Development of law, theology and institutions
Family: How Islam changed over time · 299 entries
Entries on this theme
Concept · 127
Ambiguity (ijmal)
For the mutakallimun among the usulis, mujmal is what its meaning does not make clear. For the Hanafis it is what cannot be understood without an explanation from the speaker, so that it is not found by reflection alone. Ambiguity can lie in words or deeds; an example of a deed is the Prophet's salam after two rak'as when it was unclear whether he forgot or…Ijtihad (independent juristic reasoning)
Ijtihad: the jurist's exertion of effort to derive a ruling from the revealed sources. Al-Sayis's view is that it discloses God's ruling rather than legislating, and binds only the mujtahid and those who follow him.Sufficiency of an act (ijza')
Ijza' in the lexicon means sufficiency and being enough. In law it is an act's being enough to meet what is required, even without anything added to it. It differs from permissibility (jawaz), which means that nothing forbids the act, and from lawfulness (hill), which means purity from every blemish: an act may be sufficient while disliked. In the Hanbali…Ikhala (suggestiveness of a cause in analogy)
Ikhala: a description is suggestive when its fitness to the ruling is so plain that its causal role is fixed at once; it is the ground of benefit in analogy and of open interest. The appropriate is wider than the suggestive; an accidental description is not suggestive; the killing of a Muslim used as a shield is an example; the explaining of a ruling by a…Ikhbar (report, and its names in law)
Ikhbar is the act of reporting; it has names according to its subject: claim, acknowledgement, testimony, judgement, narration, backbiting, tale-bearing, disclosure and betrayal; the report of a just person is accepted, while a dissolute person's report is not accepted in religious matters; its detailed rules are read where they arise, in purity,…Ikhtilaf (disagreement among jurists and its kinds)
Ikhtilaf (disagreement): true disagreement is contrariety; differences of expression and variety go back to agreement. Disagreement in religion has four kinds according to whether the principle is proved by decisive evidence; disagreement in ijtihad matters occurs and the dissenter is excused; it occurred in the time of the Companions; al-Shatibi reduced it…Ikhtilaf al-dar (difference of abodes in law)
Ikhtilaf al-dar (difference of abodes): the difference of the two states of the two persons; between Muslims it has no effect, since the abode of Islam is one; among unbelievers the Hanafis count a difference of abode in ruling as a bar to inheritance, the Shafi'is are close to them, and the Malikis and Hanbalis do not bar inheritance while the religions…Ikhtilas (taking by snatching, not subject to amputation)
Ikhtilas is taking a thing in the owner's presence openly and running off with it; by agreement there is no amputation for it, since the thing can be recovered by calling for help from people and the authority; its rules are treated under theft and usurpation..The effective cause (illa) in legal reasoning
In the lexicon, illa means an illness, and also a cause; as a term of the jurists of legal theory it is an apparent and regular attribute that the Lawgiver attached to a ruling and set as a sign of it. It is distinct from the wisdom (hikma) of a ruling, which is the purpose it serves. An illa differs from a sabab in that the ruling follows the illa without…Does a prohibition entail the invalidity of what is prohibited?
A question of legal theory: when the Lawgiver forbids a sale, a marriage or another act that produces legal effects, does the prohibition show that the act is invalid, that is, that its effects do not follow? Al-Ghazali in al-Mustasfa sets out three views: the great majority hold that it entails invalidity; some distinguish what is forbidden in itself from…Iqtida' (implication, demand and claim of a right)
In the language, iqtida' means demanding a right and taking it in full. The usul scholars use it for implication (dalala). Implication is an unspoken element that a speech needs in order to be correct or true. For example, the words 'free your slave on my behalf for a thousand' cannot be valid unless the speaker is first taken to have asked for the sale of…Iqtisar (a ruling taking effect only at the moment it arises)
In the jurists' usage, iqtisar means that a ruling takes effect when its cause arises, and not before or after, as with an immediate divorce. Ibn 'Abidin defines it as the ruling taking effect now. The Hanafi scholar al-Haskafi lists four ways a ruling takes effect: inqilab (a non-cause becoming a cause), iqtisar, istinad (taking effect now and tracing back…Fortune-telling by the 'arraf' (irafa)
Irafa has two senses. The first is the trade of the 'arraf', who claims to know hidden matters by means of premises and signs, such as who stole an object or where a lost animal is. The second is the verbal noun of managing a people's affairs and governing them. In the juristic sense, irafa is forbidden: whoever goes to a soothsayer (kahin) or an 'arraf'…Istihsan (juristic preference)
Istihsan in legal theory is disputed in its very definition: an argument that arises in the jurist's mind but is hard to express; departing from one analogy to a stronger one; or restricting an analogy by something stronger. Al-Shawkani reports it attributed to the Hanafis and Hanbalis and rejected by the majority; the Zahiri Ibn Hazm rejects it as…Proof in litigation (ithbat)
Ithbat in the lexicon is the verb athbata, to treat a thing as lasting, settled or sound. In the jurists' usage it is the establishment before the judge, in his session, of a lawful proof of a right or a fact. Its aim is that the claimant obtains his right or is protected from interference. The burden of proof lies on the claimant by agreement of the four…Sin (ithm)
In the lexicon, ithm means sin, or doing what is not lawful for one. For the Sunnis it is the deserving of punishment; for the Mu'tazila it is the necessity of punishment. The difference turns on whether forgiveness is possible. Sin attaches to abandoning an individual obligation, such as prayer, and to abandoning a collective obligation when all leave it,…Destruction or damage of property (itlaf)
Itlaf comes from talaf, to perish, and atlafahu, to destroy. For jurists it is removing a thing from its usual useful purpose. The default ruling is prohibition when the act is not permitted by the law. It can also be obligatory or permitted. Its usual consequence is liability when a protected, owned property of another is destroyed without the permission…Completion (itmam)
Itmam in the lexicon means completion. Jurists gave it no technical definition beyond the lexical one. It has one specific use, which concerns number rather than manner: completing a prayer instead of shortening it on a journey. Completing an obligatory act once begun is obligatory by the agreement of the jurists; completing a voluntary act is disputed.Ittiba' (following; returning to a proven ruling)
In the language, ittiba' means walking behind another; it also carries the senses of following someone in prayer, obeying a command, acting on another's word, and demanding a due. As a technical term it is returning to a saying that rests on a proof. The jurists separate it from taqlid: taqlid is acting on another's word without proof, while ittiba' is…Unity of the ruling (ittihad al-hukm)
Literally ittihad is two things becoming one, and the ruling (hukm) is God's address concerning the acts of responsible persons, by demand, by choice or by stipulation. The usulis treat unity of the ruling in two places: when a word appears unrestricted in one text and restricted in another, and when one ruling has several causes. The majority allow one…Unity of the session (ittihad al-majlis)
The unity of the session is the single sitting in which a word or act occurs. It is wider than the seat: it can hold while standing, and it can hold when place and posture change. It affects contracts, exchange of ribawi goods, salam, marriage and khul', the renewal of ablution, vomiting, prostration of recitation, repeated divorce, oaths, zihar and…Unity of the cause (ittihad al-sabab)
In the terms of jurists and usulis, the sabab is an apparent and regular attribute to which the Lawgiver attached a ruling, such that its presence entails the ruling and its absence entails none. Unity of the cause means that several causes are alike, belong to one class, or are in fact one. Usulis discuss it in the question of the unrestricted and the…Leaning (ittika')
Ittika' in the lexicon means leaning on something; it also means inclining to one side while sitting. Jurists use the word only in these two senses. Leaning during prayer is permitted for those with a valid excuse; for others it is disliked in an obligatory prayer and permitted in a voluntary one. Leaning on a grave is treated like sitting on it: the…Connection (ittisal)
Ittisal in the lexicon means non-separation, the opposite of separation. Jurists use it of physical things, such as the rows in congregational prayer or increments attached to a sold object, and of meanings, such as an offer joined to its acceptance. Increments that are permanently attached follow the principal ruling and cannot be pledged separately. A…Consideration (iwad) in contracts, marriage, injury and damage
In the lexicon, iwad is a substitute, what is given in return for a thing; it is also used of the reward in the hereafter. The jurists require that the consideration be paid in exchange contracts: the hirer and the lessor, the husband's dower, the one who destroys a thing must return its like or its value, and the killer owes the blood-money. Some things…Khass (specific; opposite of general)
Khass (specific) is lexically the opposite of general; technically a term coined for one thing or a limited number, whether a single person such as Zayd or a kind such as man or horse. A general term embraces all that it can apply to under one coinage without limit. A specific word fixes its ruling unless a proof calls for another meaning; when specific and…The phrase "la yanbaghi" in Imam Ahmad's words
The expression "la yanbaghi" ("it is not proper") in Imam Ahmad's words: is it understood as prohibition or as dislike? His companions differed over it, an example of disagreement over the school's wording.The madhhab
The madhhab in juristic usage is the method of ijtihad and legal inference traced to an imam and his school; the jurists speak of the 'four madhhabs' — Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali.The mazalim (courts of grievances)
Mazalim — the caliphal grievance institution above the ordinary qadi's remit: al-Mahdi's iron-windowed complaints house and al-Muhtadi's four-doored Dome of Redress.The clear and the ambiguous verses (muhkam and mutashabih)
Sha'rawi holds that the muhkam is what leaves no room for disagreement and is the basis of action, and that the mutashabih is what is hard to grasp and is the basis of faith. The believer refers the ambiguous to the clear. He reports the disagreement over where to pause after the name of God or after those firm in knowledge, without ruling between them.Mut'a (temporary marriage)
Mut'a — fixed-term marriage for a fee; Ahmad Amin surveys the hadiths (licensed in travel and need, then forbidden, with Umar's emphatic prohibition and the four imams' ijma') against the Shi'i retention via al-Baqir and al-Sadiq.Nafadh (taking effect)
Nafadh, in the lexicon, is passing and taking effect; as a term it is the effect of a valid disposition taking hold at once. Every effective disposition is valid, but not every valid one is effective, and ratification applies to a suspended contract but not to an effective or void one. Dispositions that do not take effect include those of an unauthorised…Share (nasib) in the rules of property and inheritance
Nasib, in the lexicon, is a share or portion of anything; a share is also the part of something divided. In inheritance every nasib is a fixed share but not every fixed share is a nasib. The law fixes the shares of heirs: a half, a quarter, an eighth, two-thirds, a third and a sixth, detailed under inheritance. In partnership a partner may dispose of his…Freedom of belief and compulsion in religion
Sha'rawi holds that God did not compel anyone into belief, since force governs bodies, not hearts. A person who has entered Islam is bound to observe its duties. He reads the early weakness of Muslims as intended, and the jizya as evidence that those who kept their religion remained.Qiyafa (legal rulings)
In the jurists' usage, qiyafa is the reading of likeness, either of footprints or of a person's bodily features, to establish kinship or trace an act. The Malikis, Shafi'is and Hanbalis allow relying on it to settle a disputed lineage when no stronger proof exists, while the Hanafis reject it because the law confines lineage to the marriage bed (firash).…Qiyas
Qiyas in usul usage is extending a root case's ruling to a branch case for a shared cause; al-Shafi'i counts it in the Risala among the proofs alongside the Book, the Sunna and ijma'. Al-Ghazali's Mustasfa ranks four kinds of qiyas: the effective (mu'aththir), whose cause's effect appears by text, consensus or exhaustive inquiry; then the suitable…The descent of the Qur'an: sending down and gradual descent
Sha'rawi holds that the Qur'an had two descents: a sending down, all at once, to the lowest heaven on the Night of Power, and a gradual descent to the Prophet over twenty-three years as events required. He holds that the Torah and the Gospel came down once, and that the gradual descent was to steady the Prophet and to teach the community.The reports from Imam Ahmad
The statements transmitted from Imam Ahmad on a single question, and how his companions reconciled them and preferred one over another; they are the school's foundation in jurisprudence.Sharia
In Islamic usage, sharia is the body of rules and regulations governing Muslim life, derived in principle from the Qur'an and hadith and closely tied to fiqh, the scholarly discussion of divine law. The Encyclopaedia of Islam article traces the word in the Qur'an and hadith and in Jewish, Christian and Muslim writing, and describes usul al-fiqh and ijtihad,…Obedience to those in authority and not rebelling (in the Tahawi creed)
al-Tahawi's position: no rebelling against the imams and rulers even if they are unjust, obeying them is part of obeying God so long as they do not command disobedience, and the pilgrimage and jihad continue with them.Taqlid
Taqlid in usul usage is accepting another's saying without proof; the Kuwaiti Fiqh Encyclopedia gives it a dedicated entry.Is every mujtahid right? (taswib and takhti'a)
A question of legal theory: when two mujtahids reason on a question and reach different answers, are both right, or is one right and the other mistaken? The life of al-Kasani in the introduction to the Bada'i' edition relates that he debated it with a jurist in the land of Rum: the jurist ascribed to Abu Hanifa the view that every mujtahid is right;…Excuse (udhr)
Linguistically, udhr is the reason a person offers in his defence; it means lifting blame, and the technical sense does not depart from it. Related are rukhsa, a rule enacted for an excuse while the forbidding cause remains, and afw, the pardoning of a fault and dropping of blame. Excuses are general or specific. Some stay with a person, such as irregular…Aggression (udwan)
Linguistically, udwan means going beyond a limit; in the jurists' usage it mostly refers to an unjust attack on a person's life or property, which calls for retaliation (qisas) or compensation (daman). Related words are zulm and ithm: the lexicographers and commentators treat udwan as narrower than sin and as close in meaning to injustice. Its ruling…Warranty (uhda) in sale and in pre-emption, and the defect
In sale, 'uhda is the seller's guarantee of the price or of the title when the object is claimed by a third party. In pre-emption it is the return of ownership to the pre-emptor or buyer; in the option for a defect it is the guarantee when a defect appears. In pre-emption the Shafi'is and Malikis place the warranty on the seller if the pre-emptor took the…Rent, fee or wage (ujra)
Ujra, lexically and in law, is the counterpart of a benefit: what a worker receives for his labour, and what the owner of a thing receives for its use. A rent may be anything that may serve as a price, whether goods, another benefit, or money, paid at once or deferred. A contract with an unknown rent, or with a rent that is part of the work done, such as…The 'Umariyya cases of inheritance (the mother's third)
'Umariyya is the name of two cases in the law of inheritance, a husband with both parents or a wife with both parents, named after 'Umar ibn al-Khattab, who was the first to decide them. The mother takes a third where the deceased has no child or grandchild and the parents alone inherit, and a sixth where there is a child or two or more siblings. 'Umar and…Generality (umum) in the sources of law and what it covers
In the lexicon, 'umum is the act of covering and including, from 'amma, to cover. Some usulis define it as the inclusion of individuals at once; al-Mazari defines a general statement as one that includes two things or more. The general term (amm) is a word that applies to individuals of agreed limits in full, the particular (khusus) is its opposite, and the…General affliction ('umum al-balwa) and the rulings built on it
General affliction is a situation or event that touches many people and cannot easily be avoided; some jurists call it general necessity. On it the jurists built concessions, such as overlooking small impurities such as the blood of sores and the droppings of birds, the purity of a leather sock or shoe cleaned by rubbing, the contract for manufacture…The generality of the implied (umum al-muqtada) in the usage of texts
'Umum al-muqtada is the implied meaning that the truth or soundness of a speech requires, though it is not stated in the words; it must be supplied for the speech to be sound, and the text is applied only after it is supplied. The Hanafis hold that an implied meaning has no generality, since generality belongs to words and the implied is not a word; the…Punishment (uquba): fixed, retaliatory and discretionary
In the lexicon, uquba is a penalty, a noun from 'iqab; as a term it is the penalty fixed for a wrong, or what falls on a person as a deserved consequence of an offence. Penalties are classed by kind, as retaliation, fixed punishment (hadd) and discretionary punishment (ta'zir); by whether the right belongs to God, to people, or to both; and by whether they…Zina
Zina in juristic usage is among the fixed hudud penalties; the Kuwaiti Fiqh Encyclopedia's 'hadd al-zina' entry details its rulings.
What is missing? Tell us · A theme is open when it has a reviewed guide, 10 questions, 25 entries across 5 classes, and voices from several traditions and regions.