Scripture and its sciences
Family: Belief and worship · 1048 entries
Entries on this theme
Question · 69
How many Companions were there?
In the preface to Tajrid Asma' al-Sahaba al-Dhahabi quotes figures that measure different things: al-Shafi'i's that the Muslims at the Prophet's death numbered sixty thousand, Abu Zur'a's that more than a hundred thousand saw and heard him, and al-Hakim's that four thousand narrated from him; his own view is that the narrators were about fifteen hundred and…Who was the best of the Successors?
A question whose views al-Suyuti gathers in Tadrib al-Rawi: Ahmad is reported to have named Sa'id ibn al-Musayyab as the best, with other reports from him naming Qays, Abu Uthman al-Nahdi, Alqama and Masruq; Ibn Khafif reported that the people of Medina said Ibn al-Musayyab, those of Kufa Uways al-Qarani and those of Basra al-Hasan, which Ibn al-Salah…May a transmitter take payment for teaching hadith?
A question of the ethics of transmission on which al-Khatib al-Baghdadi gathers two chapters in al-Kifaya: one on 'the dislike of taking payment for teaching hadith, and those who said one should not hear from a man who does so', citing al-Hasan, Hammad ibn Salama, Abu al-Aliya, Ishaq ibn Rahawayh, Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Abu Hatim; and one recording those who…Are the seven readings the seven ahruf?
Scholars state that the seven ahruf are not the readings of the seven readers; Abu Shama counts the opinion otherwise as against the consensus of the people of knowledge, Makki as a great mistake, and Ibn Taymiyya says Ibn Mujahid gathered them to match the number, not believing they are the ahruf; what remains is whether the readings mass-transmitted today…Did al-Jawhari originate the arrangement of al-Sihah, or did others precede him?
Al-Sihah arranges words in chapters by the last radical of the root. Hamad al-Jasir disputed crediting al-Jawhari with this method, showing that al-Bandaniji (d. 284 AH) had arranged his Kitab al-Taqfiya by word endings about a century earlier, and Khalil Ibrahim al-Atiyya followed him; the orientalist Krenkow claimed al-Jawhari took his uncle al-Farabi's…Did al-Tabari reject established readings in Jami' al-Bayan?
In his book on the readings al-Tabari laid down that no one reading a sound reading that agrees with the script of the codex is to be faulted, yet in Jami' al-Bayan he judged readings by the script, the agreement of most readers and the most eloquent Arabic, and rejected readings held by single readers later counted among the Seven; Ibn al-Jazari holds that…Do the texts of revelation yield certainty?
Al-Razi said in Muhassal Afkar al-Mutaqaddimin wa'l-Muta'akhkhirin that verbal proof gives certainty only when ten things are certain, among them the reliability of the transmitters of the words, the absence of figurative and ambiguous use and the absence of a rational objection. Ibn al-Qayyim made this the first of the 'four idols' in al-Sawa'iq al-Mursala…Does 'You will not see Me' deny that God can be seen? Al-Zamakhshari and Ibn al-Munayyir
Commenting on Moses' request to see God in al-A'raf 143, al-Zamakhshari in al-Kashshaf, on the Mu'tazili view, holds that Moses asked in order to silence his people and that 'lan' strengthens the denial of what is incompatible with God's attributes; Ibn al-Munayyir answers in al-Intisaf, on the Sunni view, that seeing God is rationally possible, that Moses…Does the Qur'an contain the roots of every science?
At the start of al-Burhan al-Zarkashi's tradition of counting the Qur'anic sciences goes back to Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi, who numbered them as the Qur'an's words times four; al-Suyuti, in the type 'sciences derived from the Qur'an', says God's Book contains everything, so that there is no root chapter or question of any science without something in the Qur'an…Does the Qur'an contain words from languages other than Arabic?
For al-Qurtubi there is no disagreement that the Qur'an contains no speech composed in non-Arab styles and that it contains foreign proper names such as Isra'il and Jibril; the disagreement is over single words other than names: al-Baqillani and al-Tabari deny them, calling them words in which languages coincided; others accept a few that do not stop the…Was the verse 'Your friend is only God and His Messenger' revealed about Ali?
Ibn al-Mutahhar al-Hilli made al-Ma'ida 5:55 the first of his Qur'anic proofs of Ali's imamate, claiming consensus that it was revealed about him when he gave his ring in charity while bowing in prayer, and taking wali in it to mean the one with authority. Ibn Taymiyya replied in Minhaj al-Sunna that the story is fabricated according to the hadith scholars,…How did revelation begin?
It began with true dreams for six months, then with the angel's coming to the cave of Hira in Ramadan, bringing the opening verses of Surat al-Alaq when the Prophet was forty years old; then a short pause, then the descent of the opening verses of al-Muddaththir, with the command to arise and warn, as presented in al-Raheeq al-Makhtum.How did Sunni scholars treat al-Kashshaf, given its Mu'tazili content?
Al-Zamakhshari's al-Kashshaf is a commentary of Mu'tazili creed whose author calls his school 'the people of justice and divine unity'; yet many Sunni scholars praised it for its rhetoric and mastery of ma'ani and bayan, wrote glosses on it, and Ibn al-Munayyir the Maliki answered its Mu'tazili content in al-Intisaf.How does Tafsir al-Jalalayn explain the verses on the divine attributes?
The two Jalals explain some attributes by what they entail — mercy as willing good for those who deserve it, the 'hand' in the verse of the pledge as God's knowledge of their pledge and His requital of it — and say of the rising over the Throne 'a rising befitting Him'. The reviser of the Maktabat al-Iman edition holds that the book contains departures in…How is 'He is God in the heavens and on earth' in Surat al-An'am understood?
In al-Tashil Ibn Juzayy gives three ways of attaching 'in the heavens and on earth' in the third verse of al-An'am: to the meaning of the name 'God', i.e. He is the God in both, which he calls preferable and more eloquent because the name 'God' gathers all the attributes; that He is in them by His knowledge, which the context about His awareness and…Does what al-Bukhari and Muslim agree on yield certainty of its soundness?
A question in the hadith sciences: Ibn al-Salah held that what the two Shaykhs agree on is certainly sound and yields reasoned certain knowledge, because the community received it with acceptance, and said he had first inclined to the opposite view; al-Nawawi answered that the verifiers and the majority hold it yields probability unless mass-transmitted, as…Is al-Suyuti's al-Itqan an abridgement of al-Zarkashi's al-Burhan?
Al-Suyuti says he thought himself the first to write a comprehensive book on the Qur'anic sciences until he heard of al-Burhan and sought it out, and that he arranged the types of al-Itqan better than al-Burhan; the editor of the Dar al-Hadith edition of al-Burhan holds that al-Suyuti abridged it; an Alexandria University MA thesis finds that he built most…Must a valid Qur'an reading be mass-transmitted (mutawatir)?
A question Ibn al-Jazari treats in al-Nashr when setting out the three pillars of a valid reading - agreement with Arabic in at least one way, agreement with one of the Uthmanic copies even potentially, and a sound chain; he notes that some later scholars required mass transmission in the third pillar rather than a sound chain, rejects this, says he once…Is the basmala a verse of al-Fatiha?
Al-Baydawi reports in Anwar al-Tanzil that the basmala is part of al-Fatiha for the readers and jurists of Mecca and Kufa, Ibn al-Mubarak and al-Shafi'i; that the readers and jurists of Medina, Basra and Syria, Malik and al-Awza'i disagreed; that Abu Hanifa said nothing explicit, so it was thought that for him it is not part of the sura; and that Muhammad…Is the order of the suras fixed by revelation or by the Companions' judgement?
In the introduction to his commentary al-Qurtubi reports two views on the order of the suras as they stand in the mushaf: that it may have been the Companions' own judgement, as the judge Abu Bakr ibn al-Tayyib said, while the order of verses within suras came from the Prophet; and that it was fixed by the Prophet, the view of Malik, Abu Bakr ibn al-Anbari…Has the prohibition of fighting in the sacred months been abrogated?
For a long time Muhammad al-Amin al-Shinqiti held that the prohibition of fighting in the sacred months had been abrogated and argued for it; later it became clear to him that the sounder view is that the prohibition remains and was not abrogated, and he declared his change of view in his commentary on Surat Bara'a. His biographer gives this as an example…Is the Uthmanic rasm tawqifi?
Khalid al-Sabt says some who made the Uthmanic rasm obligatory see it as laid down by the Prophet, though their proofs do not stand; he judges it more likely not to have been; Ibn Khaldun holds that the Companions wrote in their unperfected hands, so much of their spelling departs from the analogies of writing, and that explaining it by hidden meanings has…May one say 'my utterance of the Qur'an is created', or suspend judgement on its createdness?
After the inquisition over the createdness of the Qur'an two positions appeared that Ahmad ibn Hanbal, in reports from him, counted among the branches of the Jahmiyya: that of the 'Lafziyya', that the Qur'an is God's uncreated speech but our utterance and recitation of it are created – attributed to Husayn al-Karabisi – and that of the 'Waqifa', who say…May the mushaf be written in ordinary (imla'i) spelling?
Khalid al-Sabt sets out three views: the obligation to keep the Uthmanic rasm, the majority view and reported from Malik and Ahmad; that the rasm is conventional, not fixed by revelation, so departing from it is allowed, which he ascribes to Ibn Khaldun and al-Baqillani; and what is understood from al-Izz ibn Abd al-Salam, that it may be written for the…Must al-Fatiha be recited in every rak'a of the prayer?
In al-Jami' li-Ahkam al-Qur'an al-Qurtubi sets out the jurists' disagreement on al-Fatiha: Malik and his school require it of the imam and the one praying alone in every rak'a; al-Hasan al-Basri and most Basrans hold once in the prayer suffices; Abu Hanifa, al-Thawri and al-Awza'i allow other Qur'an in its place; al-Tabari requires an equal substitute;…Does the follower recite al-Fatiha behind the imam?
Al-Qurtubi sets out three Sunni positions on the follower's recitation: Malik's well-known view that he recites when the imam recites silently and not when he recites aloud; al-Shafi'i (as al-Buwayti reports) and Ahmad, that he recites al-Fatiha in every rak'a whether the imam is loud or silent; and Ibn Wahb, Ashhab, Ibn Abd al-Hakam, Ibn Habib and the…Was Abu 'Abd al-Rahman al-Sulami reliable in hadith?
His contemporary Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Qattan accused him of being unreliable and of fabricating hadith for the Sufis; al-Khatib al-Baghdadi answered that his standing among his townsmen was great and that he was a careful hadith scholar, Ibn al-Subki endorsed al-Khatib, and al-Dhahabi said he was not strong in hadith — the views as the editor of Tabaqat…Is narration from people of innovation accepted?
A question in the criticism of transmitters: if a transmitter is truthful and retentive but holds an innovation in belief, such as Shi'ism, the Qadari view or the view of the Kharijites, is he narrated from? In the introduction to Mizan al-I'tidal al-Dhahabi reports from Ibn Sirin that after the civil strife the early scholars took the hadith of the people…How should al-Hakim's authentications in the Mustadrak be treated?
Al-Hakim presented the Mustadrak as hadiths with chains of the kind the two masters relied on; later hadith critics agreed that he was lax in authentication but differed on how far, and on what to do with hadiths only he declared sound: Ibn al-Salah took a middle course, al-Dhahabi estimated proportions, Ibn Hajar divided the book into classes, and Ibn…Is leniency allowed in the chains of reports on virtuous deeds?
A question of transmission: must reports of encouragement, admonition and virtuous deeds meet the same standard of trustworthy transmitters as reports on the lawful and unlawful? Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi gives it a chapter in al-Kifaya, 'strictness in legal hadith and leniency in virtuous deeds', quoting Sufyan al-Thawri, Ibn Uyayna, Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Abu…Was Ibn Hibban lax in authenticating hadith?
Ibn al-Salah said that Ibn Hibban's Sahih comes close to the Mustadrak in standing, which some took to mean equally lax; al-'Iraqi explained it as less lax than al-Hakim, and al-Hazimi and Ibn Kathir agreed that it is firmer and cleaner in chains; Ibn Hajar disputed the charge of laxity except insofar as he counted hasan hadith as sound and set a light…May a later scholar declare a hadith sound that the earlier imams did not?
A question in the hadith sciences raised by Ibn al-Salah: when a hadith with a sound-looking chain turns up in the hadith booklets, not in the two Sahihs and not declared sound by any recognised imam, may one affirm that it is sound? Ibn al-Salah held that one may not, since independent recognition of the sound had become impracticable in his age; al-Nawawi…Was al-Bazzar reliable?
Hadith critics differed over al-Hafiz Abu Bakr al-Bazzar (d. 292 AH): al-Khatib al-Baghdadi, Abu al-Shaykh, al-Sam'ani and others called him trustworthy and praised his memory, while al-Daraqutni reported that he erred in chains and texts because he related the Musnad in Egypt from memory, and that al-Nasa'i criticised him; elsewhere al-Daraqutni called him…Does Ibn Atiyya's commentary lean towards the Mu'tazila?
Al-Muharrar al-Wajiz has been charged with Mu'tazili leanings: Ibn Taymiyya held it closer to the Sunna than al-Kashshaf but following those it calls 'the verifiers', theologians of the kalam schools; Ibn Arafa the Maliki, as quoted by Ibn Hajar al-Haytami, held it more dangerous than al-Kashshaf because it slips Mu'tazilism in; Abd al-Wahhab Fayid rejects…What are angels?
The angels are servants of God made of light who carry out His commands. They include Jibril, charged with revelation; Mika'il, charged with provision; Israfil, charged with the trumpet; the Angel of Death; and the guardians of the Fire and of Paradise.What are the jinn?
The jinn are a hidden world of God's rational creatures who bear religious obligation. They mingle with humans, and some believe while others disbelieve. Surat al-Jinn reports their acceptance of Islam.What do the separated letters at the opening of suras mean?
In Zad al-Masir Ibn al-Jawzi gathers six views on the separated letters: that they are among the ambiguous known only to God; letters of God's names; letters by which God swears; a pointer that the Qur'an is made of the very letters of the Arabs' speech, to show its inimitability; names of the suras; or the shorthand the Arabs used in speech — all Sunni…What is the barzakh?
The barzakh is the barrier between this world and the Hereafter: life in the grave after death, in which the dead person is questioned about his Lord, his Prophet and his religion, according to Ahl al-Sunna.What is a fatwa?
A fatwa is a statement of the sharia ruling on a particular case, issued by a qualified mufti. Unlike a judicial ruling, it does not bind by itself; it binds those who choose to follow it.What is ghiba?
Backbiting (ghiba) is speaking of your brother in his absence in a way he would dislike. Scholars count it among the major sins, and the Qur'an likened it to eating the flesh of the dead.What is the hijab?
Hijab is a Muslim woman's covering of her adornment from those who are not her mahram (unmarriageable kin). According to the majority of scholars it is one of the obligations of dress, and its forms vary across cultures.What is ijma?
Ijma is the agreement of the community's qualified scholars on a legal ruling. It is the third source of jurisprudence according to the majority of jurists, and its proof is prophetic reports about the community being preserved from error.What is ijtihad?
Ijtihad is the exertion of effort to derive a ruling from the sources. The restricted form belongs to the jurist-mufti who issues fatwas; the unrestricted form belongs to one who reaches the rank of competence for legal derivation.What is ikhlas?
Ikhlas is purifying one's intention for God alone, without showing off. It is a condition for the acceptance of deeds and their foundation. Surat al-Ikhlas is said to equal a third of the Qur'an in merit.What is Jahannam?
Jahannam is the fire of the Hereafter and God's punishment for disbelievers and wrongdoers. The Qur'an describes it with its levels, chains and boiling water, and with punishment that is eternal, or limited for the people of grave sins.What is Jannah?
Jannah is the everlasting abode of bliss for believers. The Qur'an describes its rivers, its palaces and a bliss no eye has seen, and its highest level is al-Firdaws.What is jihad?
Jihad is the exertion of effort in seeking God's pleasure. The books of jurisprudence give it graded meanings, from the struggle against the self to the struggle by hand and fighting in the way of God.What is meant by the seven ahruf?
Scholars differed over the meaning of 'the Qur'an was revealed in seven ahruf' until the number of views reached thirty-five in Ibn Hibban and forty in others; among the best known are seven kinds of variation in reading, seven synonymous wordings for one meaning, seven dialects of the Arabs, seven kinds of content, the number as a figure of plenty, and the…What is nikah?
Nikah is the valid legal contract of marriage in Islam. According to the majority of schools, its pillars are offer, acceptance, the guardian (wali) and the witnesses.What is riya?
Riya is seeking reputation and standing through worship. Scholars regard it as a hidden form of shirk, a blight that nullifies good deeds.What is sabr?
Sabr is restraining the self from distress and the tongue from complaint; according to the majority it is half of faith, and its fruit is reward without reckoning.What are sanad and isnad?
A sanad is the chain of narrators of a hadith back to the Prophet. With it Muslims built the science of verifying transmitted reports, which is unique in the history of human transmission.What is tafsir?
Tafsir is the disclosure of the meanings of the Quran, its occasions of revelation and its rulings. Its written heritage runs from al-Tabari, al-Zamakhshari, al-Razi and Ibn Kathir to the modern age.What is talaq?
Talaq is the dissolution of the marriage contract by a specific formula. In a hadith it is the most disliked of lawful things to God, and according to the jurists it carries rules on the waiting period, return and khul'.What is tawakkul?
Tawakkul is the heart's reliance on God together with taking the means. Its way is 'tie it and then rely', so it is worship and not the abandonment of effort.What was al-Andalus?
Al-Andalus is the Iberian Peninsula under Islamic rule, 711-1492; centuries of civilization in Cordoba, Granada and Toledo that ended with the fall of Granada.What was the Islamic Golden Age?
The Golden Age: centuries of scientific flourishing, from Abbasid Baghdad to al-Andalus and Fatimid Egypt; in it the heritage was translated and scholars produced work in medicine, astronomy and mathematics.What was the last part of the Qur'an to be revealed?
In Zad al-Masir Ibn al-Jawzi gathers the reports on the last revelation: from Ibn Abbas, in a report only al-Bukhari has, the verse of usury, and in one only Muslim has, that the last sura revealed whole was al-Nasr; through al-Dahhak from him, the verse of al-Baqara on the Day of return, held also by Sa'id ibn Jubayr and Abu Salih; from al-Bara', the verse…What was the Mongol invasion?
The Mongol invasion: the campaigns of Genghis Khan and his descendants against the Muslim world, 1219-1260; Baghdad was destroyed in 1258, and the Muslims halted the invasion at Ayn Jalut in 1260.What was the Ottoman Empire?
The Ottoman Empire was a Turkish Islamic sultanate that lasted six centuries, 1299–1922; it peaked with the conquest of Constantinople in 1453 and the reign of Suleiman the Lawgiver.What were the Crusades?
The Crusades were Latin military campaigns against Syria and Jerusalem. They began with the fall of Antioch in 1097–1098 and of Jerusalem in 1099, and ended with the expulsion of the Crusaders from the East (Hasan Ibrahim Hasan, pp. 238, 243).Where was Surat al-Fatiha revealed: in Mecca or in Medina?
Commentators differ on where al-Fatiha was revealed, with three views: Meccan, Medinan, or revealed twice. The preferred view among careful scholars, Tantawi says, is that it is Meccan and among the earliest revelations; al-Shawkani lists the reports each view relied on.Where was the Garden in which Adam was settled?
In his commentary on the verse of al-Baqara about Adam being settled in the Garden, al-Razi sets out four views: a garden on earth, held by Abu al-Qasim al-Balkhi and Abu Muslim al-Isfahani with six arguments; a garden in the seventh heaven, held by al-Jubba'i; the abode of reward itself, held by most of his own school; and suspending judgement, since all…Who first pointed and vowelled the codex of the Qur'an?
In the introduction to al-Muharrar al-Wajiz Ibn Atiyya says the codex was at first neither vowelled nor dotted, then reports three accounts of who first dotted it: that Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan ordered it and al-Hajjaj undertook it at Wasit with al-Hasan and Yahya ibn Ya'mar; that the first was Abu al-Aswad al-Du'ali, at Ziyad's order; and that the first was…Who lived on earth before Adam?
The angels' question in al-Baqara 30 about placing one who will corrupt and shed blood opened three lines among the exegetes: that the jinn lived on earth before Adam and corrupted it; that the angels knew because God told them or reasoned from the meaning of vicegerency; and that the text says nothing about anything before Adam. Al-Tabari did not adopt the…Who seals the hearts in al-Baqara 7? Al-Zamakhshari and Ibn al-Munayyir
Al-Zamakhshari, on the Mu'tazili view, holds that the sealing of hearts is figurative, and that ascribing it to God either signals how entrenched the trait is or ascribes the act to its enabler, the real sealer being Satan or the disbeliever — so as to keep God clear of doing what is evil; Ibn al-Munayyir answers, on the Sunni view, that refusing the truth…Who was Harun al-Rashid?
Harun al-Rashid (763–809) was the fifth Abbasid caliph; the state reached the height of its power in his time, and its renown is linked to the stories of One Thousand and One Nights.Why did al-Zuhri write hadith down?
Ibn Sa'd relates from Ma'mar that al-Zuhri said: 'We used to dislike writing down knowledge until these rulers compelled us to it; then we decided not to withhold it from any Muslim.' He also relates from Salih ibn Kaysan that he and al-Zuhri wrote down the sunan; al-Zuhri then wrote down what came from the Companions too and Salih did not — 'he succeeded…Why does Surat al-Tawba not open with the basmala?
Surat al-Tawba (Bara'a) is the only sura of the mushaf at whose head the basmala is not written. Al-Qurtubi summarises five explanations and then holds that it was not written because Gabriel did not bring it down; Tantawi adopts that view and judges the five explanations weak.
What is missing? Tell us · A theme is open when it has a reviewed guide, 10 questions, 25 entries across 5 classes, and voices from several traditions and regions.