taymiyya replied that this kalam was unknown to the Companions and Successors, appeared after the first century through al-Ja'd ibn Dirham and al-Jahm ibn Safwan and then the circle of Amr ibn Ubayd, and that Ali's…Did the Prophet point to Abu Bakr as his successor?
Al-Hilli reports the Sunni view as holding that the Prophet designated no imam and that Abu Bakr took office by Umar's pledge with the consent of four, and himself holds the three caliphates invalid; Ibn Taymiyya holds that the Prophet guided the community to Abu Bakr's caliphate through reports such as that of the woman told 'if you do not find me, go to…Do prophets leave an inheritance? Fatima's claim between al-Hilli and Ibn Taymiyya
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli faulted Abu Bakr for withholding Fatima's inheritance from the Prophet, saying that he alone transmitted 'We are not inherited from', that he was her adversary, and that the Qur'an contradicts the report; Ibn Taymiyya replied in Minhaj al-Sunna that a group of senior Companions transmitted the hadith, that Abu Bakr took nothing of…Does a divorce pronounced during menstruation take effect?
Ibn Hazm reports in al-Muhalla that some who hold that a divorce during menstruation takes effect claimed consensus for it, and answers that the disagreement exists; he holds that a divorce during menstruation, or in a period of purity in which intercourse took place, does not bind and is not counted, being a transgression of God's limits, and relates the…Does the hadith of Ghadir designate Ali as imam?
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli presented the hadith of Ghadir Khumm, 'Of whomever I am mawla, Ali is his mawla', as a mass-transmitted report that came with the verse 'Convey what has been sent down to you', mawla meaning the one with greater right to authority, and so as an explicit designation of Ali's imamate. Ibn Taymiyya replied in Minhaj al-Sunna that the…Does the hadith 'You are to me as Aaron was to Moses' designate Ali as successor?
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli made the hadith of the rank (manzila) the third of his hadith proofs for Ali's imamate: it gives him all of Aaron's ranks except prophethood, among them succession. Ibn Taymiyya replies in Minhaj al-Sunna that the hadith is established in the two Sahihs but was said when Ali was left in charge of Medina during the Tabuk campaign, to…Was the verse 'Your friend is only God and His Messenger' revealed about Ali?
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli made al-Ma'ida 5:55 the first of his Qur'anic proofs of Ali's imamate, claiming consensus that it was revealed about him when he gave his ring in charity while bowing in prayer, and taking wali in it to mean the one with authority. Ibn Taymiyya replied in Minhaj al-Sunna that the story is fabricated according to the hadith scholars,…How did Sunni scholars treat al-Kashshaf, given its Mu'tazili content?
Al-Zamakhshari's al-Kashshaf is a commentary of Mu'tazili creed whose author calls his school 'the people of justice and divine unity'; yet many Sunni scholars praised it for its rhetoric and mastery of ma'ani and bayan, wrote glosses on it, and Ibn al-Munayyir the Maliki answered its Mu'tazili content in al-Intisaf.How does Tafsir al-Jalalayn explain the verses on the divine attributes?
The two Jalals explain some attributes by what they entail — mercy as willing good for those who deserve it, the 'hand' in the verse of the pledge as God's knowledge of their pledge and His requital of it — and say of the rising over the Throne 'a rising befitting Him'. The reviser of the Maktabat al-Iman edition holds that the book contains departures in…How should the killing of al-Husayn and the day of Ashura be regarded?
In Minhaj al-Sunna Ibn Taymiyya divides views of al-Husayn's killing into two extremes and a middle: that he was killed rightly for seeking to split the community; that he was the imam whose obedience was due; and the middle, which he names the Sunni view, that he was killed wrongfully as a martyr and was not the ruler of the community. He holds that…How should Yazid ibn Mu'awiya be judged?
In Minhaj al-Sunna Ibn Taymiyya divides people's views of Yazid ibn Mu'awiya into two extremes and a middle: those who make him a Companion, a rightly guided caliph or a prophet; those who make him a hidden unbeliever seeking revenge for the dead of Badr; and the middle, for him, that he was one of the kings of the Muslims. He holds that Yazid did not order…Is making a bequest obligatory, and is it owed to non-inheriting relatives?
Ibn Hazm reports in al-Muhalla that Abu Hanifa, Malik, al-Shafi'i and al-Nakha'i do not hold a bequest obligatory nor require one for non-inheriting relatives, the view also of al-Zuhri, Salim, Sulayman ibn Yasar, 'Amr ibn Dinar, Ibn Sirin, al-Awza'i and al-Thawri; he holds, with Dawud and his school, that a bequest is obligatory on everyone who leaves…Is the riba of sales limited to the six commodities?
Ibn Hazm reports in al-Muhalla that riba occurs in sales and forward sales of the six commodities by consensus, and that scholars differ over other goods: Malik makes the cause being stored food together with being a currency, al-Shafi'i being food together with being a currency, and Abu Hanifa and his followers being measured by volume or weight; he holds,…Is shortening the prayer on a journey obligatory, and on what journey?
In al-Muhalla Ibn Hazm makes the traveller's two units an obligation on every journey, whether of obedience, of disobedience or neither, voids the prayer of one who knowingly prays four, and sets the journey at a mile or more and the stay that ends it at more than twenty days; he reports that Abu Hanifa makes shortening obligatory on every journey, that…Is the imamate the most important matter of religion?
In the introduction to Minhaj al-Karama, Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli stated that the imamate is the most important matter in the rules of religion; Ibn Taymiyya replied that faith in God and His Messenger is more important at every time, and that the Prophet accepted Islam on repentance, prayer and zakat without mentioning the imamate.Is zakat due on trade goods?
Ibn Hazm reports in al-Muhalla that Abu Hanifa, Malik and al-Shafi'i, in one of his two views, require zakat on goods held for trade, arguing from Samura's report and from reports from 'Umar, Ibn 'Abbas and Ibn 'Umar; he holds that zakat is due only on eight kinds of wealth, gold, silver, wheat, barley, dates, camels, cattle and sheep and goats, and that…May musical instruments be sold?
Ibn Hazm holds in al-Muhalla that selling chess sets, pipes, lutes, stringed instruments and tanburs is lawful, that whoever breaks one is liable for it, and that buying and selling singing girls is likewise lawful, reporting that Abu Hanifa also held the breaker liable; he sets out the hadiths cited by those who forbid and weakens all of them, including…May a Muslim say: I am a believer, God willing?
The question of the exception in faith: Ibn Batta al-Ukbari holds that it is a mark of people of knowledge to say 'I am a believer, God willing', not out of doubt but out of apprehension and refusal to praise oneself; his editor notes that scholars hold three views: that it is required, that it is forbidden because it suggests doubt, and a distinction…May one say 'my utterance of the Qur'an is created', or suspend judgement on its createdness?
After the inquisition over the createdness of the Qur'an two positions appeared that Ahmad ibn Hanbal, in reports from him, counted among the branches of the Jahmiyya: that of the 'Lafziyya', that the Qur'an is God's uncreated speech but our utterance and recitation of it are created – attributed to Husayn al-Karabisi – and that of the 'Waqifa', who say…Is the Ramadan fast valid on a journey?
Ibn Hazm reports five views in al-Muhalla: one whom Ramadan reaches at home must fast it even if he travels; he may choose, fasting being better, the view of Abu Hanifa, Malik and al-Shafi'i; he may choose, both being equal; he may choose, breaking being better; and his fast does not count and he must break it. He takes the last, making breaking the fast…Is a prayer deliberately left until its time has passed made up?
Ibn Hazm reports in al-Muhalla that Abu Hanifa, Malik and al-Shafi'i require one who deliberately left a prayer until its time passed to make it up, while he holds that it can never be made up, so the person should do much good and voluntary prayer, repent and ask forgiveness; he argues from the verses threatening those heedless of their prayer and those…Must reason be preferred when it conflicts with revelation?
The question of the 'universal law': al-Razi and his followers, anticipated by al-Ghazali, al-Juwayni and al-Baqillani, held that certain rational proof takes precedence over the apparent sense of a text when they conflict, since reason is the root of transmission, and the text is then interpreted or its meaning left to God. Ibn Taymiyya replied in Dar'…Are the feet washed or wiped in ablution?
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli counted the obligation to wash the feet as a change to the wiping that the Qur'an states; Ibn Taymiyya replied in Minhaj al-Sunna that washing the feet is transmitted from the Prophet by mass practice, that the word 'wipe' in the verse can mean the general wiping of which washing is one kind, and that the accusative reading is…Must the imam be infallible?
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli made the imam's infallibility his first rational proof of Ali's imamate, grounding it in the needs of human society and in the favour (lutf) he held God must grant; Ibn Taymiyya replied that the infallible one whose obedience is due is the Messenger, and that the purpose of an imam is not achieved by a hidden one.Is narration from people of innovation accepted?
A question in the criticism of transmitters: if a transmitter is truthful and retentive but holds an innovation in belief, such as Shi'ism, the Qadari view or the view of the Kharijites, is he narrated from? In the introduction to Mizan al-I'tidal al-Dhahabi reports from Ibn Sirin that after the civil strife the early scholars took the hadith of the people…Should Abu Bakr have punished Khalid ibn al-Walid for killing Malik ibn Nuwayra?
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli counted among his charges against Abu Bakr that he neither retaliated against Khalid ibn al-Walid nor punished him when Khalid killed Malik ibn Nuwayra, a Muslim, and married his wife the night he was killed. Ibn Taymiyya answers in Minhaj al-Sunna that Khalid killed him on an interpretation, believing him an apostate; that one who…Was al-Alusi Salafi in creed?
Al-Zirikli calls him 'Salafi in belief, a mujtahid'; a recent doctoral thesis concludes that he was Salafi in creed on the whole while pausing over him on some points, quoting his words that the safest course is to leave figurative reinterpretation except where the early generations reinterpreted; his biography also records that he took the Naqshbandi path…Does Ibn Atiyya's commentary lean towards the Mu'tazila?
Al-Muharrar al-Wajiz has been charged with Mu'tazili leanings: Ibn Taymiyya held it closer to the Sunna than al-Kashshaf but following those it calls 'the verifiers', theologians of the kalam schools; Ibn Arafa the Maliki, as quoted by Ibn Hajar al-Haytami, held it more dangerous than al-Kashshaf because it slips Mu'tazilism in; Abd al-Wahhab Fayid rejects…Was Mu'awiya a scribe of the revelation?
Al-Hilli rejected calling Mu'awiya a scribe of the revelation, saying he never wrote a word of it, and that on the day of the conquest of Mecca he was in Yemen reviling the Prophet and taunting his father in verse for embracing Islam; Ibn Taymiyya replied that this was a claim without proof, that the verses were forged in Mu'awiya's name, and that many who…What is the hadd for drinking wine, and is the drinker executed at the fourth offence?
Ibn Hazm reports four views in al-Muhalla on the punishment for wine: the Prophet fixed none and later authorities did; there is none; it is eighty lashes; it is forty. He takes forty, with al-Shafi'i and Dawud, regarding 'Umar's addition as discretionary punishment, not hadd; he reports that Malik, al-Shafi'i and Abu Hanifa do not hold the drinker executed…Who is the best of this community after its Prophet?
The question of ranking the Companions as presented in the chapters of Ahmad ibn Hanbal's Fada'il al-Sahaba: reports from Ali ibn Abi Talib that the best of the community after its Prophet are Abu Bakr then Umar, and reports from Ibn Umar that in the Prophet's lifetime they ranked Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman and then made no further distinction — with…
What is missing? Tell us · A theme is open when it has a reviewed guide, 10 questions, 25 entries across 5 classes, and voices from several traditions and regions.